4 ms·
He's been gone from Google for six years, so I don't think we can paint him as a hypocrite or going back on his word over this. EDIT: In fact it was around the
by ineedasername 6y ago
He's been gone from Google for six years, so I don't think we can paint him as a hypocrite or going back on his word over this.
EDIT: In fact it was around the time Android was changing a little bit away from its open source roots that Rubin was sidelined out of the Android division and into robotics, shortly after which he quit.
- scarface74 6y agoOctober 2013... “Google's iron grip on Android: controlling open source by any means necessary” https://www.wired.co.uk/article/googles-iron-grip-on-android https://www.wired.co.uk/article/googles-iron-grip-on-android
- ineedasername 6y agoThat really doesn't go against what I said: At that time anyone could still fork Android, and if they wanted the open source versions of apps replaced by closed source ones they could use the source code for those old apps were perfectly serviceable alternatives to the closed-source ones Google replaced them with. In fact the article mentions two very prominent examples of successful break-aways of Android from Google: Amazon's devices and some made for the Chinese market. So my point stands: As of Andy Rubin's departure, Android was very much an open OS.
- scarface74 6y agoSo if you wanted to sell a phone in China, where you couldn’t use Google Play Services anyway, or you were one of the world’s most valuable companies who could afford to rewrite all of Google Play dependencies, you were set? Are you also as lenient about iOS? Since the core of it is open source? WebKit? The EU doesn’t agree with you. They ruled against Google for its practices. Google wouldn’t let a manufacturer both sell a phone using an Android fork that didn’t used Google Play Services and sell a phone that did.
- ineedasername 6y agoSo it's groups with a lot of resources that have the most successful Android forks, so what? What do you think it takes you wanted to start up a new business based on a custom version of Linux? That's a pretty hard market to break into also, but that doesn't mean Linux isn't an open OS. So yes, it makes plenty of sense that deep pocketed groups are the ones that have been most successful at it. There's plenty of other good examples of Android fork too-- less notable sure but certainly popular in some circles: There was Cyanogen, its successor LineageOS, Paranoid Android, Omnirom, GrapheneOS... there's more if you want to go searching. The EU's issue with Google has nothing to do with whether or not Android is an open system: Their issue with Google is that Google was trying to stifle competition. In fact the precise issue there arose because Android can be forked. The fact that Google tries to stomp on competition doesn't change that. It's no different than when Microsoft did similar things to stop OEM's from offering desktop Linux: It didn't make Linux less open. And you know very well that iOS isn't in a similar position to Android in this respect. You can't fork iOS, never could, certainly not the way you could with Android earlier on, and not even like you can now. Parts of iOS derive from open source, but it was never an open source OS. Also it's strange to bring up WebKit, which has been successfully forked a number of times.
- scarface74 6y agoSo Google cared about “openness” with Android, but as soon as a manufacturer took advantage of its “openness”, Google threatened them? You don’t see this as “openness in name only”? Would you be okay if Apple threatened companies that forked WebKit on other devices that they were forbidden to list their apps on iOS?
- m4rtink 6y agoIt is super worrying that in the 7 years nothing really changed for better in this regard, with Google only making things even less open and removing more user control.
- scarface74 6y agoAnd this was very much when Rubin was still at Google.
- ineedasername 6y agoHe was still at Google, but sidelined from Android into the robotics division, shortly after which he quit. Sure, it's speculation, but perhaps it was precisely because he disliked and objected to the direction Android was taking. Of course the timing isn't proof, but this article was written at nearly the exact time that he was shifted off of Android.
- scarface74 6y agoHe disliked the direction Android was going and then started a company to sell Android phones?
- ineedasername 6y agoPlenty of people don't like Microsoft very much but still develop software for it or hardware to run it on. OEM's have had a rocky relationship with them over the years. Rubin may simply have wanted to work on what he saw as an excellent direction for mobile hardware, and Android was about the only option for the OS. Regardless, my point stands: At the time that Android was undergoing this shift, Rubin was moving away from Android. Without specific evidence of his seal of approval on a more closed-source Android, painting him as a hypocrite amounts to malign assumption. Without evidence to the contrary, giving a benefit of the doubt doesn't seem unreasonable.
- 6y ago