31 ms·
> This is how right-wing activists frame it but it’s thoroughly dishonest, not to mention unscientific. The key issue in the abortion debate is – "at which poi
by skissane 6y ago
> This is how right-wing activists frame it but it’s thoroughly dishonest, not to mention unscientific.
The key issue in the abortion debate is – "at which point in the development of an individual human does it gain the moral status of a person". Some say at conception, some say at birth, some say at some point in between the two. The natural sciences (including the biological and medical sciences) can't directly answer that question. It depends on what are the correct criteria for an entity to have the moral status of a person, and that is a question for morality/ethics/moral philosophy, not a question for the natural sciences. At best, if we have agreed on moral principles to determine the answer to that question, then the natural sciences can provide factual information which can be combined with those moral principles to reach a moral conclusion; but, in this case, the different sides don't agree on what are the right moral principles to apply, which is a question beyond the proper scope of the natural sciences. Hence, I don't think either side's position is inherently "unscientific", although people on both sides of the debate are fairly called that when they wrongly present the debate as something which science can settle.
> A baby is a human child which has been born
"Baby" is a term of everyday language; I don't know if it has a formal scientific definition, but even if it does, you can't presume someone using the word outside of explicitly scientific contexts means the word in some technical scientific sense. In everyday language, "baby" is the correct term to use for an unborn child (at least one which is sufficiently far along); I know when my wife was pregnant, she had a baby in her womb, and when she was pregnant with our daughter, we told her big brother that "there's a baby inside mummy's tummy".
Is "baby" the right word for a newly conceived embryo? Not in many people's usage; in my own usage, an embryo isn't a baby yet, but it is going to become one at some ill-defined point in the future, yet prior to birth. However, maybe in some people's usage, a newly conceived embryo is properly called a "baby". Different people use language in different ways. And how the term "baby" is or should be defined in everyday language is another question which is outside the proper scope of the biological and medical sciences.
> Abortion is always well before the point of viability and increasingly rare the later it gets
So, a friend of mine who identifies as "pro-life" told me about a case in the state of Victoria, Australia, in the year 2011, in which a termination of pregnancy was performed at >= 37 weeks gestation for a "maternal psychosocial indication" (i.e. no confirmed or suspected congenital abnormality). I didn't believe him at first, but it is in the official statistics (see Table 6.20b, page 141 of [1]).
I don't support a complete ban on abortion (possibly my "pro-life" friend does). But I do think there is something wrong with a state's abortion laws if healthy babies can be legally aborted at >=37 weeks for a maternal psychosocial indication. I don't see how that morally differs from performing infant euthanasia post-birth for a maternal psychosocial indication.
[1] https://www.bettersafercare.vic.gov.au/sites/default/files/2019-09/Victoria%27s%20Mothers%2C%20Babies%20and%20Children%202010%20and%202011%20Annual%20Report.pdf https://www.bettersafercare.vic.gov.au/sites/default/files/2...
- dragonwriter 6y ago> The key issue in the abortion debate is – "at which point in the development of an individual human does it gain the moral status of a person". Its sometimes framed that way, but since the situation is sui generis in other ways (no one ever has entitlement to another human's body the way necessary for compulsory continuation of pregnancy in any other circumstance) there are other valid framings; particularly, its equally valid to frame it as "what is the extent of the right of bodily autonomy against intrusions by other humans". In truth, there is no single key issue, and there is a fair degree of correlation between the differences on those issues, so its often difficult to even pull one out as decisive for any individual, much less for the general debate.
- skissane 6y agoI agree that’s another relevant framing, although once again it is a moral question, and hence not within the proper scope of the natural sciences to answer. But, even if one were to agree that a woman has a right to bodily autonomy which outweighs the right of her unborn child to life, how does that apply to a case like the one I referred to, of a termination at >= 37 weeks for a maternal psychosocial indication? If the mother didn’t want the child, why not permit it to be born alive, then put it up for adoption? It seems clear that particular line of argument, whether or not it is correct, is insufficient to justify the law and practice of the state of Victoria, Australia (and the same may possibly be true of some other jurisdictions as well.)
- acdha 6y ago> Hence, I don't think either side's position is inherently "unscientific", although people on both sides of the debate are fairly called that when they wrongly present the debate as something which science can settle. You could start with the first case I mentioned: opposition to contraception, which is something American right-wingers are increasingly trying to class as abortion even though there are nothing more than unimplanted cells at that point. Most dictionaries define baby as starting at birth. Medical science has been able to push the point of viability back earlier (fortunate for the prematurely born children we know) but that’s nowhere near the first 8-9 weeks when the vast majority of abortions occur. Where science comes into this is answering questions about development: when the brain is a handful of cells, without the major developments which start on the path to cognition it’s not what almost anyone would call a “baby”. (Yes, politics means that more people will now claim otherwise then did before this was turned into a major political recruiting issue in the 1970s. We don’t need to let bad faith arguments redefine common words.) My personal benchmark: when would you have a funeral? Somewhere between a third and half of the fertilized embryos spontaneously abort. If you wouldn’t have a funeral or a forensic investigation, it’s something else. As for the case you mentioned, I can see that’s a favorite talking point of Australian anti-abortion groups who are trying to portray it as common. Given that it’s a single record for common medical procedure my first thought would be that we don’t have enough information to know that it wasn’t a data entry or classification error. The narratives portraying these situations as doctors happily killing viable babies have a long history of turning out to be gross misrepresentations of very painful medical situations. Ask yourself how likely it is that this would happen and NOBODY would say a word - no horrified nurse going to the police, no clerk calling the news, etc. - and ask whether that would happen in the situation as portrayed by abortion opponents? You keep using this data point in your comments rather than an extremely rare outlier so it’s really important to your argument to establish that it’s a real and valid case since you have exactly one data point.