4 ms·
It looks quite neutral for me, perhaps because I'm from Argentina and we don't have any skin in this game. (We have our land and maritime border conflict too. I
by gus_massa 6y ago
It looks quite neutral for me, perhaps because I'm from Argentina and we don't have any skin in this game. (We have our land and maritime border conflict too. It's a sensitive topic in all the countries. [1])
The article helped me to understand the recent problem. My fast and possible inaccurate takeaway is:
The land shore of Turkey has a lot of nearby Greek islands. If there is oil nearby, that will surely cause a problem.
[1] Let's pick and easy one, the land frontier of Argentina and Chile. The Andes mountain range is in between. One method to select the border is to pick the highest mountains, other method is to look at the water basins. They are very different, so after a lot of problem we selected a mixed method and then added some arbitrary borders for a smaller section. Now it is quite settled, probably because there is not too much oil under the area. Other borders are too boring or too polemic.
- ivanhoe 6y agoIt's complicated to rely on natural barriers as they change too, for instance some parts of the border between Croatia and Serbia were drawn to follow the Danube river, but the river bed is ever-changing as water finds new ways - creating meanders and river islands - so now we have some areas in-between the two countries where ownership is disputed. Some guy even tried to declare a new state in one of those areas https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Liberland https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Liberland
- teddyh 6y agoAlso on the US-Canadian border: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qMkYlIA7mgw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qMkYlIA7mgw
- emteycz 6y agoThe Gornja Siga area (where Liberland is) did not appear over time as the river changed, it's that the Serbians are explicitly using the historical river while the Croatians are explicitly using the contemporary river, which results in Serbia not claiming the piece of land and Croatia declaring it belongs to Serbia.
- ivanhoe 6y agoActually it's the opposite, and the difference between the two is because the river bed has changed over the time naturally and by human engineering. To quote Wikipedia: "Serbia holds the opinion that the thalweg of the Danube valley and the centre line of the river represents the international border between the two countries. Croatia disagrees and claims that the international border lies along the boundaries of the cadastral municipalities located along the river—departing from the course at several points—reflecting the course of the Danube which existed in the 19th century before meandering and hydraulic engineering works altered its course."
- toyg 6y ago> The land shore of Turkey has a lot of nearby Greek islands. The problem is that the concept of a "Greek" community precedes the creation of any concept of "Turkish" community by several centuries at best (even 2 millennia, by some calculations). So Greeks are historically entitled to read that situation as "the Greek islands and coastal colonies have a lot of nearby Turkish land". And then you find Atatürk's ethnic cleansing. And then you realize this shit is complicated. Political geography is entangled in history, which is why it's such a mess.