5 ms·
Every political position hurts someone. (Heck, the mainstream leftist view is that you have to vote to make it easier to kill babies, and if you don't then you
by lmm 6y ago
Every political position hurts someone. (Heck, the mainstream leftist view is that you have to vote to make it easier to kill babies, and if you don't then you must be an evil person who hates women). If you vote against tax breaks for oil drillers, you're voting to hurt oil drillers. I don't think that's a productive way to frame political disagreement (and I say that as someone who lost most of my life's savings due to a shift in the law).
No doubt there are thousands of people from your partner's country who would like US citizenship and can't get it. You're demanding a special privilege for your partner and then talking as though it were a natural right. (My country doesn't give citizenship for any kind of marriage, FWIW).
- bluefinity 6y agoYou're arguing in very bad faith here. That's a huge misrepresentation of what pro-choice advocates want. > You're demanding a special privilege for your partner and then talking as though it were a natural right. It's not a special privilege. It's a privilege people who are straight get but not people who are gay, which is not okay.
- lmm 6y ago> You're arguing in very bad faith here. That's a huge misrepresentation of what pro-choice advocates want. It's the same kind of misrepresentation as saying Eich spent $1000 to hurt people like the poster. That's my point. No-one in these debates is actually setting out to hurt other people, yet from the other side that's how it's experienced.
- acdha 6y agoHow is it a misrepresentation to say that donating to the cause of opposing gay rights harms gay people? There’s a direct cause and effect, linked by exactly that issue - the Prop 8 supporters weren’t even trying to hide it, either. They very explicitly wanted to take a right away from other people, even though they suffered no plausible harm from those people exercising that right.
- wander_homer 6y agoThere's a thing called ethical beliefs and people tend to feel quite strongly about them, even though they're not consistent or reasonable in many cases. Like most of the people in my country are pro gay marriage, however most of them are also against marriages of more than two partners or between close relatives. None of those type of marriages harms anyone else, and yet people don't support it, just because it feels wrong to them or because they want to draw the line at one point to not make marriage arbitrary. I'm also pretty sure that you draw the line somewhere and I'd be surprised if you were fine with siblings being allowed to marry each other, even when they're deeply in love, they take care of each other like other couples and them being together doesn't harm you or anyone else the slightest. Edit: My take on this is: Even though I'm married myself, I don't think marriage should be part of the legal system or the concern of the state. If the state wants to support people who take care of each other, it should state specific requirements and everyone who fulfils them gets the benefits, no matter who they are. And if people want to get married they can do that as part of a private ceremony, provided by the church or whatever, and if they can't live without the consequences of being married today, they can sign a private contract to their liking. No reason to involve the state in this private matter.
- foldr 6y ago>No reason to involve the state in this private matter. You won't be singing the same tune when they take away the tax breaks, your right to visit your partner in hospital, your right to live in the same country as your partner should you be of different nationalities, etc. etc. I'm so sick of straight people who essentially say "well if gay people can get married then I guess marriage shouldn't be a real thing any more". In 100% of cases these people turn out not to have even minimally thought through the implications of this. But maybe suddenly stripping straight people of their right to get married would be the only effective way to stop the endless stream of heartless and hurtful comments on threads like this.
