4 ms·
> Apple recently rolled out "Sign-In With Apple", which creates burner e-mail address that you can seamlessly use with 3rd party services. As a privacy-consciou
by echelon 6y ago
> Apple recently rolled out "Sign-In With Apple", which creates burner e-mail address that you can seamlessly use with 3rd party services. As a privacy-conscious consumer, this was great!
Apple spins this as privacy, but it's really a salvo they fired against other companies. Notably Google and Facebook. Apple seeks to weaponize its userbase in the war over attention.
Apple wins by inserting themselves as middleman into every transaction they can.
A "Sign in With Apple" user isn't your customer anymore.
If you think they value privacy, you should consider the telemetry they collect on you and the conversations they record.
- bhupy 6y ago> A "Sign in With Apple" user isn't your customer anymore. Apple inserted themselves as middleman yet again. Yes, as a customer, I don't wish to provide my email / identity with every service I use. If it takes Apple being the "middleman" to have the power to control how a business interacts with me as a customer, then so be it. > If you think they value privacy, you should consider the telemetry they collect on you and the conversations they record. I used to work at Apple on their services team, and I can tell you right now that Apple has virtually no useful telemetry information that can be tied to an individual user. iOS telemetry data is tied to a periodically recycling identifier that's un-correlated with your iCloud identity.
- stickfigure 6y ago> If it takes Apple being the "middleman" to have the power ...that works right up until Apple bans you, or one of your favorite services, or just demands you pony up 30% of all the money you spend online. You think that's unlikely? In the 80s, Microsoft was the hero and IBM was the villain. In the late 90s and early 2000s, Google was everyone's favorite. During the Arab Spring, Facebook was a popular tool for liberation. Every corporation will become evil if it becomes successful enough. Give Apple centralized control over web authentication and they'll be just as ruthless as they are with the app store. We're watching a shift in public perception happen right now. The only long-term defense we have is decentralizataion, and you're fighting that. Why? So you won't get spam that you never see?
- echelon 6y ago> Why? So you won't get spam that you never see? They worked at Apple and probably have a different perception than someone who works uphill against Apple.
- bhupy 6y agoDude, maybe cool down a little. I understand you feel really strongly about this, but there's no need for personal attacks. We're all dealing with the implications of this, and there are pros and cons on both sides. This is a nuanced issue. And if you'll excuse some unsolicited feedback, your arguments will bear way more weight if you do away with the histrionics.
- echelon 6y ago> but there's no need for personal attacks It wasn't a personal attack, unless "They worked at Apple and probably have a different perception" is a personal attack. I don't harbor any ill will against you. Characterizing my words that way is disingenuous. > This is a nuanced issue. From my perspective, it's black and white. Apple is clearly taking advantage of market forces and is hurting small players. > your arguments will bear way more weight if you do away with the histrionics. The arguments that are heard are the ones that engender empathy. We've been at the point of logical discussion for years, and that hasn't gotten us anywhere. Now the outrage has come to a boil, and I won't censor myself or pretend this is a friendly game of sports. Apple is a trillion dollar vampire. I'm letting my representatives know that.
- bhupy 6y ago> From my perspective, it's black and white. You're probably on the wrong forum, then. Either that or you'll have to understand that not everybody sees this as black and white, and maybe understand exactly why. > Apple is a trillion dollar vampire. I'm letting my representatives know that. I wish you and your crusade the best of luck.
- bhupy 6y ago