3 ms·
I think there is an extreme confusion about this portrayal of affirmative action as a sort of 'reverse-racism'. It's not actually a judgement based on race or e
by Barrin92 6y ago
I think there is an extreme confusion about this portrayal of affirmative action as a sort of 'reverse-racism'. It's not actually a judgement based on race or ethnicity, but on the factors that give people from these groups a harder time to get into the top universities.
I'm sure you could construct a sort of proxy of income/test-scores/hardship or whatever that approximates exactly what affirmative action does while formally avoiding the race issue.
- john-shaffer 6y agoSuch a proxy would be a completely different beast than affirmative action. Affirmative action means that uber-rich minorities are helped more than dirt poor Asians/whites. I don't think that any race-neutral proxy could ever approximate a race-based policy.
- Niten 6y ago"Affirmative action", in the common understanding of the term, refers to non-race-blind processes in admissions and so forth. If, while controlling for all other variables, a person of race A has a different chance of being admitted than a person of race B because of their race, then yes, we certainly are talking about a form of racism. On the other hand, as you point out, one could design a race-blind system that gives a leg up to people who grew up in poverty, people whose parents were incarcerated on account of the war on drugs, etc. This system would disproportionately give a leg up to black students, so when looked at from an angle of averaged-out racial group dynamics it may "approximate exactly what affirmative action does." However, crucially, on an _individual_ level such a system would not discriminate between otherwise similar applicants on the arbitrary basis of race. Unlike affirmative action, such an alternative system as you describe would not be racist, and that is no small distinction.