4 ms·
Computer software development has none of the characteristics of a profession, either. There's no licensure, no guild, no liability, and many people practice it
by jeffbee 6y ago
Computer software development has none of the characteristics of a profession, either. There's no licensure, no guild, no liability, and many people practice it without formal training.
The software industry would benefit from moving in the direction of being either a "trade" without the manual labor, or toward being a real profession, but it currently occupies a weird middle ground.
- ceilingcorner 6y agoTBH I think this is a feature, not a bug. Over-credentializing coding will limit creativity. If you want a better existing paradigm, consider design (as in the broad field of design, which includes graphic, fashion, industrial, etc.)
- jeffbee 6y agoThat's fine with me because I favor the trade direction. I tell my mentees to make things in good taste that they're proud to show people, like a cabinet maker.
- room500 6y agoAfter dealing with many legacy projects from "creative" developers, I don't think standardizing on some basic practices would be a bad thing
- jquery 6y agoThat might increase efficiency but I bet it would reduce joy. As someone who joined the industry for the joy aspect, not the efficiency and money aspect, that’s not very appealing to me. Besides, I think standardization is already happening and being rewarded in the form of higher salaries for people who are fluent in modern frameworks and practices.
- 0xffff2 6y ago>There's no licensure, no guild, no liability, Those are all things that are near-universally features of working a trade, so what exactly is the difference between a trade and a profession?
- jeffbee 6y agoYou got me there. I guess I think of specific trades that don't have those aspects. As far as I am aware, you don't need a state license to be a machinist. But yes, you do need those things to be an electrician etc. So I guess software development is just basically like bagging groceries. Totally informal.
- elliekelly 6y agoSee now I don’t think I’d consider grocery bagging a trade because there isn’t really any skill involved. You could pick just about any person off the street and they’d be able to bag groceries.
- 908B64B197 6y agoThat makes recruiting a very fun game. I wouldn't believe the stories on candidates failing FizzBuzz until I saw it with my own eyes, several times!