3 ms·
I wonder what a fair trial means to people...his own admissions include describing his own illegal activity...
by duxup 6y ago
I wonder what a fair trial means to people...his own admissions include describing his own illegal activity...
- cryptonector 6y agoYou can admit guilt and plead innocent. It's weird, but it's true. And the jury can acquit in spite of overwhelming evidence of guilt. That's how the anglosaxon system of criminal justice works (or used to; perhaps this is only true now in the U.S.?).
- duxup 6y agoA jury can...but that really depends on the opinions of the jury. It's not like a legal argument about what you knew or when and what the law says about your responsibility / actions. A jury ignoring admissions of crimes is pretty rare and a roll of the dice. I get why people would want that to happen, but expecting that random chance of an outcome and using it to measure fairness, I dunno, they're likely to be disappointed.
- mindcrime 6y agoWithout going too deep down the "jury nullification" rabbit hole, I'll just say that it's entirely reasonable to admit taking an action that is prohibited by law, while pleading not guilty to violating the same law. You may argue that there were extenuating circumstances that pre-empt the law in the specific case, or you may argue that the law itself is inherently wrong, etc. Yes, it's difficult to win an acquittal like this, but it does happen. That we can't just mechanically apply the law like the axioms of mathematics is part of the very reason that we have judges, juries, and the adversarial system, to allow for some measure of human judgement in the process.
- duxup 6y agoJury nullification is so rare and really relies on a particular jury thinking a particular way... A jury can even be sympathetic... and still convict him. I hear folks talk about a fair trial but he's already admitted to crimes... so is the "fairness" only determined by a highly unlikely outcome, I'm not sure that's about fairness.