3 ms·
And because of the great effectiveness of the American government, MS lost their dominance in the PC operating system market and rank nowhere near the top five
by scarface74 6y ago
And because of the great effectiveness of the American government, MS lost their dominance in the PC operating system market and rank nowhere near the top five most valuable companies in the US like they did 20 years ago.
- Hnrobert42 6y agoYou say it like it’s a bad thing. Perhaps if MS had remained so all-powerful, we would not have seen the rise of other US companies, including Google. If Google lost its monopoly stranglehold on Search and mobile, what interesting and useful innovation might emerge?
- scarface74 6y agoSo an anti trust schedule that ended in 2001 stopped Google’s emergence during the same time period when they had to convince people to come to their website using IE? You could say the same for FB, Amazon and Apple’s resurgence. None of them were helped by the government’s actions.
- Hnrobert42 6y agoHow do you know? Had MS remained all-powerful, perhaps those entities may not have emerged. That’s the justification for anti-trust legislation. But if you like your markets saturated with monopolies, you’re in luck. The world is full of them and under the current administration anyway, they aren’t going anywhere.
- scarface74 6y agoIt’s easy. Google - came to dominance on top of most people using IE. The consent decree did not stop MS from entering the search engine business and there was no indication that the federal government would have stopped them from buying Yahoo if Yahoo had accepted their offer v Apple emerged from going almost bankrupt by selling music players. MS tried repeatedly to get in the music player business - partially by leveraging Windows Media Player and failed. MS was also early in the smart phone market and failed - not because of government intervention. Amazon - how did anything that the government do against MS help Amazon? Facebook - Facebook became popular almost a decade later when no one was worried about MS. What exactly do you think the government consent decree did that helped any of those companies?
- Wowfunhappy 6y agoBecause of the effectiveness of the US government, MS wasn't able to behave anti-competitively and other platforms were able to take root. Today, MS is still one of the most valuable companies in the world, but the overall technology landscape is more diverse. It's hard to say for sure what would have happened without the antitrust case, but from where I sit, the government accomplished exactly what they set out to do, and just about everyone has benefited as a result.
- scarface74 6y agoSo exactly what did a the government action have to do with A) Facebook becoming a dominant social network? 10 years later? B) Apple’s resurgence with first the iPod - it’s not like MS didn’t try repeatedly to compete (Plays4Sure, Zune) and then the iPhone? Again nothing that the government did stopped MS from losing its early lead in smart phones. 3. Google from becoming the most popular search engine. 4. Amazon from becoming dominant? As far as the landscape being more diverse, Microsoft and Apple still have about the same split in PC operating systems, Google and Apple have about the same split in mobile operating systems as MS/Apple. And now instead of IE being dominant and Netscape being an also ran, now Chrome is just as dominant and Firefox is an also ran - funded mostly by Google. Meet the new boss...
- heavyset_go 6y agoThe suit wasn't about their dominance in the PC operating systems market, it was about anticompetitive behavior to maintain that advantage against competitors, and anticompetitive behavior to gain advantages against competitors in other markets. Had the suit came earlier, we would not have been blessed with the decade of security vulnerabilities that plagued the desktop because Internet Explorer was tightly integrated with Windows, and perhaps Netscape would still be around, along with Be Inc.
- scarface74 6y agoIt definitely was about MS forcing OEMs to pay Windows license fees for every PC they shipped whether or not the PC ran Windows. It was also about the the productivity software market and the lack of interoperability And browser bundling. And the lack of interoperability with MS’s network stack. MS had to make minor concessions on all four fronts.
- sjwright 6y agoIn a world where OS/2 failed, Be wouldn’t have a chance. The biggest irony to Microsoft’s anti-competitive OEM practices is that they were unnecessary. The network effects of software compatibility proved sufficient to maintain their dominance. And their temporarily successful attempts to dominate the browser market failed to turn the open standards web platform into the Windows platform’s greatest competitor.
- nitrogen 6y agoThe network effects of software compatibility proved sufficient to maintain their dominance. Before that point it was common for software to be ported to all the major platforms, so I don't think that caused their dominance, it just helped reinforce it.
- scarface74 6y agoYou didn’t own a Mac back then did you? By 2000 there were only two major platforms for desktop operating systems - Macs and Windows.
- fatbird 6y agoI'm not disagreeing, but it was a very specific thing that hobbled the antitrust result against MS: the DOJ had won, and then the 2000 election ushered in the Bush Administration. Nine months later, the DoJ decided to abandon seeking a breakup of MS, instead pursuing a toothless negotiated settlement allowing some competitive software presence and better documentation of APIs. It wasn't generic gov't incompetence; it was a specific policy decision by a Microsoft friendly administration.
- scarface74 6y agoYou mean an administration from the same party as the current administration? Even worse, the current administration is more concerned about “bias against conservatives” than consumer rights.