4 ms·
From reading the proof, it seems the authors are mainly focused on “linking” or showing correlation, not causation. Part of me wonders about the directionality
by alextheparrot 6y ago
From reading the proof, it seems the authors are mainly focused on “linking” or showing correlation, not causation.
Part of me wonders about the directionality of causation here (If we assumed one existed). One could argue the hippocampus, which from my recollection is involved in inhibiting impulsive behavior, has a clear path to being a causative agent for obesity. Distinguishing between the two narratives of “Being overweight inhibits brain function” versus “Differences in part of brain controlling impulses leads to weight differences” is important to resolving it, as it is easier to imagine treatment regimens to combat weight more than brain blood flow.
It is also completely possible these two variables do not affect each other, but are correlated. That’s useful still, because it means we may be able to use body weight increases as an inferred marker for the brain changes.
It would be incredibly interesting if the story of Alzheimer’s transformed more into “Same factor may be causing both America’s obesity increases as well as Alzheimer’s cases”
Edit: Updated this a few times while reading the original paper
- CyberDildonics 6y agoOr maybe fructose intake and absorption correlates to both obesity and cognitive function.
- alextheparrot 6y agoI fell into the same over-reaching trap I was critiquing, which is a bit funny, but I agree they could be caused by the same thing and correlated because of that as well.
- bawana 6y agoAbsolutely. The whole constellation of diminished brain function and obesity brings to mind a hibernation switch that is getting turned on. Perhaps further research will elucidate the biochemical pathway that is active in these patients and allow us to put people into ‘suspended animation’ for long space voyages. “ You have to eat 2 lbs of spaghetti and a gallon of ice cream a day for a month before going to mars in your sleep couch”