3 ms·
If what you mean by "on average" is that that is what most people calling themselves software engineers do, that may be true. But framework knowledge is to soft
by lolinder 6y ago
If what you mean by "on average" is that that is what most people calling themselves software engineers do, that may be true. But framework knowledge is to software engineering what knowledge of tools is to civil engineering.
If you're building a dog house or even a shed, that'll be plenty. But I've seen developers try to take a knowledge of framework alone and attempt to build large-scale, business-critical applications, and they tend to come crashing down around their heads.
- scarface74 6y agoCounterpoint: I’ve seen plenty of “smart people” who could reverse a binary tree on a whiteboard in their sleep, wasted hours writing a maintaining their own bespoke frameworks because they thought that their problem was a special snowflake and couldn’t deliver business value that met customer’s needs to save their life. Part of my role at my last two companies was to know what to outsource and what to build internally and when to outsource the grunt work - ie decide what “the undifferentiated heavy lifting” was.
- lolinder 6y agoAbsolutely yes. I don't think that raw computer science is what most software engineers need. But it's also a lot more than framework knowledge. What is missing in most developers' educations is the actual engineering. If civil engineering is applied physics, then our discipline is applied computer science. A physicist might be a terrible civil engineer. Plenty of computer scientists are terrible software engineers. But that no more means we need to neglect the computer science then it means that civil engineers should neglect physics.
- crispyambulance 6y agoThese building analogies only go so far, I think. There are many different ways that people master a profession, and sure, in the best of all possible worlds people would learn under the guidance of expert mentors who supply "guard-rails" for the work of people they mentor. In reality, however, that's not always possible. Many of us don't have the benefit of a safety net or benevolent deity, we just wing it, fail, learn, and try again. It's not always pretty, but it works, eventually. Someone who is a Dunning-Kruger poster-boy one year may very well become your MVP a couple years later. If people don't push the limits of their capabilities (which often means failure), they'll not be able to grow.