8 ms·
A flutter in time: Quantum mechanics is immune to the butterfly effect
- ganzuul 6y agoThis gives difficult to grasp answers about what time really is. If I understood this right it implies that the present is a state of coherence, and that the past and future diverges.
- mnky9800n 6y agoIsn't this what all space time diagrams represent?
- ganzuul 6y agoNot quite... GR is classical, so the diagrams don't represent quantum information. At least they are not intended to.
- pmoriarty 6y agoThis experiment merely "mimic the effect of evolving a quantum system backwards in time". Since this was a simulation there are no implications regarding time whatsoever.
- ganzuul 6y agoThat doesn't seem right. Why would they simulate something with no relevance to reality?
- dakial1 6y agoMaybe they thought they destroyed the information but it was still present somewhere.
- akvadrako 6y agoYou can't destroy (or create) information in QM; a consequence of it being linear.
- kiki_jiki 6y agoWouldn't this be simply because of the small number of variables compared to a non-quantum scale system?
- gus_massa 6y agoThe "butterfly effect" is only possible in some classic systems. For example imagine that you put a drop of ink in a glass of water (with some sugar). If a butterfly drinks some water, it will not change the final equilibrium state where the ink is evenly distributed. This prove that one particular quantum system does not have an important butterfly effect, not that any quantum system does not have a butterfly effect. (Note that (as far as we know) reality is described by quantum mechanics. So it they prove that any quantum system does not have a butterfly effect, then the weather and all the other macroscopic systems do not have a butterfly effect.)
- JanSt 6y agoMaybe the macro world doesn't have the butterfly effect either given enough time (millions of years?)
- esperent 6y agoGiven enough time (heat death of the universe) the macro word certainly doesn't have the butterfly effect. It's generally used in reference to shorter time scales.
- ralusek 6y agoEven at the heat death of the universe, butterfly effect would have resulted in different distributions of matter in their final resting states. I feel like your argument is akin to saying that it doesn't matter what an artist does on a canvas, because in the end, the painting is always abandoned by the artist. Yes, that's true, but the paintings are only indistinguishable insofar as your only criteria is that they are no longer being updated by the artist.
- coldtea 6y ago>butterfly effect would have resulted in different distributions of matter in their final resting states. Isn't there just one distribution of matter in the heat death? If the universe was in any kind of distribution with entropy to spare it wouldn't be the heat death...
- foxes 6y agoQuantum mechanics is unitary time evolution? Apart from measurement its all linear, look at the Schroedinger equation... there's no chaotic dynamics. A trivial result? Pity I cant read the rest of the article behind a paywall.
- willis936 6y agoFrom a physics perspective it is trivial. I think this is more of a lesson in chaos than it is in quantum mechanics. It can also help in perspective when trying to grasp why quantum mechanics don't scale up to macro. Just yesterday I used this thought process as an analogy to the engineering adage: "You can do it fast, cheap, or good. Pick two." I argued that this is the most true for personal projects, but as you have larger numbers of people involved other effects become dominant.
- jostylr 6y agoHere's a non-paywalled article: https://ladailypost.com/lanl-simulating-quantum-time-travel-disproves-butterfly-effect-in-quantum-realm/ https://ladailypost.com/lanl-simulating-quantum-time-travel-... Here is the preprint: https://arxiv.org/abs/2003.07267 https://arxiv.org/abs/2003.07267 They are using the linearity to say that the effect is not magnified as it would be classically, but it is in the context of repairing damage done by a measurement.
- _Microft 6y agoNot that I could ever endorse such behaviour but have you tried calling on Alexandra, patron saint of the paywalled scientist?
- matt123456789 6y ago1. Researchers set the value of qubit X to zero 2. They pressed rewind on all qubits 3. They scrambled the value of qubit X 4. They pressed “play” 5. They checked the value of qubit X to see how close it was to zero. Turns out it was very very close to zero. This calls for an explanation of the recovery of the final value of qubit X despite the destruction of its initial state during step 3. The article proposes that the information necessary to recover the final value is encoded in the qubits with which X is entangled. I don’t know enough about QM to understand how the system is able to use this information to “set” the qubit to the value that it “should” be. Do the researchers’ actions influence the values of the qubits with which X is entangled in such a way that the forward evolution results in a system where X recovers its initial (final) value? My background is in deep learning. If I look at the activations in the final layer of a network, and want to achieve an output for a particular element, I can set that element to the desired value and run the network backward to reconstruct an input that would give that value. If I perturb that input slightly, the network will produce a slightly different activation pattern. If I take an adversarial approach, I can have what would appear to be an outsized influence on the final layer activations. I wonder if such an adversarial perturbation has a quantum analogue.
