5 ms·
> they do a lot to curtail scummy developer practices. Which is excellent. Apple taking a cut for apps I have no problem with. They have support, I trust them
by alkonaut 6y ago
> they do a lot to curtail scummy developer practices.
Which is excellent. Apple taking a cut for apps I have no problem with. They have support, I trust them with privacy/security and so on. That costs money.
The interesting discussion is how much apple can claim to own a part of profits made in the apps, by selling content (in-app purchases).
On one hand: if a game is free for a trial, and you can unlock the full game I think that should count as an app purchase (the alternative would be to not have in-app upgrades and just have 2 apps, which was a worse situation).
But on the other hand: if I buy a recipe app for $10 and then recipes for $1 a piece which I could also buy on the corresponding website, then I don't think apple should have a cut at all.
- kwanbix 6y agoI agree with you somehow. 30% sounds too high. 10% is much more reasonable. Imagine you selling a house and the realtor getting 30% of it. Crazy high.
- Razengan 6y agoWhat percentage do Microsoft, Google, Sony, Nintendo, Steam and Epic take?
- blaser-waffle 6y agoCan't speak for others, but Steam gets 30% Source: https://www.theverge.com/2018/11/30/18120577/valve-steam-game-marketplace-revenue-split-new-rules-competition https://www.theverge.com/2018/11/30/18120577/valve-steam-gam...
- joncalhoun 6y agoDoes steam take any cut of in-game purchases for free to play games? I don't think they do, so that is a difference to consider.
- SyneRyder 6y agoMicrosoft takes 5%. https://www.zdnet.com/article/microsofts-windows-10-sweetener-new-deal-gives-devs-bigger-cut-of-app-store-sales/ https://www.zdnet.com/article/microsofts-windows-10-sweetene...
- alkonaut 6y agoTake an interesting case like a subscription fee for content, not just an app cut. No one is angry about cuts from app prices (or prices that are effectively upgrades of an app e.g. from trial to full). What I'm angry about is when apple wants X% of the price of content whhen they don't produce the content, they don't process the transaction. All they do is host the store where the $0 client app sits. I don't think it makes sense.
- nacs 6y agoGoogle takes 30% (and have also kicked Fortnite off it's store). And Epic takes 15%, (some of which goes to Epic's 40% owner Tencent).
- Razengan 6y ago> if I buy a recipe app for $10 and then recipes for $1 a piece which I could also buy on the corresponding website, then I don't think apple should have a cut at all. Ah that sounds like a fair point at first, but it could be argued that you gained access to those sales because of Apple. More importantly, they're processing payments for you, and every payment processor out there takes a cut, one way or the other.
- alkonaut 6y agoI meant the case in the topic where they are not processing the payments. I did get access to a market/users via the store but I still don’t think that makes Apple eligible for a cut of sales in all apps that they don’t process.
- TechBro8615 6y agoPayment processors take a cut in the range of 1-3%.
- brianwawok 6y agoFind me a US payment process that takes 1% for credit cards
- TechBro8615 6y agoBut I provided a range to absolve myself of the culpability of a citation. :) Jokes aside, I'm sure you can find processors charging < 2% for customers with high volume. But you're right, it's certainly not standard. Maybe 2-4% is a more accurate range. Point stands that it's a lot lower than 30%.
- SyneRyder 6y agoNot even for high volume. Stripe's standard rate is just 1.4% for domestic cards in the UK (1.75% in Australia) and 2.9% for international sales. https://stripe.com/en-gb/pricing https://stripe.com/en-gb/pricing https://stripe.com/en-au/pricing https://stripe.com/en-au/pricing
- NamTaf 6y agoOn one hand, I get where you're coming from. On the other hand, if they offer a recipe app for free (because it contains no recipes, and let's face it, that's how you get quick user interest), then purchase recipes for $1.x each to cover the amortised app creation cost, you're basically just sidestepping the app store cut by any other name.
- graeme 6y agoThis is the crux of it. People aren’t applying second order thinking.
- alkonaut 6y agoI don't think Apple should be allowed to charge a cut from a subscription app for example. Just because I can watch Netflix on my iPhone doesn't mean it's wrong that I can download a $0 app, and then pay Netflix for the content without Apple seeing one cent from it.
- graeme 6y agoBut what app couldn’t be either a subscription or be unlocked via in app purchase? The dominant ios business model for apps currently is a basic version free to download, bigger functionality unlocked via in app purchase. Up front app costs are fading.
- alkonaut 6y agoAgreed. So the current model of “take a cut of everything” makes it very simple because they don’t need to differentiate between unlocking a full version of a game and buying a monthly subscription to music. The first I think is obviously right the second is insane (and in between there are an infinite number of cases). I don’t think the status quo is acceptable though.