6 ms·
Thunderbird is funded by users. There is currently no way to donate directly to Firefox separately of Mozilla general fund. Can initial steps be taken to finan
by walterbell 6y ago
Thunderbird is funded by users. There is currently no way to donate directly to Firefox separately of Mozilla general fund.
Can initial steps be taken to financially firewall Firefox development from the rest of Mozilla, as Thunderbird has done successfully? Start by moving the web standards advocacy brain trust to the separate org. Ask users to donate/subscribe. Begin the transition now, don't wait for the next negotiation with Alphabet/Google.
As donations grow, more Firefox teams can move to the independent legal org.
- nvr219 6y agoI use Firefox and Thunderbird all day, every day, and Thunderbird definitely feels like it's funded by users whereas Firefox feels like it is funded by an actual company lol. So.
- walterbell 6y agoIn 2020, desktop email clients are also a smaller market by several orders of magnitude.
- notyourwork 6y agoFor end users probably, for enterprise I doubt it.
- freehunter 6y agoBut enterprise is going to default something with an enterprise license and support agreement (like Outlook). You might have some users who prefer Thunderbird but they’re going to be a much smaller audience.
- giancarlostoro 6y agoNot always, we pay for a plugin for Thunderbird (ExQuilzilla) though. We're primarily working on Linux systems so it makes no sense to even have Outlook or Windows in our office. We don't make up a large demographic of our company (which is in the F500 range), but I wouldn't be surprised if there's other places that do the same. It's a shame Firefox doesn't sell a developer ready IDE, I'd subscribe to that myself if it means better MDN and that the dev tools team is better funded, and Firefox in addition to other donations from elsewhere, throw in a VPN subscription to sweeten it for most people. I'm ready to pay for anything that funds Firefox directly. I've even seen some in QA who do have Windows just installing Thunderbird.
- cglong 6y agoYou could always use Outlook Web App (even installing it as a PWA if desired); it's actually really polished. Disclaimer: Microsoft employee unaffiliated with Outlook/Exchange :)
- notyourwork 6y agoWe use exchange, Apple Mail and Thunderbird can both be used. There are limitations but there are options beyond the status quo in enterprise. Its a protocol.
- zerkten 6y agoPeople don't just do email in business settings. The proposition with Exchange was that you had email and calendaring together. This combination likely predates Exchange, but it was the juggernaut that took over big companies. Now you have GSuite and others copying that approach. In terms of clients, Outlook is probably a bigger Gmail client than Thunderbird within the enterprise due to the fact that business people in many places are only familiar with it. Yes, the protocols are supported in other clients, but going with something else is a in practice a peculiarity. I don't think that is healthy, but it's what's happening out there and impacting the potential of any other client. In the early days, Phoenix knew what it was about and had a team driving a really focused product experience for what would become Firefox. This was a very important part of why Firefox had the impact it had. Thunderbird always felt like a "me too" product focusing on email. In 2002, the set of criteria for global success (an integrated email and calendar experience) was already well defined. The product never got any razor sharp focus and an opportunity was squandered. It's hard to see how Thunderbird can ever achieve what it might have done.
- stjohnswarts 6y agoDo you know of a single enterprise of any size (say > 30 employees) is using thunderbird as their default internal email client?
- Macha 6y agoOWA and G Suite gmail are pretty widespread.
- trynewideas 6y agoAll the more reason to fund and support browser development, since it includes their mobile products?
- dleslie 6y ago> Can initial steps be taken to financially firewall Firefox development from the rest of Mozilla, as Thunderbird has done successfully? It would have to be a fork with user support. Mozilla doesn't have much incentive to distance itself from its core product and even less incentive to provide a means by which their users can dictate what policies and products their financial support is for. Mozilla has too many individuals in its organization, including its executive, who are not so closely tied to Firefox for this idea to succeed.
- walterbell 6y agoIn some organizations, 25% layoffs are not considered a sign of success. If Mozilla isn't tied to Firefox, yet has the ability to siphon from Firefox success or increase existential risk due to debatable roadmaps, new side effects of this principal-agent gap may appear.
