4 ms·
Regarding fission: - no one has yet solved the waste problem (okay, the US has ample free land, but the rest of the world does not!) - the proliferation risk
by mschuster91 6y ago
Regarding fission:
- no one has yet solved the waste problem (okay, the US has ample free land, but the rest of the world does not!)
- the proliferation risk is not eliminated (and no, it's not only plutonium, but also ordinary uranium for dirty bombs to take care of, plus the risk of enrichment tech, as evidenced with Iran)
- uranium fuel is mined under incredibly exploitative conditions. Additionally the US doesn't have meaningful uranium reserves on their territory, dito for Europe. Does the world really want a repeat of the oil crises, with some random sheikhdom having the world by the proverbial balls?
- safety issues haven't been solved at all: terrorism (hijacked airplanes) remains a constant threat, operator error/sabotage is a risk, and capitalism leading to corner cutting in construction, operation and demolition is popping up every other year.
Fission is a dead end, the hope is solar, wind and battery storage.
- opo 6y ago>...- no one has yet solved the waste problem (okay, the US has ample free land, but the rest of the world does not!) In terms of the waste, right now nuclear waste can and should be recycled which would reduce the amount of waste: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Radioactive_waste https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Radioactive_waste Soon it will be possible to use most of the waste as fuel: "...Fast reactors can "burn" long lasting nuclear transuranic waste (TRU) waste components (actinides: reactor-grade plutonium and minor actinides), turning liabilities into assets. Another major waste component, fission products (FP), would stabilize at a lower level of radioactivity than the original natural uranium ore it was attained from in two to four centuries, rather than tens of thousands of years" http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Integral_fast_reactor http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Integral_fast_reactor https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Generation_IV_reactor https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Generation_IV_reactor While there are issues with nuclear power, the worry people have about nuclear waste is greatly overblown to say the least. The amounts generated are manageable and in a relatively short amount of time we can use most of this "waste" to generate electricity. >...- the proliferation risk is not eliminated (and no, it's not only plutonium, but also ordinary uranium for dirty bombs to take care of, plus the risk of enrichment tech, as evidenced with Iran) This isn't really relevant for commercial nuclear power - no country has ever gotten a nuclear bomb from commercial nuclear reactors. No terrorist has ever gotten access to nuclear waste. There are lots easier ways for terrorists and countries to obtain nuclear material. (Nuclear designs like the Integral Fast Reactor keep everything on site (including reprocessing) so the terrorist threat would be even more unlikely.) >..- uranium fuel is mined under incredibly exploitative conditions. Better than mining rare earths or coal etc. >...Additionally the US doesn't have meaningful uranium reserves on their territory, With next gen breeder reactors, there is enough fuel for tens of thousands of years. (Or thorium reactors might be used, etc) >...- safety issues haven't been solved at all: Nuclear power has proven to be the safest form of mass power we have ever created. Yes, like any power source we should worry about terrorism, but that isn't unique to nuclear power. >...Fission is a dead end, the hope is solar, wind and battery storage. It is possible there will be some major advances in grid storage that will allow us to stop using natural gas to cover for the intermittent nature of wind and solar. But what if that doesn't pan out? The dangers we are facing in the coming decades are immense. Is your fear of nuclear power so great that if you had to choose, you would prefer the world to suffer through catastrophic climate change rather than use nuclear power?
- eadan 6y agoAgreed, with modern reactor designs nuclear "waste" is a misnomer. The Dutch keep all of their nuclear waste in buildings open to the public for tours, buildings which also happen to house priceless artwork: https://www.covra.nl/en/radioactive-waste/the-art-of-preservation/ https://www.covra.nl/en/radioactive-waste/the-art-of-preserv...
- khuey 6y agoGiven that two of the three countries with the highest known uranium reserves are Australia and Canada I'm not too worried about "random sheikhdom having the world by the proverbial balls"
- roenxi 6y agoActually it is Australia and Kazakhstan [0]. But the point remains a good one. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_uranium_reserves https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_uranium_r...
- loeg 6y ago> no one has yet solved the waste problem (okay, the US has ample free land, but the rest of the world does not!) Waste is completely overblown as a problem. Solar and windmills have much lower energy density than fission. So your zero-carbon alternatives to storing fission waste somewhere are: - Find even more land from somewhere for solar/wind farms, or - Vastly reduce electricity consumption Neither option really seems better than storing fission waste.
- mint2 6y agoMostly right but for the wrong reasons. Fission is on the way out as a widespread commercial scale power source buts that’s got everything to do with politics and economic up front costs and uncertainty of future electricity prices. The waste problem is only intractable because the politics are intractable, the technology part is not an issue. Political incentives simply are not set up to make it realistic for politicians to tackle the waste. Unless suddenly society becomes entirely populated by ultra rationalist super well educated people, there is no changing this current state.