3 ms·
Then force ISPs who own infrastructure to allow competitors to use it. Residents are technically the ones who own it and lease to these monopolies at the local
by paulryanrogers 6y ago
Then force ISPs who own infrastructure to allow competitors to use it. Residents are technically the ones who own it and lease to these monopolies at the local level.
ISPs are more like Ma Bell than a free market while they keep getting exclusivity agreements from localities
- ghaff 6y agoResidents don't own infrastructure if a local monopoly delivery company does. I don't own the electrical lines coming to my house. Nothing wrong with a system where the infrastructure is a regulated utility and ISPs can use it. Just don't assume it will be better or cheaper than it is today. There's no reason to believe that infrastructure won't cost you $100+ per month before you buy service on top of it. Or that it will be more widely available than today.
- paulryanrogers 6y agoConsidering all the broadband expansion contracts that ISPs have weaseled out of (while still keeping government grants) I imagine we've paid for most of the infrastructure many times over. Profits aren't suffering.
- curryst 6y ago> Nothing wrong with a system where the infrastructure is a regulated utility and ISPs can use it. Or, alternately, ISPs could continue to own the infrastructure but be required to allow other ISPs to rent or pay for passage on their last mile infrastructure. That seems to be the greatest point of contention smaller ISPs have. Getting a backbone connection seems relatively easy, but duplicating the existing telephone pole cabling and drops into people's houses seems to be very capital intensive. There's no reason for every ISP to have their own cables on telephone lines. Unless I'm fundamentally misunderstanding how those connections work (which is very possible).
- kebman 6y agoThis seems to be the model in Norway for both power and internet service. You pay a small fee for "line rent" in both instances. While this works well for electricity in Norway, IMO it's not that good for internet service. How many ISP's there are depends on who's got a server in your immediate area. I don't know the details of how it's regulated, though. This is just based upon what I see on my bill, and the competing ISP's in my area, whic surprisingly aren't that many, even though I'm in the middle of Oslo.