3 ms·
This is an interesting bill to me. On one hand, I hate the idea of these wiretaps, and think they're one of a number of reasons for which Bush should be impeach
by mattmaroon 18y ago
This is an interesting bill to me. On one hand, I hate the idea of these wiretaps, and think they're one of a number of reasons for which Bush should be impeached.
On the other hand, I think the phone companies need to be exonerated. Corporations can't be expected to pick and choose when they cooperate with the government, and they should never be penalized for doing so. We don't want to create a system in which companies can be held liable for that. It will hinder legitimate law enforcement, and create insurmountable legal bills for small businesses asked to cooperate with government investigations.
- Alex3917 18y ago"It will hinder legitimate law enforcement, and create insurmountable legal bills for small businesses asked to cooperate with government investigations." Your argument is flawed because the telecoms weren't obligated to fight the government's attempts to receive a warrant, but rather to inspect the warrant before giving the government wiretapping ability.
- mattmaroon 18y agoPerhaps, I don't know that much about it. The overall problem though is with legal precedent, as I feel it puts businesses in a no-win situation. What if you're a small business owner, say of a video rental store, and the White House asks you for records? Your options are: 1. Comply 2. Start spending serious money on legal advice. Suppose your lawyer says not to do it without a warrant (which he probably would.) Then what? You risk fighting the White House in court? You could suck up a lifetime of a video store's revenue doing this. You'd probably waste a couple weeks of profit just to pay the retainer to get that advice in the first place. You, a small business owner, the keystone of our economy, with a family to feed and kids to put through college, should have to pay a significant amount of money to help police our government? Even for a large telecom that can afford the legal bills, they're putting shareholder money at risk to fight an ethical battle by refusing to meet the White House's demands. They might be risking shareholder lawsuits for that. Either way, they're screwed. The way I see it, we as a society have two reasonable options. 1) This sort of oversight should come from the government itself, or at least somehow be publicly funded. or 2) Corporations should never be penalized for following a government issued order. Of course, if it turns out that order was illegal (as in the case of this wiretapping) the government agencies and employees involved should be the ones held at fault. Not the business that merely complied with the government.
- chaostheory 18y agothere's 1 problem with your argument. these weren't small businesses. they were telecoms with hundreds of millions of dollars with nice big legal departments
- mattmaroon 18y agoThat doesn't matter. There's no corporate size limit at which you no longer have to comply with government orders. In fact, the fact that they're publicly traded means they're exposed to shareholder lawsuits if the shareholders decide that the people in charge aren't doing their duty to represent them. Especially by, say, wasting a bunch of money on legal bills to fight the government. I just can't envision running a corporation in a world in which you could be penalized for complying with the government. What Sarb-Ox has done to publicly traded companies, this would do 10x to all of them.
- Alex3917 18y agoMounting a legal defense wouldn't cost the business owner any money; in fact, they wouldn't even need a lawyer. If anyone sued them they could go to court and lose instantly and be in the clear legally. But instead they acted without being compelled to by a court. That's what makes their actions illegal and that's why they deserve to be in jail.
- mattmaroon 18y agoThat makes so little sense that I hope you mis-worded it. You're not thinking from the perspective of a business owner. I've been taken to court before, and when facing that situation you don't think "well, I'll go represent myself and lose, and then I'll be in the clear legally." That makes no sense. Your thought process is more like "fuck, I better find a good lawyer." Being taken to court is serious stuff. And I've never been taken to court by the government. That's really serious stuff.
- Alex3917 18y agoI am thinking from the perspective of the business owner. Let's say the government asks me to wiretap for them. I say no because it would be illegal, but if it weren't illegal then I would gladly do it (as an evil telecom). So the government then goes to court to compel me to do it. I go to court and put up no defense and I lose. Now because the government has a court order mandating that I allow them to wiretap, if I do allow them to wiretap then I cannot be held accountable. I don't see what is so misguided about this.
- gills 18y agoThe Bill of Rights does not secure the right to earn a profit. Every one of these corporations had a choice between doing the right thing and doing the easy thing. A true patriot would fold the business before allowing it to be used to infringe upon the rights of citizens. We can blame Bush and we can blame Congress, but first we should blame ourselves for letting it go this far.
- mattmaroon 18y agoFolding the business because you think a government order is unethical would land you in jail. When you run a publicly traded company, you have a legal responsibility to represent your shareholders' financial interest. If you want to be technical, the Bill of Rights does not secure the right to use a phone without the government knowing who you call. In fact, it doesn't even secure the right to privacy. It kind of flirts with the issue, but it's a common misconception that it guarantees it. Maybe I'm biased because I think patriotism is stupid (as Shaw said "Patriotism is your conviction that this country is superior to all other countries because you were born in it.") but if captains of industry folded their corporations every time they perceived an ethical violation we'd have no stock market left.
- yelsgib 18y agoNo, let's blame our parents for raising us to be this way! No, let's blame THEIR parents. I blame you.
- jksmith 18y agoWhat if the Administration asked a company to go kill somebody in the name of fighting terrorism, somebody gets killed, but the company is exonerated? These American companies (incl ATT) had every right to refuse to support this, and could have chosen to do so, just as Qwest did. But ATT chose to cooperate, just because the Admin asked them to. So now we cut them a break by not allowing a lawsuit by American citizens to be filed? That's the problem with all this stuff. The government compromises everything it touches to the point that bailouts overrule justice. All this debacle will repeat itself, and next time it will be a little bit worse, and the circumstances get a little bit more ridiculous. But we American citizens will keep adjusting to it, because we become a little bit more compromised along the way. This is wrong, and should be treated as such no matter what the consequences to any company.
- mattmaroon 18y agoIt's not the corporations' responsibility to police our government, it's ours. We should be impeaching Bush and various members of his administration undoubtedly for issuing the requests. But you just cannot have an orderly society in which corporations are expected to pick and choose which laws and governmental agency requests they are going to follow and which they are not.
- jamesbritt 18y ago"But you just cannot have an orderly society in which corporations are expected to pick and choose which laws and governmental agency requests they are going to follow and which they are not." Court orders and subpoenas. No need for arbitrary picking and choosing. And, really, in the end, I would hope that something was learned from Nuremberg.