4 ms·
>In a discussion about the arrow of time, this is somewhat begging the question! Not really. "Been in" isn't meant to imply a temporal relationship. If a syste
by PaulDavisThe1st 6y ago
>In a discussion about the arrow of time, this is somewhat begging the question!
Not really. "Been in" isn't meant to imply a temporal relationship. If a system has been in microstates A, B and C, then it can potentially remember states A, B and C. It cannot remember state D. That doesn't stay anything about whether or not A preceeded B, or C preceeded A.
I agree with your last two paragraphs, but not the formulation in the middle para. "you cannot remember the future" ... this just seems like an non-useful observation to me. I think the problem comes from this line:
>We (and other physical systems) are able to form memories in one direction, but not the other.
I think this is wrong. The issue is that our memories are of macrostates, and macrostates are subject to the entropy gradient. If we could form memories of microstates, we'd effectively be able to remember events that had no arrow of time associated with them. But then you say this yourself in your final line. And Maccone's concept seems fine to me (as if that matters :)