6 ms·
Seriously. I don't understand why there isn't a movement to regulate ISP's like utilities at this point. Why aren't mayors and governors running on this as a ma
by crazygringo 6y ago
Seriously. I don't understand why there isn't a movement to regulate ISP's like utilities at this point. Why aren't mayors and governors running on this as a major plank?
ISP investments, profits and pricing would all get regulated by the municipality. Performance is monitored and guaranteed.
I've lived in many, many apartments in NYC and each building has only ever had one choice -- Spectrum (was Time Warner) or Optimum. And it's always the same -- it's $24.99-39.99 at first, then after a year it's jacked up to $49.99-54.99, then another year up to $69.99.
It used to be you'd call to threaten to cancel and they'd re-lower it. But they haven't agreed to do that for over 3 years now -- they'll just let you cancel. They know you don't have a choice.
ISP's are so obviously by now a utility like water, gas and electric. Why aren't we treating them that way?
- cameronbrown 6y ago> Seriously. I don't understand why there isn't a movement to regulate ISP's like utilities at this point. Why aren't mayors and governors running on this as a major plank? Who do you think gave them these monopolies in the first place?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- ravenstine 6y agoExactly. They're making money!
- Retric 6y agoYour local power, water, trash, etc company's have a local monopoly and serious regulation. Internet just has the monopoly bit.
- zdragnar 6y agoMy local trash company, in fact, does not have a monopoly. The city I left to move to where I am now implemented a monopoly trash service shortly after I left, and gave my street to a trash hauler that is quite possibly the most consumer hostile company I have ever had the displeasure of working with... worse by far than Comcast. Also interestingly, internet options were Comcast or I think Quest fiber. Sucks to be whoever bought my house, I guess.
- war1025 6y agoThere are like four different trash services we can pick from. It's kind of crazy to me. I guess when all you need is a truck, it's not a hard business to get into.
- lioeters 6y agoThat's the answer to why most Americans have "no real choice" in Internet service providers, as well in countless other services like healthcare, where anti-competitive behavior has become normalized and tolerated (or actively encouraged) legally. Even when it's not legally a "monopoly", it's a collusion among the most powerful corporations and their revolving-door regulators that allow continued exploitation of the public.
- dhosek 6y agoThe ISPs have bought themselves some democracy. They've managed to get numerous state laws passed to prevent local government from doing any of this.
- kinjba11 6y agoThis is correct. What happened to Wilson, NC is fairly illuminating. Big ISPs convinced governments to pass laws that make it illegal to make an ISP as a utility. Planet Money - Small America vs Big Internet https://www.npr.org/transcripts/865908114 https://www.npr.org/transcripts/865908114
- ghaff 6y agoMa Bell as a regulated monopoly for long distance gave us pretty great service. It wasn't cheap.
- paulryanrogers 6y agoThen force ISPs who own infrastructure to allow competitors to use it. Residents are technically the ones who own it and lease to these monopolies at the local level. ISPs are more like Ma Bell than a free market while they keep getting exclusivity agreements from localities
- ghaff 6y agoResidents don't own infrastructure if a local monopoly delivery company does. I don't own the electrical lines coming to my house. Nothing wrong with a system where the infrastructure is a regulated utility and ISPs can use it. Just don't assume it will be better or cheaper than it is today. There's no reason to believe that infrastructure won't cost you $100+ per month before you buy service on top of it. Or that it will be more widely available than today.
- paulryanrogers 6y agoConsidering all the broadband expansion contracts that ISPs have weaseled out of (while still keeping government grants) I imagine we've paid for most of the infrastructure many times over. Profits aren't suffering.
- curryst 6y ago> Nothing wrong with a system where the infrastructure is a regulated utility and ISPs can use it. Or, alternately, ISPs could continue to own the infrastructure but be required to allow other ISPs to rent or pay for passage on their last mile infrastructure. That seems to be the greatest point of contention smaller ISPs have. Getting a backbone connection seems relatively easy, but duplicating the existing telephone pole cabling and drops into people's houses seems to be very capital intensive. There's no reason for every ISP to have their own cables on telephone lines. Unless I'm fundamentally misunderstanding how those connections work (which is very possible).
- pwinnski 6y agoBecause very large companies with a lot of money are willing to spend vast fortunes to ensure we don't. If it costs them $200 million in lobbying to ensure that they hang onto $1 billion a year in revenue, that's well worth it to them, while the rest of us are too busy paying our too-high monthly ISP bills to scrape together $200 million to counter their lobbying. A regular diet of TechDirt[0] on the subject, going back many years, tells quite a story. [0] https://www.techdirt.com/blog/?tag=muni+broadband https://www.techdirt.com/blog/?tag=muni+broadband
- amiga_500 6y agoWhy are the entire population just accepting the lack of democratic representation to defend their interests?
- pwinnski 6y agoI'm not sure what you're suggesting as an alternative. Large groups of people just marched in the street to protest far more heinous injustice that this corruption and the result was violent attacks by militarized police. What do you suggest it looks like for us to not accept this?
- amiga_500 6y agoSo would you say you are in a democracy, given the lobbying beats out voter needs and the state violently suppresses protests? Where does this end? edit as I hit the fake "you're submitting too fast" sorry if I hit a nerve there fella
- pwinnski 6y agoWould you say that you avoid answering questions on a regular basis? Do you pretend your questions actually seek an answer, rather than just making whatever point you want to make in the superficial form of a question? Still, I'll answer the question: Yes, I think we are clearly not yet in a totalitarian regime despite our general lack of choice in internet providers. I believe we are clearly still in a democratic republic, although a badly-abused one. Your last "question" suggests that the direction in which things move is inevitable, but American history demonstrates that is not the case. There has been an ebb and flow between moneyed powers and the people for more than 240 years, and we've been both better off and worse off than we are today. We will fight back, and make progress, but things like that don't happen on an internet timescale. Since you've declined to answer any questions or offer any alternatives, I'll offer some of my own. If you're an American an want to do something to push back against the corrupting influence of money in America, look here: https://www.unrigbook.com/get-involved https://www.unrigbook.com/get-involved
- zajd 6y agoI live in a town with all utilities municipalized and it's wonderful. $50/mo for a Gigabit fiber connection.
