8 ms·
One is a proposal, which at the time, was mainstream enough to gain the support of a majority of California voters. (And, even today, although I don't think it
by skissane 6y ago
One is a proposal, which at the time, was mainstream enough to gain the support of a majority of California voters. (And, even today, although I don't think it would get a majority any more, it probably still would get a significant minority of California voters supporting it.)
The other is an extremely fringe view which has only ever been supported by a tiny percentage of the population.
I also don't think Eich was "out there advocating" for something. He made a private donation, which was not a significant amount in the grand scheme of things ($1,000 either way was not going to make any difference to the outcome). The law required that fact to be made publicly available, and then others publicised it; he didn't voluntarily choose to publicise his donation. When people publicly asked him about his beliefs on the topic, he avoided answering the question.
- XMPPwocky 6y agoSo, hi. I'm gay. My partner of 4 years is from a different country. Because of that, one of the only ways we can live together is to get married and get one of us citizenship in the other's country that way. To say nothing of other rights related to marriage. Just so you know that. Again: Brendan Eich spent $1,000 to hurt people like me. If gay marriage was not legal, my life would be significantly worse today. I didn't do anything when Eich was made CEO. I probably should have. Let's say I did. Would you say I'd be in the wrong for telling Mozilla that I disagree with their choice of CEO, because he directly hurt people like me and avoids answering questions about whether he's likely to do it again? Hm, here, try this. Instead of something provocative, let's try something else. Suppose Eich donated, say, $500 to strengthen the DMCA. Let's say be advocated for harsher punishments for anybody reverse-engineering a DRM scheme, even for interoperability or other non-piracy purposes. Then suppose he gave another $500 to lobby against net neutrality. When asked about these donations, let's say he refuses to answer or talk about them. Would you be comfortable with him leading Mozilla? Kinda seems like his values might be deeply in conflict with those of the organization, making him a poor choice for CEO. But also ... That's just politics, after all. Has nothing to do with his leadership or technical skill. > I also don't think Eich was "out there advocating" for something. You're right- he was paying other people to go out there advocating for it. Hardly better!
- LeFantome 6y agoI am kind of with the post you are responding to. People have all sorts of private opinions. I hate the DMCA and think it represents an extremely dangerous precedent that completely misrepresents why laws like copyright were created in the first place. The idea is almost more dangerous than the implementation. That said, I think I would be ok with the Mozilla CEO donating to the DMCA as long as he did not take action on that opinion at work. I would be cynical and watching the corporate behaviour like a hawk. I would give little benefit of the doubt in assuming the worst of any official behaviour, policy, or stance that seemed inappropriate. I would be unsympathetic about any consequences that resulted from inappropriately projecting personal values into corporate action. I cannot say that I agree that it is appropriate to take corporate action against somebody for the opinions they hold as a private citizen. A pharmacist needs to provide birth control even if they personally object to it for religious reasons—-because it is the law. If they don’t, there should be consequences ( perhaps losing their license ). However, it does not follow for me that they should be penalized for stating their opinion privately, at a rally, via donation, or even in the local paper. He has the right to stop his own daughter but not to stop mine. What he does with his family is not a good reason for me to go after his business. Now, I might not support his business. That is my personal decision. I might even suggest that others don’t support him either. I sure hope that this would not lead me to lose my job though. That would not seem at all fair to me. In fact, I would consider shutting down my freedom of speech and action like that to be quite unethical.
- XMPPwocky 6y ago"I cannot say that I agree that it is appropriate to take corporate action against somebody for the opinions they hold as a private citizen." This is definitely valid! I thiiink I'd still disagree- in a public-facing leadership role, it's just not that easy to separate personal actions from business-related ones- but it's definitely a view I have some sympathy for. I do get where you're coming from. That said- Eich resigned. He wasn't fired. And so far I've seen no real evidence that this wasn't just his decision- that he realized he wasn't the best candidate for CEO because of his past actions. Perhaps he really was just pushed out... If you have anything backing that up, I'd like to see it. Because from what I've read- and that's not too much, so if there's any info I'm missing please fill me in- if I say "I don't like the CEO, I won't donate anymore while he's in charge, and you shouldn't either"...am I in the wrong?