3 ms·
I think they serve different purposes. Satellites serve areas where they can't run wires or it's insanely expensive for too few people. Think very rural areas
by jedberg 6y ago
I think they serve different purposes. Satellites serve areas where they can't run wires or it's insanely expensive for too few people. Think very rural areas and war torn areas. Imagine being able to get unblocked internet in China by using satellites? Or in Belarus. Or the middle of Amazon (rainforest)?
- Alupis 6y agoWill Starlink even be able to legally sell internet services in China? Would they not have to comply with CCP's censorship policies and disconnect people at their will? I strongly disagree with CCP's policies here, but that's not for us to decide.
- jedberg 6y agoI was thinking of the opposite use case -- an American traveling to China for work and getting uncensored internet. But I mean once a Chinese citizen gets their hands on the equipment, I'm not sure how China would stop them. I suppose they could have roving bands of listening posts looking for the uplink signals. I'm sure someone could figure out a way to take payments for them. Many rich Chinese citizens already have bank accounts outside of China.
- Alupis 6y agoPretty sure an American company deliberately subverting another nation's laws to make a profit isn't going to be looked well upon, even if it is unjust CCP laws. Regarding an American traveling to China - I think you're still beholden to the host country's laws, no? You can't break their local laws just because you're from out of town. Not to mention the punitive actions CCP could take against Tesla (as they try to build out a business there) to put pressure on SpaceX to stop allowing Starlink access in China. That wouldn't be fair either, but Musk is CEO of both organizations and I'm not sure the CCP would distinguish them separately.
- bdamm 6y agoSpaceX isn't going to piss off China. The satellites are really just repeaters to the local base station. Starlink will be firewalled off from the world just like the rest of China (when the terminal is in China.)
- Klathmon 6y ago>I suppose they could have roving bands of listening posts looking for the uplink signals. I think this is pretty likely. In the US the FCC has a whole set of systems designed to locate interference sources [1], and I've heard stories that they're extremely good at it. They even have a whole facility in Maryland dedicated to satellite monitoring! [1] https://www.fcc.gov/over-air-spectrum-observation-capabilities https://www.fcc.gov/over-air-spectrum-observation-capabiliti...
- gamblor956 6y agoPeople keep bringing that up as a common use case, but how do you propose that people in China or wartorn countries will get their hands on the modems they would need to use Starlink?
- Alupis 6y agoOr even afford it? People earning an equivalent of a couple USD a day, or nothing at all, aren't going to be able to afford to pay some US corporation for fast internet. Fast internet probably isn't even a concern in wartorn countries, honestly. Let's be honest - Starlink is almost exclusively going to be used by people living in rural areas within developed nations.
- DudeInBasement 6y agoImplying the US government won't pay for the cost of an open internet where people can search for 'bad people square'
- Alupis 6y agoI'm not sure I understand your comment. Why would the US Government (aka. Taxpayers) pay for internet use in other nations? We already have expensive problems domestically that people would rather spend that coin on.
- bronco21016 6y agoWinning 'hearts and minds'. You drop access to the internet as whole in places where the internet is suppressed or non-existent and the populace learns just how bad they have things then they might revolt on their own. I wouldn't say I 100% advocate for the idea but thats the thought process behind it.
- gamblor956 6y agoThat would generally be considered a violation of another country's airspace, and some countries would even treat that as an act of war. You would also have to deal with the real possibility that those countries would simply shoot down any planes observed dropping Starlink base stations.
- closeparen 6y agoPossession of unauthorized satellite equipment is as good as getting caught red-handed at a dead drop. A paranoid security state wouldn't blink at executing every such person as a spy.