- zzzeek 6y agooptimum is now 90 BUCKS A MONTH. for basic internet, no TV, no phone. they are owned by some corporate entity called "Altice" which basically came in and ruined whatever slightly positive features the website had, like an outage map.
- hvaoc 6y agoUS Internet system is rigged to benefit the providers. This exactly the reason after every year we switch back the internet connection between me and my spouse, to keep the internet cost low. For most part US doesn't have functional government to manage these things properly.
- stainforth 6y agoI would say all of marketism is rigged to benefit providers
- BatmanAoD 6y agoA few municipalities have decided to offer fiber internet through the city, but I don't know how common that is. These projects take several years, though.
- roenxi 6y agoNobody on HN can know what "regulate ISP's like utilities" means. The utilities aren't regulated in a uniform way and it isn't obvious what the term means when applied to internet providers. The devil is really in the detail for that sort of term. Movements are probably held back by the cynical (and realistic) observation that "change the regulation" was the strategy that was tried in healthcare and made the situation worse. Somehow.
- 8ytecoder 6y agoUtilities are also guaranteed by law to make a profit. The prices are set to ensure that happens. Cities providing last mile delivery is a better approach to encourage competition.
- glial 6y agoI’m not totally convinced that more regulation is needed in this case. It might be that fewer would be beneficial, because existing regulations might effectively be regulatory capture. I don’t know enough to know, but what regulations are keeping startups from entering this market?
- zajio1am 6y agoIMHO more important question is why ISP market in US is so broken, while it works in other places. Instead of 'bad' regulation like heavy handed regulations of 'investments, profits and pricing', there should be 'good' regulation to improve competition without direct market intervention. Running small ISP is extremely simple, i started one (non-profit) while studying a university. Why this does not happen in US?
- blihp 6y agoThere are laws on the books in many states/municipalities thanks to heavy lobbying efforts by our cable/telco companies that prevent it.
- heavyset_go 6y ago> Seriously. I don't understand why there isn't a movement to regulate ISP's like utilities at this point. Why aren't mayors and governors running on this as a major plank? Politically untenable in this climate. There's a certain subset of the population who will claim that any type of regulation they disagree with is communism, and those currently in power have no problem boosting those voices to prevent ISPs from being regulated.
- Shivetya 6y agoDo you want them metered like all other utilities? Why do people assume it will all be fast and unlimited? It may have claims that it will be but suddenly there will be service issues and the only way to be fair is to meter. You get people who will abuse any service and with them you get calls to make it so they cannot. Why aren't we treating that way? Because they are still so new relative to other utilities and for the most part a large number of people don't find the internet as useful as people in our fields do. You would be damn well surprised how many families there are where only the kids see value in the net.
- tomc1985 6y agoNo company seems to want to be a utility. They all feel the need to compete on inconsequential, value-added crap and bullshit services when all we want from them is the pipe.
- gnopgnip 6y agoUtilities are expensive to operate and it is a tough sell to do something that will lose money for 5+ years.
- ivalm 6y agoAnd yet America has shitty expensive internet relative to most European countries. So we are doing something wrong.
- p1necone 6y agoBecause half the voting base hears the word regulate and starts screaming communism. Just because it would benefit everyone doesn't mean there isn't a huge group of people who would rather cut off their nose to spite their face.
- crawsome 6y ago>Seriously. I don't understand why there isn't a movement to regulate ISP's like utilities at this point. Why aren't mayors and governors running on this as a major plank? There was one, it was called Net Neutrality... How old are users on here?
- crazygringo 6y agoNet neutrality was/is solely about content. I'm talking exclusively about pricing and profits. Totally different things. How old are you?
- harikb 6y agoOne question on the $70 price tag. I get that it is high compared to, say, Europe or Asia, but not by much. Comcast/Xfinity gives 1 or 1.5 TB per month for that money. Now let us compare to business connection. One would think a business has “options” - they are someone who can’t be toyed with. Even their rates are not cheaper! I am talking about price/mbps or price/TB . I don’t think you can get a business connection for less than $100 - yes, you get static IP. We (at home) expect the same “reliability” as a business. We can cut it down to $50, may be, if we did muni internet. But it won’t become $20
- war1025 6y agoI pay $75/mo for 30/30 fiber. It seems a bit steep to me, but I never think of it as outlandish, I guess. I'm a bit curious as to whether the speed cap is due to old hardware or what exactly since much faster speeds seem to be common now, but I also never do anything that makes me wish my internet was faster. I am content.
- zepto 6y agoIt’s not obvious that treating internet like electricity and gas would be any kind of improvement in California.
- mushufasa 6y agoif you're in NYC, you do have other options. NYC mesh wifi is volunteer-based free isp, with suggested $20 monthly donation. https://www.nycmesh.net https://www.nycmesh.net.
- kanox 6y agoBecause it's a bad idea to replace a private monopoly with a regulated state monopoly. Regulation should instead focus on ensuring that consumers have multiple choices, as is the case in other countries.
- Mandatum 6y agoAt least you have mesh options in NYC which are arguably cheaper, faster and more reliable.
- irontinkerer 6y agoPerhaps that now we are work-from-home for so long, there’s a new compelling legal argument for regulating them a utility?