4 ms·
The "butterfly effect" is only possible in some classic systems. For example imagine that you put a drop of ink in a glass of water (with some sugar). If a butt
by gus_massa 6y ago
The "butterfly effect" is only possible in some classic systems. For example imagine that you put a drop of ink in a glass of water (with some sugar). If a butterfly drinks some water, it will not change the final equilibrium state where the ink is evenly distributed.
This prove that one particular quantum system does not have an important butterfly effect, not that any quantum system does not have a butterfly effect.
(Note that (as far as we know) reality is described by quantum mechanics. So it they prove that any quantum system does not have a butterfly effect, then the weather and all the other macroscopic systems do not have a butterfly effect.)
- JanSt 6y agoMaybe the macro world doesn't have the butterfly effect either given enough time (millions of years?)
- esperent 6y agoGiven enough time (heat death of the universe) the macro word certainly doesn't have the butterfly effect. It's generally used in reference to shorter time scales.
- ralusek 6y agoEven at the heat death of the universe, butterfly effect would have resulted in different distributions of matter in their final resting states. I feel like your argument is akin to saying that it doesn't matter what an artist does on a canvas, because in the end, the painting is always abandoned by the artist. Yes, that's true, but the paintings are only indistinguishable insofar as your only criteria is that they are no longer being updated by the artist.
- coldtea 6y ago>butterfly effect would have resulted in different distributions of matter in their final resting states. Isn't there just one distribution of matter in the heat death? If the universe was in any kind of distribution with entropy to spare it wouldn't be the heat death...
- irjustin 6y agoNot entirely. Technical heat-death means there's no extractable work available anywhere and everything is in its most stable state for all of time. If protons do not decay[0] (we're not sure), parent comment could be correct. That there is a distribution of protons (or something else) left which would be unique because of some 'butterfly effect'. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Proton_decay https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Proton_decay
- goldenkey 6y agoThat is the idea behind Conformal Cyclic Cosmology, hypothesized by the titanic Roger Penrose. [1] However, he has considered a couple different possibilities: [Possibility 1] The last eon's heat death determines the big bang's character which in turn determines the distribution of matter-energy in the universe, ie. cosmic microwave background distribution [Possibility 2] There is no information able to pass from universe to universe, ie. the state of the big bang is essentially {}, a null state. Any asymmetry in the big bang is due to purely JIT QM. Nonetheless, the crux of the theory is that a heat death is the conformal equivalent of a big bang, since there are no particles with mass, thus no clocks/time. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Conformal_cyclic_cosmology https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Conformal_cyclic_cosmology
- aetherson 6y agoThe butterfly effect refers to positive feedback loops, allowing a small stimulus to have an outsized macroscopic effect.
- irjustin 6y ago> butterfly effect would have resulted in different distributions of matter in their final resting states. This isn't a verified yet. We aren't sure if fundamental particles hold up under heat-death[0] Not even sure if the quarks and gluons hold up either[1]. All this to say, the parent comment could be right? [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Proton_decay https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Proton_decay [1] https://physics.stackexchange.com/questions/147893/what-are-quarks-made-of-and-will-they-ever-decay-to-this https://physics.stackexchange.com/questions/147893/what-are-...
- hanoz 6y ago> So it they prove that any quantum system does not have a butterfly effect, then the weather and all the other macroscopic systems do not have a butterfly effect. You can build a chaotic system from non chaotic parts, so that doesn't follow at all.
- gus_massa 6y agoCompletely agree. The problem is that they build one small system that is not chaotic. They didn't prove that any quantum system is not chaotic as the article try to present it.
- breuleux 6y ago> For example imagine that you put a drop of ink in a glass of water (with some sugar). If a butterfly drinks some water, it will not change the final equilibrium state where the ink is evenly distributed. Yes and no. It will not change the equilibrium macrostate, but it will change the specific sequence of microstates the contents of the glass go through. Basically, if you take a snapshot of the glass in an hour, the ink will be evenly distributed regardless of what the butterfly does, but the specific positions of the ink molecules in the glass will be different. So if you use an external device that reads and amplifies a microstate of the glass, for example a device that reads the direction of the first atom that hits it, and you do this an hour, a day, a year after the ink was dropped, the result will be different depending on whether the butterfly drank or not.