4 ms·
> The real question is, why were the explosives there? In a highly structured and rule driven entity (government) what happens when a problem falls outside the
by MattGaiser 6y ago
> The real question is, why were the explosives there?
In a highly structured and rule driven entity (government) what happens when a problem falls outside the set up structure?
It tends to be ignored as nobody is responsible for dealing with it.
- rectang 6y agoI've read numerous articles and although it seems lots of people knew the situation was dangerous and lots of letters flew back and forth, I'm still not clear on who had jurisdiction or failed to take action. The Port Authority? The courts? The Army? The General Directorate of State Security? This Reuters article is maddening, but it hits much closer to the truth than all the pointless "welding is dangerous" threads going on right now around us: https://www.reuters.com/article/us-lebanon-security-blast-documents-excl/exclusive-lebanons-leaders-warned-in-july-about-explosives-at-port-documents-idUSKCN2562L7 https://www.reuters.com/article/us-lebanon-security-blast-do... The hypothesis I tend to reach for is a general lack of "good government", originating because the factional tension in Lebanon completely overshadows any other political differentiation. The factions can't compete on competence because votes are locked in by group identity.
- Sharlin 6y ago> I've read numerous articles and although it seems lots of people knew the situation was dangerous and lots of letters flew back and forth, I'm still not clear on who had jurisdiction or failed to take action. That's exactly the problem. They weren't either.
- TheSpiceIsLife 6y agoIn an advanced country with a modern legal system, like, say, Australia, the answer to your question is: Every single person who knew the dangers is personally liable for up to $50,000 for an individual, if I recall correctly. And for industrial manslaughter the maximum penalty is 20 years jail and AU$10 million for a business operator: https://www.afr.com/work-and-careers/workplace/business-fined-3m-under-new-industrial-manslaughter-laws-20200611-p551mp https://www.afr.com/work-and-careers/workplace/business-fine...
- Dahoon 6y agoA modern legal system and an advanced country doesn't have or allow concentration style camps for immigrants or do its best to ruin the lives and rights of the original people. That rules out Australia.
- jiggawatts 6y agoAnd the United States also, by that metric...
- TheSpiceIsLife 6y agoNot an entirely unfair point! If we discount everyone with any faults, we'll never get anywhere.
- bjowen 6y agoThe concentration camps aren’t a mark of the effectiveness of the legal system so much as one of the political system - as inexcusable as they are, the country still manages to have mechanisms of state to administer airspace, health and safety and so on. But those institutions are fragile, especially when they're exposed to the political system (robodebt and the Murray-Darling authority spring to mind) but it’s also possible for dangerous situations to evolve in pretty well-defined regulatory frameworks. There’s a bunch of case law around situations such as buildings that failed inspections under one code or another, then caught fire and destroyed neighbouring property before the compliance deadline had elapsed. Common law negligence is there to catch these sorts of cases, but it’s much more of a way to assign liability than to guide behaviour. I haven’t followed the West Footscray fire from a couple of years ago, but it definitely had the signs of something that slipped through the cracks between regulations, which leaves it a matter of luck that it wasn’t something super duper toxic, explosive, or flammable and under pressure.
- antris 6y agoHighly structured and rule driven practices are key to all safety. Hospitals, military, airlines all depend on a rigid set of safety instructions that are followed without exceptions. Same goes for explosives. Many governments around the world set various different rules around storage of explosives, and the Beirut port explosion was a result of ignoring pretty much all of them. It's an example of what happens when the government isn't there to do its job.
- ninth_ant 6y ago> In a highly structured and rule driven entity (government) what happens when a problem falls outside the set up structure? It tends to be ignored as nobody is responsible for dealing with it. This class of problem isn’t unique to governments. Modern society has a whole host of problems that are caused by externalities generated by corporations.
- rectang 6y agoThe common thread is that in both cases, those entities and individuals closest to the problem have strong incentives to do nothing (prevention is a thankless, costly task), and so it falls to the general populace to create incentives to hold them accountable.
- MattGaiser 6y agoAnd you will be blamed for imperfect prevention. Say that the army spent $20,000 moving the fertilizer to a disposal site. Would someone get in trouble for that? Yep.
- lb1lf 6y ago-This is not meant as a witticism, but suggesting the Lebanese government is 'highly structured and rule driven' is giving it way too much credit. Cynical me find the explanation that AN fertiliser simply is too cheap more likely - it simply wasn't worth the effort to -ahem- reallocate the resources from the warehouse it was stored in.