3 ms·
This filing is clever on Epic's part. (Or someone at Cravath, more likely.) What Epic is asking for is an injunction. They may well get a temporary injunction
by Animats 6y ago
This filing is clever on Epic's part. (Or someone at Cravath, more likely.)
What Epic is asking for is an injunction. They may well get a temporary injunction quickly, compelling Apple to put their app back in Apple's store. Then the case gets litigated on the merits, but starting from a de facto win for Epic.
The standard required for a temporary injunction is low:
"To justify a temporary injunction it is not necessary that the plaintiff's right to a final decision, after a trial, be absolutely certain, wholly without doubt; if the other elements are present (i.e., the balance of hardships tips decidedly toward plaintiff), it will ordinarily be enough that the plaintiff has raised questions going to the merits so serious, substantial, difficult and doubtful, as to make them a fair ground for litigation and thus for more deliberate investigation."[1]
Litigation on temporary injunctions is relatively fast. This part will be decided in weeks, not years.
Epic might only win a rollback to the last uncontroverted state, though. That is, apparently, before Epic's payment system went live on Apple platforms.
If Apple had allowed third party payments for a while, then removed the app, Epic would be in a stronger position to insist that their own payment system remain live.
[1] https://scholarship.law.duke.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=2013&context=dlj https://scholarship.law.duke.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article...
[2] https://www.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.wiwd.39930/gov.uscourts.wiwd.39930.191.0.pdf https://www.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.wiwd.39930/...
- calcifer 6y ago> Epic might only win a rollback to the last uncontroverted state, though. That is, apparently, before Epic's payment system went live on Apple platforms. IIUIC the app itself wasn't updated, only the webview for payments was updated on the server side.
- Animats 6y agoInteresting. If that's correct, Epic is in an even stronger position. They can claim that Apple retaliated against them for a competitive move which had no bearing on the activities taking place in the arena Apple claims to control.