- prepend 6y agoI would definitely donate to a Gozilla fork.
- chrisseaton 6y agoI don’t think Gozilla is anything to do with Mozilla is it?
- oblio 6y ago> The project took its name, "Mozilla", after the original code name of the Netscape Navigator browser — a portmanteau of "Mosaic and Godzilla".
- chrisseaton 6y agoYeah I know that... but what does this have to do with Gozilla? I don’t think Gozilla has ever been a Mozilla or Netscape product. The names are similar but they’re unrelated.
- calcifer 6y agoI donate to Mozilla every year. The changes you suggest would it make it less likely for me to continue, because I support Mozilla's overall mission of being a force for good, which is so rare in the technology world. Firefox is a part of that but Mozilla as a whole is a lot more important to me.
- dleslie 6y agoYou could still donate to the Mozilla Foundation and not the hypothetical Firefox charity.
- input_sh 6y ago> Can initial steps be taken to financially firewall Firefox development from the rest of Mozilla, as Thunderbird has done successfully? Start by moving the web standards advocacy brain trust to the separate org. That's exactly how it's done for the past 15 years. Mozilla Corporation is in charge of Firefox development. Mozilla Foundation is in charge of advocacy. Mozilla Corporation is fully owned by the Mozilla Foundation. Thunderbird development is handled by a different subsidiary of the Mozilla Foundation called MZLA Technologies Corporation. Yes, their naming mechanism is awful.
- dleslie 6y agoMozilla Corp does a lot more than Firefox development. All software development at Mozilla is under the purview of MozCorp. It's also wholly under the oversight of Mozilla Foundation and Mozilla Foundation has the ability to direct MozCorp to support its non-software development endeavours. Ie, by using Firefox push notifications to spread messages to users.
- notatoad 6y ago>Mozilla Corporation is in charge of Firefox development. Mozilla Foundation is in charge of advocacy. Mozilla Corporation is fully owned by the Mozilla Foundation. but the mozilla layoffs yesterday impacted both MDN and firefox. If the corp vs foundation is a distinction without a difference, why bother bringing it up?
- dec0dedab0de 6y agoAt this point I kind of wish Firefox would get moved to the Apache foundation.
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 6y agoWhy is Google even interested in Firefox users? Presumably many/most of those users are not happy with Google/Chrome/advertising/tracking. If there is some sort of "threat" to Google from Mozilla, this is like Google funding antitrust think tanks. It is difficult to take Mozilla, the organisation not necessarily the work product, seriously. https://www.nytimes.com/2017/08/30/us/politics/eric-schmidt-google-new-america.html https://www.nytimes.com/2017/08/30/us/politics/eric-schmidt-... https://www.nytimes.com/2020/07/24/technology/global-antitrust-institute-google-amazon-qualcomm.html https://www.nytimes.com/2020/07/24/technology/global-antitru... Neither the (NetBSD) OS nor the GCC compiler I am using, not to mention myriad other programs, needs to be supported by advertising. What makes the "web browser" different? As the comments on the Register article point out, it seems $400 million/year is how much money it takes to develop/maintain a web browser. https://forums.theregister.com/forum/all/2020/08/14/mozilla_google_search/ https://forums.theregister.com/forum/all/2020/08/14/mozilla_...
- twblalock 6y ago> Presumably many/most of those users are not happy with Google/Chrome/advertising/tracking. I wouldn't bet on that. A lot of non-tech-savvy people use Firefox because it was recommended by their nerdy friends. If funding Mozilla resulted in no return, Google would have realized it by now. They have been doing it for quite a long time.
- jhardy54 6y ago> If funding Mozilla resulted in no return, Google would have realized it by now. They have been doing it for quite a long time. Conspiracy theory: the return on investment is that the active development of Firefox defends Google against anti-trust accusations.
- 20after4 6y agoIs it really a conspiracy theory? It's almost certainly a significant portion of the equation.
- 6y ago
- znpy 6y agoThe development team might all agree to leave the company en masse, foto Firefox and start working on the Firefox fork. In six months to one year the fork will be in advantage over the original Firefox, and the new management will be able to focus on Firefox fork development.