8 ms·
What is wrong with in-person paper-ballots? They have worked for centuries. And continue to be the absolute best system from multiple criteria.
by Ekaros 6y ago
What is wrong with in-person paper-ballots? They have worked for centuries. And continue to be the absolute best system from multiple criteria.
- diffeomorphism 6y agoCovid? Waiting in long lines? Not having votes on a holiday like in civilized countries?
- Swenrekcah 6y agoAll of those are solvable (and solved in most western countries). Re. Covid, it would be a simple solution to spread in person voting out a few days. It would be an inconvenience but no need to invent a new system.
- TheHypnotist 6y agoYou overestimate the current government of the USA.
- Fjolsvith 6y agoThe federal government doesn't handle vote tallying or polling, so why your comment?
- mhh__ 6y agoThe federal government also doesn't set the drinking age. The Trump administration seems to be trying to ratfuck an entire election. They won't succeed, but "Will no one rid me of this turbulent priest"-style comments from trump about fraud and months of delays in the results are beyond asinine. I'm slightly amazed that HN seems to have a contingent of I'm alright jack supporters of him. Maybe that says something about our ethics but I won't go there.
- Touche 6y agoYou're assuming those in power want to increase enfranchisement.
- Fjolsvith 6y agoSo neither party wants to increase enfranchisement?
- Touche 6y agoParties want to increase enfranchisement when they are in a position to gain from it. Once they've gained power they usually no longer need the help that increased enfranchisement would provide (survivorship bias). This is the same problem that prevents fixing many problems in government, like underrepresentation due to the 2-party system. Those in power want to maintain the status quo.
- diffeomorphism 6y ago> it would be a simple solution to spread in person voting out a few days. Don't you need volunteers to sit at all polling stations for all this time? So your simple solution is "we just need five times as many volunteers" and that at a time where all this contact is risky and where the president is claiming elections are fraudulent? That sounds difficult.
- Swenrekcah 6y agoYeah, I meant simple, not easy in the current environment. Proper distancing and masking is relatively easy and just pay the workers a bit and everyone is happy. I'm just saying holding fair elections is a solved problem. People should hold their representatives accountable to use the tried and tested methods.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- kristopolous 6y agoIt's way too easy for the ruling party to put the thumb on the scale and That's what's actually been happening for centuries. These days it's ID laws where certain IDs are accepted and others aren't based on who is likely to have what. It's closing the places to acquire the ID in the areas that will vote against you It's closing the polling stations, putting them in inconvenient locations, reducing the number of machines, putting only new people at the polling place, reducing the hours of operation, making the directions intentionally confusing ... there's many ways these are being manipulated. Historically it was much worse. Ballots were the parties responsibilities and lots of shenanigans happened there, making the slots too small to fit some ballots, giving the counters a way to "prefer" which ones to count first and thus give a candidate momentum. There's also lots of instances of "losing" ballots or finding stashes after the results were announced. I mean really, it's not a panacea, it's susceptible to dishonesty and manipulation like any other human institution. There's a number of great precautions other countries have done but the blinders of American exceptionalism strikes again and we're still stuck in the relative dark ages.
- Gwypaas 6y agoThat's only issues because you choose them to be issues since there's no central constitutionally guaranteed process. Most first-world countries simply require a polling location with certain number of booths per X people, require the maximum distance to one be Y kilometers which makes voting go swiftly. I've never waited in line to vote. Place elections on Sundays and ID's are already ubiquitous because you need them to function in modern societies. Like, I want to show my ID and then see my name be crossed of the list. It gives me the feeling of doing my part of upholding the integrity of the process. The whole election is public, you can observe the polling locations and count. Just show up. This is mostly done by the political parties and watchdog groups. Due to the size of the locations the first count is done a couple of hours after the election closes and the result is published the same evening. We also simplified the process even more to allow you to vote up to 18 days advance of the election day at any place in the country. If you then decide to change your vote you can go to your polling location on the election day and the advance vote is thrown out.