- gus_massa 6y agoFollowing your numeration, I'll try to ELI25: 0) Let's assume they have 4 qbits. Then the system has 2^4 = 16 possibilities, so the complete estate of the system is a complex vector of length 16 (v_0000, v_0001, v_0010, v_0011, ..., v_1110, v_1111) such that |v_0000|^2 + |v_0001|^2 + ... + |v_1110|^2 + |v_1111|^2 = 1 And |v_abcd|^2 is the probability that if you measure the value of all the qbits you get the value a in the first one, b in the second one, c in the third and d in the fourth. When you measure the value of all the bits, the system "collapses" and randomly select one of the possibilities using this probabilities. (Yes, it is weird.) 1) Let's assume that X is the first qbit. They made a system where the first qbit is zero. This is means that the last 8 coefficient of the vector, i.e. v_1000, ..., v_1111 are zero. So if you measure the system you always will get a 0 in the first qbit. They probably made an easier initial configuration, where one of the coefficients is one and all the other are zero, but the important part is that at least all the coefficients of the vector where the first qbit is 1 have the value zero. 2) Letting the system evolve in time (without an intermediate measurement) is equivalent of multiplying the vector of length 16 by an unitary matrix. The coefficients of the matrix are determined by how you connect the quantum gates or how your quantum system is made. The important part is that is unitary. Reversing the time means multiplying by the inverse. If you make no measurements, yo can go(simulate) back in time and return, and you get v_new = U U^-1 v so v_new = v Here we must assume that the matrix U and U^-1 are not very diagonal or has block, sparse, whatever. Let's assume that it is full or almost full and the values of the vector are mixed thoughtfully by the matrix multiplication. 3) After going back in time, the state is w = U^-1 v. Then they measure one qbit. Let´s assume that it is the last one. When you measure only one qbit, you can get a 0 or a 1. Here you have to distinguish the coefficients where the fourth qbit is 0 and the coefficients where the fourth qbit is 1. The probability of getting 0 is related to the values of the coefficients where the fourth qbit is 0 |w_0000|^2 + |w_0010|^2 + ... + |w_1100|^2 + |w_1110|^2 and the probability of getting 1 is |w_0001|^2 + |w_0011|^2 + ... + |w_1101|^2 + |w_1111|^2 They sum 1, so it's a probability. As a side effect of the measurement, if you get a 0, all the coefficients where the fourth qbit is 1 get erased and only survive the coefficients where the fourth qbit is 1. You have to multiply all of them so the sum is again 1. But the important part is that half of the information is destroyed. If the result of the measurement is 1, then the other half of the vector of length 16 is erased. The important part is that in either case, half of the vector is erased. You get a new vector w_half. :) 4) Now you return from your trip to the past. This is like multiplying the new vector by U. So the result is v_new = U w_half = U Msm w = U Msm U^-1 v where Msm is the measurement operation. Now v_new is not equal to the initial v, because the measurement in the past is messing the calculation. 5) Now they measure the value of the first qbit in the new state. It is like in 3. The probability of getting a 0 is |v_new_0000|^2 + |v_new_0001|^2 + ... + |v_new_0110|^2 + |v_new_0111|^2 and the probability of getting 1 is |v_new_1000|^2 + |v_new_1001|^2 + ... + |v_new_1110|^2 + |v_new_1111|^2 The result of the article is that in this last measurement there is a high probability of getting a 0. Note that if you apply this calculation to the initial states made in 1) you get a 100% probability of getting a 0. So the idea is that the measurement in the simulated past has not messed too much this value. The important part is you can't use any unitary matrix U, it must be not very sparse so U^-1 distribute the initial information in all the coefficients, and when half of them are erased, you don't loose too much information.
- throw14082020 6y agoMy heart fluttered as i thought this was another post about Flutter.
- dreamcompiler 6y agoI'm not surprised by this. The Butterfly Effect only applies to nonlinear chaotic systems and at the quantum level everything is linear. Nondeterministic, but linear. You can easily build macro-scale nonlinear systems from micro-scale linear quantum systems; a double pendulum for example. I rather dislike that the word "chaotic" gets applied to all sorts of things. It has a specific meaning, and it refers to nonlinear systems with sensitive dependence to initial conditions. It does not imply some vague connotation of "random." Chaotic systems are nonlinear and thus theoretically deterministic but practically unpredictable. Quantum systems are not even deterministic in theory, but they're linear and thus they do not exhibit sensitive dependence (the Butterfly Effect).
- _0ffh 6y agoThat was my understanding also. Good thing I scanned the page first, that saved me some typing work! =)
- tbabb 6y agoQuantum mechanics is deterministic in most interpretations except Copenhagen, which is losing favor.
- klysm 6y agoIs there a term for deterministic but where there is ‘hidden’ state such that it appears random?
