4 ms·
Isn't that kinda like saying that the electric companies do the same thing, though?
by andai 6y ago
Isn't that kinda like saying that the electric companies do the same thing, though?
- alangibson 6y agoThey kind of do, which is why alot of big tech should be highly regulated like utilities.
- Spivak 6y agoI feel like saying that AWS should be regulated like a utility because lots of businesses use their products is a little sill. They have heavy competition in basically all of their markets, their moat is their breadth of services and they’re constantly at risk of being unbundled by a competitor that has more time to devote to a single product segment. They have persistent natural competition with colo-ing that keeps their prices from straying too far from commodity hardware and an ops person. Like if you’re looking to regulate a market this seems like one of the last you’d peg as not being healthy.
- huffmsa 6y agoThere are tons of niche hosts that have sprung up recently, a lot for developing and serving AI/ML applications. Amazon was there first, but it's getting cheaper by the day to buy a bunch of hardware, stick it in an increasingly cheaply electrified building, run a bunch of fiber to it and slap some virtualization software on it.
- alangibson 6y agoAWS wouldn't be my first choice to regulate, but at this point they can turn any competing business into a feature of AWS without breaking a sweat. I know for sure this stifles innovation because I've watched people abandon promising ideas because of that fact.
- leetrout 6y agoI’m under the impression there is more regulation because they are a utility company.
- jfoster 6y agoAWS has varying degrees of vendor lock-in, which electricity companies generally don't have.
- jstanley 6y agoElectric companies can switch off your electricity, and not much else. Amazon can read your secrets.
- speedgoose 6y agoI know that in practice nobody at AWS reads customer secrets and if someone does, it will be logged somewhere but I always find it funny that you can encrypt things in AWS with secrets fully managed by AWS. It's just a checkbox to check the box for encryption in technical requirements but it doesn't really matter if you really care about privacy when the keys are stored in a very safe box accessible by AWS and the USA state (patriot act).
- oarsinsync 6y ago> I know that in practice nobody at AWS reads customer secrets and if someone does, it will be logged somewhere Can you share how you know this to be true? I certainly hope it's true, but I have no way of knowing myself.
- speedgoose 6y agoI actually don't know, you are right. I have some trust in AWS but I would never put a real secret in AWS in clear text.
- mrweasel 6y agoTrue, that’s why in some markets the electric companies have been split into transmission companies and delivery companies. You buy power from the delivery company and the transmission companies are paid to maintain power lines.
- jefftk 6y agoThat's effectively how it already is though: there's one market for connectivity, and a separate market for cloud computing. If you don't want to build on Amazon's cloud, you can build on Azure, GCP, or one of the smaller competitors.
- PaulHoule 6y agoIsn't that a scam from Enron that we are still living with? In New York we have almost as many ESCOs as there are shady looking prepaid phone cards. Maybe they save you 0.001% over the real electric company if you cash the check for 78 cents they send you every six months. I thought the point of that was financial engineering. Used to be if you wanted to shut down a coal burning power plant the power company would be sued by creditors. Now the creditors can sue a shell company with no assets and get nothing. It is good that coal burning power plants are being shut down, but rather than having an engineering or environmental based plan they do it this way. There will be plenty of money for solar roofs if they government is paying but private money will not be there for other investments if it doesn't have to be paid back.
- geitir 6y agoYes but that's why they're classified as a utility