- skissane 6y ago> You won't be singing the same tune when they take away the tax breaks, your right to visit your partner in hospital, your right to live in the same country as your partner should you be of different nationalities, etc. etc. Here in Australia, the government has decided that unmarried couples in long-term marriage-like relationships (with characteristics like intentions of permanence, sharing of finances and mutual financial support, living together, raising children together, etc) should be treated equivalently to married couples, and receive the same rights and entitlements as married couples do – those long-term marriage-like unmarried relationships are called de facto relationships. This has been enshrined in law, and is now mostly true (modulo some obscure legal technicalities, and the fact that some government agencies at times fail to adhere to the spirit or even letter of the law – although to my knowledge immigration is the main and maybe even only offender). So, in Australia, there are no special tax breaks for being married – unmarried people in de facto relationships can claim the same tax breaks. Family law courts, etc, treat long-term de facto couples as if they were married for issues like property settlements and child custody. This gave a somewhat different character to the same-sex marriage debate in Australia – unmarried couples, both opposite-sex and same-sex, already had pretty much the same rights as opposite-sex married couples, and extending the right of marriage was primarily a symbolic statement of equality rather than a change in people's real world rights and entitlements. I think other countries, including the US, should do the same thing as Australia has – extend long-term/serious unmarried couples the same legal rights and entitlements as married couples. And once you've done that, there really is no obstacle to abolishing marriage as a secular legal institution. People who want to participate in it, either as a cultural institution or as a religious institution (or both) are free to do so, but there really is no compelling reason for the government to get involved.
- acdha 6y ago> Heck, the mainstream leftist view is that you have to vote to make it easier to kill babies This is how right-wing activists frame it but it’s thoroughly dishonest, not to mention unscientific. A baby is a human child which has been born. The contraception options those people oppose affect what is at that point a few cells. Abortion is always well before the point of viability and increasingly rare the later it gets – you’re talking cases with severe health risks and a long way from being developed enough to have any chance of surviving in a NICU.
- skissane 6y ago> This is how right-wing activists frame it but it’s thoroughly dishonest, not to mention unscientific. The key issue in the abortion debate is – "at which point in the development of an individual human does it gain the moral status of a person". Some say at conception, some say at birth, some say at some point in between the two. The natural sciences (including the biological and medical sciences) can't directly answer that question. It depends on what are the correct criteria for an entity to have the moral status of a person, and that is a question for morality/ethics/moral philosophy, not a question for the natural sciences. At best, if we have agreed on moral principles to determine the answer to that question, then the natural sciences can provide factual information which can be combined with those moral principles to reach a moral conclusion; but, in this case, the different sides don't agree on what are the right moral principles to apply, which is a question beyond the proper scope of the natural sciences. Hence, I don't think either side's position is inherently "unscientific", although people on both sides of the debate are fairly called that when they wrongly present the debate as something which science can settle. > A baby is a human child which has been born "Baby" is a term of everyday language; I don't know if it has a formal scientific definition, but even if it does, you can't presume someone using the word outside of explicitly scientific contexts means the word in some technical scientific sense. In everyday language, "baby" is the correct term to use for an unborn child (at least one which is sufficiently far along); I know when my wife was pregnant, she had a baby in her womb, and when she was pregnant with our daughter, we told her big brother that "there's a baby inside mummy's tummy". Is "baby" the right word for a newly conceived embryo? Not in many people's usage; in my own usage, an embryo isn't a baby yet, but it is going to become one at some ill-defined point in the future, yet prior to birth. However, maybe in some people's usage, a newly conceived embryo is properly called a "baby". Different people use language in different ways. And how the term "baby" is or should be defined in everyday language is another question which is outside the proper scope of the biological and medical sciences. > Abortion is always well before the point of viability and increasingly rare the later it gets So, a friend of mine who identifies as "pro-life" told me about a case in the state of Victoria, Australia, in the year 2011, in which a termination of pregnancy was performed at >= 37 weeks gestation for a "maternal psychosocial indication" (i.e. no confirmed or suspected congenital abnormality). I didn't believe him at first, but it is in the official statistics (see Table 6.20b, page 141 of [1]). I don't support a complete ban on abortion (possibly my "pro-life" friend does). But I do think there is something wrong with a state's abortion laws if healthy babies can be legally aborted at >=37 weeks for a maternal psychosocial indication. I don't see how that morally differs from performing infant euthanasia post-birth for a maternal psychosocial indication. [1] https://www.bettersafercare.vic.gov.au/sites/default/files/2019-09/Victoria%27s%20Mothers%2C%20Babies%20and%20Children%202010%20and%202011%20Annual%20Report.pdf https://www.bettersafercare.vic.gov.au/sites/default/files/2...