- ithkuil 6y agoHidden variable theories don't satisfy the bell equation. There are other interpretations that don't require hidden variables and yet are fully deterministic. There is no free lunch though, so usually these interpretations require you "lose" something else. As a layperson, the one that I can make most sense of is the Everettian interpretation (often called Many Worlds, although I personally find that a source of confusion). In the Everettian interpretation there is only a quantum state and the observer is part of it. Thus the non-determinism and the wave function collapse is just an illusion due to the fact that the observers themselves are in a superposition state (which they are not aware of) and entangled with what they observe.
- kkylin 6y agoLooks like this is the paper: https://journals.aps.org/prl/abstract/10.1103/PhysRevLett.125.040605 https://journals.aps.org/prl/abstract/10.1103/PhysRevLett.12... ArXiV: https://arxiv.org/abs/2003.07267 https://arxiv.org/abs/2003.07267
- tasty_freeze 6y agoI've heard people claim that the mind cannot be strictly physical for there to be free will, therefore free will must arise at the quantum level where there are "free variables" that can interface to the strictly causal physical world. Somehow these quantum events percolate up to the macro level to make manifest that free will. The butterfly effect only works when a physical system is on the knife's edge, that it is prone to unstable/chaotic behavior. While it is conceivable that these conditions could exist at times (all the way from quantum level to saying "I'd like strawberry" vs "I'd like vanilla"), it seems unlikely to me that those conditions happen frequently enough that one's free will can direct the desired outcome consistently. Secondly, the idea ignores the problem of how this free will "knows" which quantum events to perturb such that their effects would cause the pachinko machine of sub-atomic -> atomic -> molecular -> nervous system interactions to achieve its intended outcome.
- abtom 6y agoQuantum effects apply even to physical objects. Only they are small enough to ignore. Trying to use quantum mechanics to justify free will feels forced. Surely, none of the people who believe in free will also proclaim that the will is completely random, or is something that can be modelled probabilistically.
- akimball 6y agoFree will can certainly be modeled probabilistically.
- klysm 6y agoI think the notion of consciousness arising from quantum behavior is a kind of ‘god in the gaps’ fallacy (https://rationalwiki.org/wiki/God_of_the_gaps https://rationalwiki.org/wiki/God_of_the_gaps).
- oezi 6y agoI think parent didn't talk about consciousness, but free will/randomness generated by the brain. We already know that consciousness is lagging the decision processes in the brain (we have decided to go for vanilla ice cream 30ms before we are consciously aware). It also seems obvious to me that the human brain can generate entropy somehow (we can unpredictably go for chocolate ice cream). While I am sure that we will be able to measure with sufficient accuracy any brain process that leads to such decision while a decision is being taken, it seems that any suggestion that we will be able know the outcome of the ice cream decision a time x prior to presenting the choice (say 60 seconds) is impossible.
- goldenkey 6y agoMirror (non-paywall): http://archive.is/SBBrp http://archive.is/SBBrp
- galaxyLogic 6y agoBecause everything builds on behavior of elementary particles, which behave randomly, everything more or less must behave randomly. Because of things like laws of normal distribution when lots of randomly behaving particles work together we have a way of predicting how the world behaves. But we can never make 100% accurate predictions because at the bottom there is randomness. Butterfly effect amplifies the initial randomness, a small difference in the random initial state can cause big differences in the end-state. But, there even isn't any definite initial state. Therefore Butterfly Effect rules This causes (in my view) the Arrow of Time. Because there are no definite initial conditions there can not be any definite final conditions either. Therefore it would be impossible to "reverse time" by following the equations backwards from a given end-condition, because there are no definite end-conditions. Everything starts with a fuzzy quantum state of say momentum. Even when our equations are deterministic because the initial condition is not knowable in principle neither is the end-condition. And this must apply in the other direction too, reversing the equations and starting from indefinite end-condition we can not "reach back" to a definite "same" initial condition. Therefore Time can not be reversed. Now I am not a professional physicist, this is just my intuition. Based on the above it seems intuitive to me why it is not a mystery that the Arrow of Time can have only one direction.
- ksaj 6y agoBesides the Thermodynamic Arrow of Time, there is also the Adaptive Arrow of Time, which is effectively its reverse. The theory of Natural Selection is an example of the Adaptive Arrow of Time, since over time, variability in a population is minimized instead of maximized, as the law of Thermodynamics would have it. That is to say, in living things, randomness decreases disorder, at least for the time that a thing is living or exhibiting life-like behaviours. Conway's Game of Life is so named because of it. Thermodynamics favours, among a set of probabilities, the most probable state. Natural Selection, on the other hand, favours the improbable state. A purely thermodynamic arrow of time would disallow increasing stability in populations, and the entire concept of species. There are other "arrows of time," but I don't know enough about them to compare. My point is merely that thermodynamics explains only one of them. It is a fascinating topic, and they are all probably related in some magical way we are yet to understand.