3 ms·
The author is diminishing the bigger picture geostrategic issues such as trade, security, influence and state control. This has little to do with 'expression o
by jariel 6y ago
The author is diminishing the bigger picture geostrategic issues such as trade, security, influence and state control.
This has little to do with 'expression or values' - they are hardly part of he equation.
TikTok is a 'large Chinese company' which means it has deep ties to the government. TikTok users were apparently partly responsible for screwing up Trump's rally. I don't actually believe China was behind this, nor are we sure how much said users had an effect, but the fact that this is plausible is a very, very serious concern.
Authoritarian states are getting really, really good at controlling information, it's much more effective than nuclear threats.
That most of us happen to loathe Trump (who as far as I am concerned would for TikTok to ban negative videos of him if he could get away with) is besides the point.
The 'tit for tat' issues are not issues of 'values' - they are mostly issues of trade asymmetry, and there are very legit concerns there.
The notion that one state could have so much information about another state and act coherently on that in the context of a fairly aggressive, almost Imperial plan, is something we're going to have to contend with very soon.
Edit: I should add that values/freedom of expression do matter of course, but they are absolutely not the driving factors underlying this issue. Arguably not even part of the equation at this point.
- anniefrost 6y agoThere are literally thousands of apps that do that, but they were targeting TikTok? This is a political and economical move, if this is how US and Trump wanted it to be, by forcing another company to sell into another local company then it would be a forced acquisition and this would make other companies to reconsidered to invest or build their company in the US. By this rule, other country in this case China could also enforced banning on services and products into their market with the reason of "Security, Influence and State Control"