4 ms·
"Otherwise they have a very similar method of cloaking detection, a similar policy for punishment, and a similar timeline for reducing the punishment for cloaki
by jerf 16y ago
"Otherwise they have a very similar method of cloaking detection, a similar policy for punishment, and a similar timeline for reducing the punishment for cloaking… At this point I feel that there are too many coincidences for this to be mere chance."
I disagree. The realities of having to work in the real world will tend to push Google and Bing in the same directions, even if their development is fully independent. The possibility of independent implementations of similar policies is not so unlikely that it justifies accusations of copying. I think you need more evidence.
Besides, it can't flow along the pathways that were previously established to my satisfaction (YMMV). If I understand it correctly, the Bing toolbar analyzes click patterns to see how pages connect together on the web, Google used the Bing toolbar while making their spiked searches, and found that small amounts of that signal made it into Bing, which was exposed when they created searches by design that had no other signal. I'd lay money the Bing toolbar now has an exclusion for Google (and probably other search sites), if only because Google demonstrated it opens an attack vector from the competition. And I do not think the Bing toolbar could pick up on cloaking like this, because that would rest solely on Google's internal servers. I'm not even sure by what mechanism Bing could be copying this signal from Google.
- hung 16y agoTo answer your question. My theory is that my site dropped in search engine results pages for Google. The Bing toolbar stopped getting click info for my site and dropped their rankings as well. That's how the toolbar could gather that info from SERPs alone.
- eli 16y agoWell, but, so what? Is it the apparent degree to which Bing appears to be weighting information from the toolbar? Otherwise, I don't see how this is new.
- hung 16y agoThe difference is that this was not observed from a sting operation where Google tried very hard to show that their rankings were having an effect on Bing results. It's a happy accident that I decided to take a closer look at and write my thoughts up on. And I'm sure there's more evidence living in Google Analytics that might make an interesting research paper.
- kenjackson 16y agoAgree with jerf. And furthermore, looking at the chart provided its not clear to me that one is trailing the other. For example, Bing has a big dip on March 14th, which is prior to the date that Google does. And even before the March 15th date your incoming data isn't very flat. And during the March 7th week Bing seems to again lead Google on a downward trend. I don't think you can assume anything from this data at all. What would be far more useful, to prove this hypothesis, is request to Google to not show the site for a week and see if Bing's results fall off a cliff. I suspect they won't, but give it a shot.
- hung 16y agoI also had a suggestion to show different content to Goooglebot and Bingbot. While that would make scientific sense, it wouldn't necessarily make financial sense ;)
- kenjackson 16y agoAnd one more thing... Google seemed to suggest that the data took months to go from Bing toolbar to search results. You seem to suggest it takes one day! That's a pretty big difference in the efficiency of mining their clickstream data.
- hung 16y agoThis is a good point. I am not sure how long it takes for change to propagate, but you are right; one day seems pretty fast.