7 ms·
San Francisco will put ‘CEO tax’ on the ballot this November
- tootahe45 6y agoHaven't done any calculations, but this sounds like one of those taxes which earns very little revenue, and can easily be bypassed? Essentially it exists just to stroke a politician's ego and gain support from those with tall-poppy syndrome.
- Erlich_Bachman 6y agoUntil they increase the percentages a couple of years down the line, when they already have the foot in the door (when the law itself is already established). Just like they did with VAT in many countries.
- briandear 6y agoSo if a company pays its CEO less, will they get a tax credit? Unlikely. With coronavirus, why does a company need to have a San Francisco HQ? Simply move the headquarters to Las Vegas, Reno, or Texas, and hire remote. To my knowledge, there aren’t too many hardware companies in San Francisco; they are mostly companies they have employees that sit at computers typing stuff or calling people. Other than cachet, why would a company choose to locate in the city limits? The tax is admittedly rather small, but being in San Francisco is a death of a thousand cuts.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- Seasonwreckage 6y agoWhy are we downvoting this? It is the most fair assessment of the tech industry. FAANG might vacate large office spaces completely and shift status quo in real estate, VC and startups for the next 10 years.
- nikanj 6y agoThe location of the HQ on paper has nothing to do with where the office actually is, anyway. So many large corporations are registered in Delaware, or in a tax haven.
- pmlnr 6y agoThe fact that there are ceos who get paid 200x more, than an employee, is already outrageous.
- jstanley 6y agoWhy?
- wrren 6y agoBecause it's an expression of a corrupt system where CEO pay is public, and thus it's easy for candidates to negotiate, but employees are strongly discouraged from sharing their own pay data or are prevented from seeing the company's own pay bands. Where swathes of employees are let go when a company underperforms, but no-one is held accountable for making the strategic blunders that got them there. Where employees who try to unionize are targeted by their employers and harassed out or outright fired because companies are terrified of collective bargaining.
- MrBuddyCasino 6y ago> Where swathes of employees are let go when a company underperforms, but no-one is held accountable for making the strategic blunders that got them there. Execs should have more Skin in the Game. But it is also a fact that the higher you go in the hierarchy, the riskier your job gets. You get fired easier, in shorter amounts of time and sometimes just for backstabbing/political reasons. The average tenure of execs has gotten shorter and shorter over the last decades. Finding a new job is also considerably harder, as the market size gets smaller and smaller the higher you go in the pyramid. There are bad and questionable reasons why compensations are high, but also some good and reasonable ones. If markets seem irrational, chances are good you don’t fully understand them.
- Miner49er 6y agoMost CEO's golden parachutes are worth more then some workers make in a decade or even their lifetime. It doesn't matter if they are at a higher risk of being fired or have a harder time finding a job afterwards.
- Hydraulix989 6y agoThe only effect this will have is making SF even more of a hostile place for doing business during a mass exodus of people already leaving. There's other ways of controlling outrageous CEO pay than raising taxes.
- ShowdeadTrue 6y agoThe biggest complaint I hear about Californians is they bring their failed policies with them when they flee to other states, even though it's the consequences of those same policies that caused them to move in the first place.
- consp 6y agoI'm going to be a bit skeptical as most free reign in this respect in the past 30 years has created this situation and ask: What do you propose that would actually work?
- birdyrooster 6y agoWhen cities raise taxes they add value as opposed to accepting the status quo or racing to the bottom in a price war. Similar to business, attracting businesses as a city by competing on price is detrimental to the other aspects of city that could provide a unique value.
- LockAndLol 6y ago0.1-0.6%? That's laughable. I don't know if income tax is federal or a state issue, but if they simple increased it in the higher income bracket they would surely get more in their state coffers. (Yes, I know SF is a city). SF could also add a tax for people with uninhabited homes in the city. If you don't live in it, you pay the amount of money the city would've made had somebody been living in it.
- EdwinLarkin 6y agoCan we just please stop duct taping the broken system? We need fair taxes.Not high, not low. We need to hit the sweet spot between "it does not pay off finding the loophole and transfer all the money elsewhere" and "not paying anything to the system".
- Konohamaru 6y agoBack in the 1950-1959 decade a period existed when we had 90% tax rate on the upper decile of income... because the only place industrialists could flee to was the Soviet Union. But how are you gonna stop people from moving nowadays?
- maxk42 6y agoThe total number of CEOs this is likely to affect is zero. > According to reports, Wells Fargo, the bank headquartered in San Francisco, increased its CEO’s salary to $23 million in 2019. It would have to pay its median worker in the city at least $38,000 to avoid the highest tax rate and $230,000 to avoid the lowest tax rate. Well the minimum wage in San Francisco is $33,425.60 annually, so the median wage is almost certain to be above that since I doubt more than half their employees are entry-level bank tellers making minimum wage. Additionally since Wells Fargo is headquartered in San Francisco, I'm sure the number of highly-compensated key employees present locally is even higher. > additional tax would only apply to companies with gross annual revenues of at least $1.7 million and executives who make at least $2.7 million annually Again, minimum wage for a full-time employee is $33,425.60 annually, so this really could only apply to executives making more than $3,342,560 unless we're talking about part-time jobs. The net effect of this is going to be nil all but the largest corporations that have a large minimum-wage workforce based in the city and perhaps a handful of small corporations that employ a large number of part-time employees. So whereas I'm sure they passed this intending to make it sound like they're sticking-up for the little guy, the net effect is going to be the loss of a number of minimum-wage jobs. A couple big-box stores might either pay-up or move outside the city limits. And a lucky handful of employees might receive a modest raise. But probably not, since any small corporation could just as easily compensate their executives via dividends which are not covered by this legislation. In short: This is the legislative equivalent of a puff piece. Designed to sound good on paper without actually effecting any meaningful change.
- jbob2000 6y agoWhile it seems ineffective now, the legislation installs the knobs and levers which can later be turned or pulled to achieve effectiveness.
- bleah1000 6y agoIt's likely if this passes, we'll see companies use the pandemic as a reason to move out of SF. If these companies see that the city is becoming increasingly hostile to them, why would they stay? This is also the perfect time since it's likely that you can get real estate for much cheaper in other parts of the state or even in a different state. In the end, I wouldn't be surprised if just putting this on the ballot caused a few companies to decide to move away, which results in less tax revenue for the city. This whole thing seems short sighted, and unlikely to do anything but hurt the people of SF.
- user5994461 6y agoLow pay employees are hired through contracting agencies, they're not on the books of the mother company and have none of the benefits. The tax seems to ignore that entirely, contractors don't factor in the median pay of the company at all. If it weren't bad enough, the tax will only encourage executives to push even more employees to contracting.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]