3 ms·
We've been there, done that: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=625255 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=625255 Anything that isn't spam shouldn't be "banne
by petercooper 16y ago
We've been there, done that: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=625255 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=625255
Anything that isn't spam shouldn't be "banned". It's all down to what people vote up. If people are voting up TechCrunch stories as opposed to flagging them, that's your poll result right there in real life action rather than indignant votes.
- rgarcia 16y agoGood point. Although I would say that TC from two years ago is a lot different than TC today. I guess I submitted this in the same spirit as pg's ominous "How to prevent the decline of HN" post earlier this week. Maybe drastic times call for drastic measures?
- petercooper 16y agoPerhaps, but let's say this poll gets 500 votes "for" blocking TechCrunch and 300 against. What would that tell us? That there's a legion of TechCrunch fans/upvoters whose opinion matters less than a legion of TechCrunch detractors? If so, is dismissing the opinion of people who actively vote up stories on HN a way to prevent the "decline"? I don't have an answer to these questions but if it comes down to blocking Web sites that are relevant to HN's gamut of topics, the answers could be important.
- ericd 16y agoWe shouldn't avoid paring stuff out to avoid the possibility of missing something. There's way too much news out there to take that approach, and the really big stuff generally gets posted multiple places. Part of the problem is that HN's "gamut of topics", as you put it, has gotten too wide. There are lots of general tech news sites out there, this shouldn't be another. This is a narrowly focused community.
- Hawramani 16y agoThere are two ways to think about this. First, there is a saying, "The state of a nation will never be better than the sum of the state of each one of its individuals." If the awareness of the people on HN is not enough to automatically cause content like TechCrunch to be excluded, maybe we deserve to see such content until we work to increase awareness. Second, maybe it is non-core or new users of HN who vote up TechCrunch articles. Maybe we should take into consideration the opinion of the people who really care about HN and who know the business (and TechCrunch) better than the rest, and if they say the community will benefit if TechCrunch is banned then it should be.
- petercooper 16y agoPoint 1 - agreed. To counter this, regulars need to spend more time in /newest setting a good example with their votes. I subscribe to the "HN firehose" on Twitter for this reason. It's amazing, though, how much good stuff gets stuff in the low single digits because people just don't happen to be looking there. Point 2 - sure, but that introduces a layer of authority that is, at present, well hidden and rarely engaged. Perhaps instead of the deus ex machina solution of arbitrarily coming up with policies or bans, the voting system should be improved. I'd suggest that there's enough of a userbase here nowadays to stop, say, people with under X karma or Y days of HN membership from voting without causing a negative impact. This sort of algorithmic solution appeals to me more than potentially erroneous and biased decision making by committee any day.
- Hawramani 16y agoGreat suggestion! I wholeheartedly agree with what you said, it is vastly superior to my second solution.
- teyc 16y agoWhile the site guidelines (see below) classifies general news as off-topic, I believe tech news sites like TC needs a higher level of votes before showing up on the front page. -- On-Topic: Anything that good hackers would find interesting. That includes more than hacking and startups. If you had to reduce it to a sentence, the answer might be: anything that gratifies one's intellectual curiosity. Off-Topic: Most stories about politics, or crime, or sports, unless they're evidence of some interesting new phenomenon. Videos of pratfalls or disasters, or cute animal pictures. If they'd cover it on TV news, it's probably off-topic