3 ms·
>Ironic that Scott Adams has basically tanked his own reputation outside the alt-right through a set of poor choices recently. Or in other words, stated opinio
by coldtea 6y ago
>Ironic that Scott Adams has basically tanked his own reputation outside the alt-right through a set of poor choices recently.
Or in other words, stated opinions that disagree with yours / polite Californian dinner talk.
- dtech 6y agoQuote from him on women > The reality is that women are treated differently by society for exactly the same reason that children and the mentally handicapped are treated differently. [1] Yes, very California bubble to think that women are equal and not like children or mentally handicapped [1] https://comicsalliance.com/scott-adam-sexist-mens-rights/ https://comicsalliance.com/scott-adam-sexist-mens-rights/
- teddyh 6y agoThat’s yet another quote taken wildly out of context. Context explained here: https://www.scottadamssays.com/2011/03/27/im-a-what/ https://www.scottadamssays.com/2011/03/27/im-a-what/
- wombatmobile 6y agoHe says: > But perhaps I can summarize my viewpoint so you can understand why I’m such a misogynist asshole douche bag. Here’s my view in brief: > You can’t expect to have a rational discussion on any topic that has an emotional charge. Emotion pushes out reason. That is true for all humans, including children, men, women, and people in every range of mental ability. The path of least resistance is to walk away from that sort of fight. Men generally prefer the path of least resistance. The exception is when men irrationally debate with other men. That’s a type of sport. No one expects opinions to be changed as a result.
- teddyh 6y agoI would not normally try to summarize a long complex explanation, but I would think that this section would also be crucial to include in any summary: > First, some background. A few weeks ago I asked readers of this blog to suggest a topic they would like to see me write about. The topic that got the most up votes, by a landslide, was something called Men’s Rights. Obviously the fix was in. Activists had mobilized their minions to trick me into giving their cause some free publicity. In retrospect, the Men’s Rights activists probably should have done some homework on me before hatching this scheme. > As you can see, I thought it would be funny to embrace the Men’s Rights viewpoint in the beginning of the piece and get those guys all lathered up before dismissing their entire membership as a “bunch of pussies.”
- watwut 6y agoTaken at face value, that argument is nonsense. If you do that, the beginning of the piece serves as propagation of MRA women are inferior viepoint. And is treated as such. The latter insults "bunch of pussies" does not cancel the beginning. It does not correct what you wrote about women either. It just makes women collateral damage in you strughle for dominance against MRA.
- teddyh 6y ago> […] the beginning of the piece serves as […] You mean, if you take a piece of it out of context, and remove the text following it, it can serve to mean something completely different than what was intended? My point exactly. Also, from the same original text, Adams writes: > I realize I might take some heat for lumping women, children and the mentally handicapped in the same group. So I want to be perfectly clear. I’m not saying women are similar to either group. So he’s explicitly and clearly saying that he’s not saying that women are “like children or mentally handicapped”, just so that nobody gets him wrong. But then, of course, everybody takes the first quote, cuts it out of context, removes the clarification, and parades it around the internet like a hideous rallying flag.
- watwut 6y agoI reacted to your quote: > As you can see, I thought it would be funny to embrace the Men’s Rights viewpoint in the beginning of the piece and get those guys all lathered up before dismissing their entire membership as a “bunch of pussies.”
- arkis22 6y agohaha, yeah. who in the world treats women differently than men?
- coldtea 6y ago>Yes, very California bubble to think that women are equal and not like children or mentally handicapped He doesn't say that women are not equal. If you read the particular article the line is from, he makes a totally unrelated argument in that line and in that comparison: that men don't attempt to argue with women because they're emotional/unreasonable in arguments. And to translate casual talk for those that have to read everything literally, he means that some men, some of the time, don't attempt to argue with women because some women are emotional/unreasonable in some arguments. (That is, a seemingly absolute statement in a casual phrasing - not e.g. in some logical notation - doesn't translate to "absolute everybody/all the time/100%", but usually to some or at worse, most).