4 ms·
The problem is that it's also true. Comments like that decrease the quality of the discussion by attacking the "author" rather than the content. (If the commen
by Wowfunhappy 6y ago
The problem is that it's also true. Comments like that decrease the quality of the discussion by attacking the "author" rather than the content.
(If the commenter had written even a couple sentences on why they suspected GPT-3, I would feel differently.)
- happytoexplain 6y agoExactly. I can't tell if that poster actually suspects the content was generated, or if they are simply using the comparison as an insult.
- bawolff 6y agoAs a criticism, i don't see how that matters. An article written by a human at the quality level of gpt-3 has the same value as an article actually written by gpt-3. Knowing that gpt-3 actually wrote the article doesn't change its level vapidity. Either the article is vapid or it isn't.
- Wowfunhappy 6y agoBut there's no need to accuse the author of being a robot. They could have written: > This article is vapid. Zero substantive content, pure regurgitation Now, I would still have downvoted such a comment. If I'm reading a thread, I clearly like at least the article's topic, and I want to read more on that topic, not dismissive comments telling me that it's stupid. But, at least the modified version focuses on the content, rather than the author.
- ColanR 6y agoI mean, there's not much to elaborate on beyond what they said: "Zero substantive content, pure regurgitation."
- umanwizard 6y agoIt's not true, though. There really is substantive content in that blog post (although it's trite and probably useless advice, it's certainly making a real argument).
- ColanR 6y agoI dunno. "Trite" and "substantiative" usually don't go together.
- Wowfunhappy 6y agoThen don't say anything. Click the hide button.
- codezero 6y agoI agree, and this is my instinct, but I worry about the effort becoming very asymmetric. In a world where a large amount of content CAN be generated (my time to read becomes much larger than time to generate / get my attention), and I may or may not be reading sincerely generated content, at what point do I get to attack the content creator for that, especially since it's very difficult for me to understand any given content creators intentions without some level of social proof or trust. I think we're likely to get to a place where we either consolidate to trusted sources of information, or accept machine generated content as valuable on its own, even if for novelty and just move on with our miserable lives.
- albatruss 6y agoThis is exactly the reason why academics like their ivory tower, and value credentials more than egalitarian hackers do.