3 ms·
So, here in Australia we had a plebiscite on legalising same-sex marriage, and I voted in favour of it. If I were a Californian, I would have voted against Prop
by skissane 6y ago
So, here in Australia we had a plebiscite on legalising same-sex marriage, and I voted in favour of it. If I were a Californian, I would have voted against Prop 8.
You say the only reason your partner could immigrate is due to being allowed to marry, but it is actually also due to US immigration laws not recognising civil partnerships or de facto relationships. If they did, your partner could have immigrated even if you weren’t allowed to marry. I don’t know what Eich’s views on immigration laws are (or were), but for all we know he might support such a change to US immigration laws. I think it is very likely that some people who voted for Prop 8 would have supported such a change (I can’t say whether that “some” would have been few or many.) Personally, I think immigration laws should be marriage-neutral, and treat married and unmarried relationships the same.
I think it is an important cultural norm that employees be allowed to engage in small-scale, mainstream, private political activity outside of work without getting in trouble at work for doing so. We need this norm to apply at CEO level as well, because the norm at the top flows downhill to the rest of the company. (“Mainstream” means it doesn’t apply to fringe groups like neo-Nazis; “small-scale” means it no longer applies if employee wants to run for public office, lead an activist group, etc)
(There is possibly an exception for CEOs supporting policies which directly contradict the core business interests of the company; I don’t think marriage laws relate to the core business interests of a browser vendor; DMCA laws are possibly somewhat closer to those core business interests, but even then probably not close enough - if Mozilla’s product was a content platform in its own right, as opposed to being a tool used to access other people’s content platforms, then DMCA would have been directly relevant to their core business.)
I think the biggest blame here lies, not with people who called for Eich’s sacking, but with the failure of the Board to publicly come to his defence. A CEO can weather any amount of public criticism so long as the Board still publicly supports them.
- XMPPwocky 6y agoIf Eich had explained himself, maybe even said, hey, I have these views about the definition of "marriage" as a word and as an institution, but I support treating civil partnerships as equivalent to man/woman "marriage"- I don't think I'd have as much of an issue with him being CEO. Or, heck, for all I know the donation was a complete accident. Maybe he just slipped and his checkbook fell out of his pocket onto a pen in juuust such a way that it signed a check to that organization. Somebody could have even stolen his identity to make the donation! But when he refused to explain that donation, it's a lot harder to assume good faith, that he totally supports my rights but just has a problem with calling it "marriage", or that it was just a tragic checkbook-related trip-and-fall accident. Maybe he made public statements explaining his views that I haven't seen- links appreciated.
- skissane 6y ago> But when he refused to explain that donation, I myself wish he’d explained his views in more detail. However, I am not sure if his doing so would have helped much. Whatever he said, some people likely would have tried to twist his words in to making them sound as unreasonable as possible, and it would not surprise me if his PR team were advising him that explaining and defending his views in detail would only add fuel to the fire. Also, if one views it in terms of the principle that employees (CEOs included) should be allowed to privately express their political views by donation, then demanding a public explanation is undermining that principle and turning private views into public ones. It is possible that respect for that principle is one of the reasons behind Eich’s refusal to publicly elaborate his views on the issue.