7 ms·
Some perspective is required to understand RC's decision here. If you only view this from the perspective of the author, it feels unfair that the RC would impo
by PragmaticPulp 6y ago
Some perspective is required to understand RC's decision here.
If you only view this from the perspective of the author, it feels unfair that the RC would impose harsh consequences for not reading an e-mail. In theory, his situation could have been fixed by having the staff carve extra time out of their schedules to individually handle his onboarding at a later time and go through the work of bringing him up to speed with everyone else, right?
Consider this from your own perspective: Have you ever had your manager stop by your desk with a last-minute requirement that they forgot to mention? Or a new feature they forgot to put in the requirements document? How does it feel when they ask "Can't you just take 5 minutes and do this for me?" even though you have other important priorities and you know it will end up taking 1-2 hours out of your already busy schedule? It's not fair that you pay the price for someone else not following procedure. It's not fair that your other work must be de-prioritized just because your boss wants this done ASAP for their own benefit.
That's the problem. Catering to the author is not a zero-cost activity for the organization. The staff is likely already busy sticking to their schedules and working with all of the people who followed the rules and showed up on time. They'd be taking time away from the people who read their e-mail to give 1:1 instruction to the person who did not.
There are second-order consequences to consider, as well. If you start granting exceptions to a new group of people on day 1 for missing meetings and not reading your e-mail, word gets around. You send a signal that meetings are optional, reading e-mail is optional, and skipping required events is okay as long as you follow up with the staff later. From experience, the reality of situations like this is that some people can't be bothered to follow the rules unless there are negative consequences in place. As soon as you send a signal to everyone that there are no consequences, some fraction of your team will start pushing boundaries in more places.
Speaking from experience organizing similar situations: Granting exceptions and doing 1:1 catchup in a program like this is never as easy at it sounds from the other side. It's better to focus on delivering the best experience to the people who follow the rules rather than allocating disproportionate 1:1 time to the people who can't, unless you really have excess idle time or excess staffing. In reality, it's far more likely that everyone is already overloaded and overworked.
- wonder_er 6y agoDon't both sides have to be understanding of the other's? > Speaking from experience organizing similar situations: Granting exceptions and doing 1:1 catchup in a program like this is never as easy at it sounds from the other side. This is absolutely true! But forcing the author to drop out of the program because he missed a meeting is acting like his _life_ is of no importance to someone at RC's convenience. RC made a mistake in their onboarding. The author demonstrated good intent and a desire to fulfill his side of the obligation. For a variety of reasons, a message was not communicated. To say it a different way: RC failed to communicate effectively RC probably should apply an expensive band-aid fix to the problem (1:1 instruction to someone who missed a critical meeting) and then re-evaluate how they communicate going forward so it doesn't happen again. Acting like this is an individual failing instead of a system failing is a sign of ENORMOUS organizational ill-health. RC made a mistake, and instead of bearing some of the burden of the mistake, they're harming _the person who was harmed by their error_. When I make a mistake, I try to fix it. If I blamed the person who was hurt by my mistake, you'd consider me to be sociopathic. RC's behavior is sociopathic at an organizational level.
- PragmaticPulp 6y ago> RC failed to communicate effectively The author wrote the RC communicated it via e-mail and also placed it on his calendar. From the article: > It was on the calendar, but at 7:15am in my local time zone, so by merit of that alone I had simply ignored the event RC also reached out to the author via e-mail, but didn't hear back until the second e-mail: > Hi Erik! I sent you an email this morning, but never heard back – we didn’t see you during the welcome flow or talks this morning, and we wanted to check in to see what happened. Furthermore, apparently the author is the only person who has ever missed the orientation communications: > The schedule was at the top of the email sent on August 5th and was on the RC calendar, and missing the first day for this reason hasn’t happened to anyone else since we’ve been running RC online. I don't think it's fair to suggest that RC wasn't communicating properly. The author admits he simply didn't read the e-mails and ignored the calendar event because it was too early.
- 6y ago