4 ms·
I think this is called tacit collusion. You see something like this with gasoline pricing - major brands will have "competing" stations across the street from
by musicale 6y ago
I think this is called tacit collusion.
You see something like this with gasoline pricing - major brands will have "competing" stations across the street from each other, but their prices moves in lock step without a race to the bottom.
Memory vendors have explicitly colluded in the past, but they really didn't need to - they just needed to copy their competitors' posted pricing. Presumably that is what they do now.
If there are high barriers to new competitors entering the market, then the situation is unlikely to change.
- umvi 6y ago> You tend to see it with gasoline pricing as well - all the major companies have nearly identical prices. Yeah because otherwise you make no money on gas. If I undercut the store across the street by a penny, they will then immediately match me or undercut by a penny. Pretty soon, we are at the break-even point and can't go lower without losing money. That's not tacit collusion, that's just a race to the bottom. There's a big difference between all major app stores taking 30% every time money changes hands, and a race-to-the-bottom industry like milk or gasoline. Try starting a dairy farm - I think you'll find you won't be able to price your milk lower than your competition, and as a result your milk will be the same price everyone else's has been for the past 50 years - ~$2-3/gallon.
- dudus 6y agoI believe the correct term is Cartel and is just as illegal as monopoly just harder to prove.
- g_p 6y agoA cartel, by my understanding, would require the act of collusion to take place. The issue in the telecoms market, at least IMO, is the high entry price (spectrum access sometimes meaning there is no option aside from buying an existing operator), combined with scale of the operators (usually large and national-level) meaning there is little entrepreneurial spirit to drive costs down. It can cost a large company 100x what it would cost a small company to do the same work, and that becomes a price everyone ends up paying for. But absent knocking down barriers to entry, it's a very hard market for a new entrant to get into, unless you are happy to just sell to the existing incumbents as clients.
- Tehnix 6y agoActually, that’s not correct about gas stations. Having worked at one, we would check the prices of the two others on the same road once every hour. These numbers were reported into HQ, and a price adjustment would be made to be lower. It’s very competitive and people are willing to drive or wait until a different time of day to get a lower price. EDIT: Maybe I should have said: that’s at least not the case everywhere.
- Kinrany 6y agoThe question is, would you also adjust the price when the others increased their prices? If a store knows that the other store will raise their price in response, they can collude without an explicit agreement.
- kevin_thibedeau 6y agoThis isn't practical without an electronic sign.
- Tehnix 6y agoIn all the parts of the world I’ve been in, I’ve never seen a gas station without an electronic sign?
- jeffrallen 6y agoYou might enjoy a trip to Aru, in eastern DR Congo. The gas pumps were run off of a gas generator!
- kevin_thibedeau 6y agoYou only have to travel to third world countries like USA.
- boogies 6y agoI don’t have downvote yet and you’re tempting me to flag you. The US is a vast and diverse country with plenty of areas that aren’t homogeneously Liechtenstein rich but it’s far from any widely-established definition of a third world country.
- s3r3nity 6y agoIndeed price signaling [1] is a real thing when it comes to anti-competitive behavior among dominant market players - and government economists love analyzing these types of problems for antitrust cases, as they can be like solving forensic puzzles. [2] [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Price_signal#:~:text=A%20price%20signal%20is%20information,quantity%20supplied%20or%20quantity%20demanded https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Price_signal#:~:text=A%20price.... [2] https://www.thesoulofenterprise.com/tsoe/antitrust https://www.thesoulofenterprise.com/tsoe/antitrust
- kazinator 6y agoI don't think so; the situation of copying the posted price can easily trigger a price war. It is not stable, unless someone is designated as the price master, and the others are slaves. That's the only thing which can explain that the prices can go wildly up and down, yet in lock step. Everyone acting in complete independence, simply copying everyone else, cannot lead to stability, let alone the durable, persistent lock-step stability that is seen.