5 ms·
I read the whole article. NYC nor any other major city will die from this. 10,000 people want to leave NYC on a Facebook group? NYC has what, 8 million people
by dangus 6y ago
I read the whole article.
NYC nor any other major city will die from this.
10,000 people want to leave NYC on a Facebook group? NYC has what, 8 million people?
Half the article is talking about the kind of fears that watching the local news will get you. You think Phoenix doesn’t have any homeless people? You think people don’t get shot occasionally in Phoenix? New York City is literally statistically safer for murder per capita than many of these smaller cities.
I think the author over-emphasizes how much bandwidth will keep all work remote, too. Sure, it’ll work for some tech jobs, but the narrative that productivity has increased across the board is not backed up by convincing numbers. Only about half the country works a “desk job” from my understanding.
I know for me, personally, as soon as it’s safe to go back to the office, I’m doing it. I’m tired of subsidizing my employer’s need for real estate. I want my kitchen table back. But I know that’s a personal anecdote.
The 1918 pandemic didn’t mean that NYC died and I don’t see how this one is very different.
Mark my words, we won’t be talking about COVID-19 in 2025.
- alexktz 6y ago> I read the whole article. But we only the read the titles and react around here. /s I agree with your sentiments overall. The whole thrust of the article feels anecdotal. We will feel some acceleration of remote working trends over the next decade+ as a direct result of covid but it's not going to happen overnight.
- Waterluvian 6y agoYep. I really didn’t see any convincing arguments whatsoever. The thing about large cities is that their trends move slowly. It isn’t evacuated in a year. Meaning there’s time for economics to self correct. If there’s any sort of exodus, prices will fall and people will move in.
- thu2111 6y agoBut that didn't happen with Detroit.
- dahfizz 6y ago> New York City is literally statistically safer for murder per capita than many of these smaller cities. This little trick is a pet peeve of mine. Per capita crime statistics mean nothing to the people living in a city. It doesn't matter that each person you run into each day is slightly less likely to be a criminal if you run into 100x more people in NYC than in a small suburb. What matters is the question "how likely am I to be the victim of a crime?". The answer is: a lot more likely in NYC than a small city.
- quicklime 6y agoDoesn't "murders per capita" answer that question? It's "murder victims per capita", not "murderers per capita", so it doesn't matter if you run into 100x more people in NYC.
- ponker 6y agoAnd even if it was murderers per capita, it would require the assumption that each murderer is murdering a constant percentage, regardless of location, of the people that he sees.
- jcranmer 6y agoThe more I think about it, the less sense your argument makes. Property crimes like burglary and arson are committed against your property, and so the natural denominator is per household size. As long as household size is pretty invariable among cities, then per capita is going to correlate quite highly with household size. How about crimes like murders? Most murders are people killing someone they know. Your social circle is limited more by human capabilities, so it's not going to increase just because you live in a denser city. So again, your likelihood of being murdered will correlate with murders per capita. Another take on the statistics: if your argument is that you are more likely to run into the number of criminals because of a higher density of interactions, then consequently the number of crimes per criminal should also go up. I don't have any hard numbers on these statistics, but I would be extremely shocked if they bore you out here. A final comment is that actual crime statistics is measured by the number of crimes committed per residents living there. There is actually some bias here: some of the highest numbers here are measured in places like Times Square which combines extremely high tourist traffic (and hence high pickpocket rates) with extremely low residential numbers. But if you talk about entire city-level rates, those effects are going to be muted. If you again assume that the number of victims of a single crime is constant, then the number of crimes committed per population, and that the victim of a crime is chosen uniformly at random, then the crime rate per capita is pretty much the inverse of the likelihood of being a victim of a crime.