4 ms·
You are being way too favorable to the author. The ad hominem is that they dismiss a bunch of positions as ‘bullshit’ based on their own (true) claim to experi
by zepto 6y ago
You are being way too favorable to the author.
The ad hominem is that they dismiss a bunch of positions as ‘bullshit’ based on their own (true) claim to experience, and the assertion that the people making these claims don’t have the experience. I.e. ‘if you don’t see things as clearly as the author, you are just a commenter with no experience’.
Any favorable reading of the author’s position is based on believing they are sincere and correct about Epic lying about what they want.
There is no favorable reading where one of these conditions is not met.
If the author is not being sincere, the piece is disingenuous.
If Epic is not lying, the piece is delusional and self-contradictory.
But this central conceit is not justified at all by any reasoning. The consequences of it being true are not explored.
The fact is that Epic’s positioning doesn’t allow for Apple to settle in this way.
There is no way for them to do so without entering into an illegal cartel with Epic.
The fact that they are honest about Epic’s flaws is very positive but it doesn’t change the overall positioning of the article. Epic is not ‘destroyed’ at all. That is a misrepresentation. They simply aren’t held out to be a saint.
I can make a statement like “Apple has engaged in egregious corporate behavior and was guilty fo conspiring to hold down developer wages, so why should we think they aren’t doing this on a grand scale with the App Store?”
This is a true statement followed by a valid question. It’s also innuendo. But more importantly, the fact I’m willing to make it does nothing to change the rest of the arguments I’m making here. Do you suddenly think I’m being fair? I wouldn’t imagine so.
The positioning of the author is that much reasoning about this is ‘bullshit’, or the work of people who don’t have enough experience.
If the piece were a HN comment in response to another commenter, it would be against the guidelines.
It’s a bad piece. It doesn’t make any real arguments, rather it seeks to defeat arguments with innuendo.
I agree with you about the value of the opinions in the piece, and that it’s good to have them shared, but that doesn’t take away from the overall criticism.
A bad or disingenuous argument can include many important and valuable points, and still be bad.
- totooto 6y agoYou are describing yourself without realising it.