3 ms·
> profiting from that use and not sharing any of the profits. Walmart profits when you buy their products. Yet you don't hear anyone demanding Walmart shares
by londons_explore 6y ago
> profiting from that use and not sharing any of the profits.
Walmart profits when you buy their products. Yet you don't hear anyone demanding Walmart shares their profits with their customers.
Let's not mix up the user privacy debate with the 'are companies allowed to make profits and not share them with me' debate.
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 6y agoLet's not compare Google with Walmart. The differences far outnumber any similarities. I was not making a general argument for profit-sharing, I was calling attention to this presumed idea in the example of users worrying "they will use my data against my best interest". Obviously they will not use your data against you in a way that causes measurable injury (damages). If they did, you could sue them and potentially win. They are not that stupid. However they may use your data for purposes other than the reason you allowed them to collect it. They will likely use the data to further their best interest; they will not tell you exactly how they use it nor will they cause you any injury. The only claim you potentially have is to the value of your data, which they utilise in their pursuit of profits. You might not get a "share of profits", but you could claim the value of the data they obtained from you. If many users make the same claim, in the aggregate, that could be a substantial amount of data that carries a substantial amount of value.