3 ms·
> In low-social-trust situations, people aren't a good option. Bockchains provide an entirely new and welcome option for that scenario. We've been handling the
by arcticbull 6y ago
> In low-social-trust situations, people aren't a good option. Bockchains provide an entirely new and welcome option for that scenario.
We've been handling these set-ups very well for millennia. You find a trusted intermediary. These days, for better or worse, globalization has created more and more of them.
- cortesoft 6y agoThere is even a word for it: escrow
- arcticbull 6y agoIndeed, the process is quite simple. You want to do business with Steve, but you don't trust Steve. Cool. Do you and Steve mutually trust someone? Awesome, you've found an escrow. If you can't find someone who trusts both you and Steve, that's a great sign you shouldn't do business with Steve. No amount of magic Blockchain pixie dust is going to change that there are bad actors out there.
- naveen99 6y agoIt’s more for when you already trust Steve, but you don’t trust your national currency, the credit card companies, and other available “escrows”. Why force use of an escrow when you trust your counterparty ?
- arcticbull 6y ago> Why force use of an escrow when you trust your counterparty ? Why use a trustless payment method when you trust your counterparty and waste a month's worth of electricity?
- naveen99 6y agoBecause my counterparty may not be able to spend my IOU elsewhere.
- arcticbull 6y agoThis situation feels pretty contrived, do you have a concrete example, especially one which you've seen personally or been personally involved with?
- naveen99 6y agonot personally. but imagine you are the king of island A, and want to engage in a transaction with king of island B. Or you want to split up your estate amongst your children.
- arcticbull 6y agoI get that, but I firmly believe that solutions, certainly ones as highly touted here, should operated in the problem domain. We've yet to identify, in 11 years, a concrete problem that blockchains are better at solving than any other solution.
- 9nGQluzmnq3M 6y agoBut what if your business is ransomware or selling narcotics, and it's hard to find a trusted intermediary?
- arcticbull 6y agoFor everything else, there's wire transfers MasterCard jingle plays.
- AbrahamParangi 6y agoThose intermediaries can be moderately to very expensive. Look at how much value credit-card interchange skims. Blockchains offer a technological solution to a social problem- and threaten many "trusted brokers" with replacement with near-zero marginal cost software.
- arcticbull 6y agoThe fact that a single Bitcoin transaction requires 561kWh of power (enough to power an average US household for 19 days) -- and produces 94g of e-waste -- means that classical intermediaries are a lot less expensive in the majority of cases. [1] Using the world average of $0.14/kWh means that a Bitcoin payment costs (or rather extracts in welfare) $79. This fee is socialized across all users in the form of block rewards, and as they diminish, end-users will have to bear the whole cost or the hash rate will drop off precipitously eliminating the security guarantees. This is on top of the $3.392 fee for processing the transaction on-chain. At a break-even of $82.39 per BTC payment, a credit card transaction would have to be at least $27,500 in Europe (based on their 0.3% interchange cap) and $4,551 in the US (based on the average interchange rate of 1.81%). ACH payments cost banks $0.11 US. Trusted brokers aren't going anywhere, and IMO, there's no such thing as a technological solution to a social problem. [1] https://digiconomist.net/bitcoin-energy-consumption/ https://digiconomist.net/bitcoin-energy-consumption/
- AbrahamParangi 6y agoThese things are true at present but are they true in the limit? Bitcoin is the first blockchain technology to see adoption and has a present market cap of over $200B despite scaling incredibly poorly. Trusted brokers won't disappear but there's a big difference between being the only game in town and filling a niche in an ecosystem. Technology makes social solutions irrelevant all the time. How many interactions intermediated by people no longer exist because they are now intermediated by software and platforms?
- arcticbull 6y agoWe've had 11 years of innovation in blockchain technology and so far, nothing has improved on the status quo. 11 years ago was right around when the first iPhone came out, for reference. In my opinion, that's because you can't solve trust with magic pixie dust. No matter what, trust represents a huge optimization. That means anything you try and do to reduce trust will introduce massive quantities of friction. Trust is good and should be embraced. If something better comes along, great, but I've seen no evidence in the last 11 years that would indicate anything's at risk of coming down the pike. I've got no interest in championing a technology that hasn't budged a single iota (heh) in 11 years. If it does, I'll eat my... well. You get the joke. [edit] note that market cap doesn't mean anything for a currency. There's no market cap of US dollars, because dollars have a fixed value relative to dollars. If I exchange my dollar for a dollar, the market cap of dollars is equal to the number of dollars in circulation. End of story. You value other things relative to currency to obtain their market cap. The market cap of BTC is 21MM BTC. Less, given the huge quantities that go missing all the time.
- sneak 6y agoThose trusted intermediaries require a lot of identity information, usually by law. It’s nice to be able to transact privately sometimes.
- sthnblllII 6y agoIran and Venezuela would disagree, or any country the US government has banned from the international banking network. The fact that one country can unilaterally block bank transfers between third parties solidifies the need for non-politically centralized banking.
- arcticbull 6y agoBecause allowing the transfers enriched those in power, helping keep the leadership in place and the people down. For the record this is something you can vote on and change, because it’s a group decision. Unlike all those poor scammers who keep getting blacklisted from exchanges and such. Secondarily, crypto is no panacea here. You can’t solve the initial distribution problem. How do you decide which individual gets how many coins to start? If you ignore that issue, and if you can only trade within the country the total amount of crypto and the total amount of local currency remains the same meaning the total net welfare has not improved. If you can trade outside the country a myriad better options exist. Crypto doesn’t help here either, it just purports to through magic of the blockchain. What’s necessary isn’t magic beans that live in computers but for the locals to rise up and overthrow their local governments and institute proper monetary and fiscal policy. Concrete example: why don’t people use bitcoin in Venezuela (separate from the fact a single transaction costs a few weeks wages)? It’s been 11 years and were still waiting like skeletons for op to deliver. How did the Petro change the situation there?
- lifty 6y agoPeople actually use Bitcoin in Venezuela [0], not en mass, but still, it provides some very useful escape hatches for a part of the population. 0. https://www.bbc.com/news/business-47553048 https://www.bbc.com/news/business-47553048
- arcticbull 6y agoPart of the population solves none of the problem, as I outlined. The monthly minimum wage is 1 bitcoin transaction fee. It's only the wealthy that can afford to use it in the first place. It's doing nothing to increase the total welfare of the system. I never disputed that a select few couldn't benefit from it, it's not a good general solution, though.