14 ms·
Apple is about to get bitten hard for being a monopoly. I hope the government considers the harshest punishment of all: splitting up Apple into hardware and so
by echelon 6y ago
Apple is about to get bitten hard for being a monopoly.
I hope the government considers the harshest punishment of all: splitting up Apple into hardware and software+services entities.
This is absurd that Apple has built a fiefdom on America's most popular generic computer device. It's a threat to freedom! We can only compute what the overlords allow and can tax? What a crock!
The fact that Apple thinks they can extort more protection money from developers than the government does in taxes is an affront. But the freedom aspect should have everyone out with their pitchforks.
This after Apple created an environment where its users, many of whom have lots of disposable income for buying goods and services, expect apps to be $0.99 and come with free updates for life. Meanwhile Apple's own products are luxury priced. And they still take 30%.
US Government, please force Apple to open up iPhone to any software we want to install. It's a generic computer. It's how we communicate, do banking, do basic shopping, dating, business ... everything. Apple can't be the gatekeepers of 21st century life. It's incredibly damaging to our ability to innovate and succeed as small business owners and entrepreneurs.
Apple, you are the tyrant king. Long have we suffered under your rule. We won't stand for it any longer and we demand our freedom.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 6y agoExactly what I came here to say. Epic Games is large enough to fight this. I think they purposefully chose this fight right here and now because of the looming report on anti trust violations that should be out any day.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- ianmobbs 6y agoYou seem to have forgotten about Android. The solution to anti-trust cases is not a blanket “break them up. In this case, requiring Apple to allow third-party App Stores is going to be the key issue. The lawyers will likely take heavy inspiration from Microsoft’s antitrust suit from the early 00s
- valuearb 6y agoThird party stores would be a disaster for customers and developers, even worse than the ones on Android.
- pauliusj 6y agoHow would that be worse? Always having the option to install whatever you want on device you own is the most pro customer thing ever
- mhh__ 6y agoIn what universe do customers suffer from having the freedom to choose?
- dwighttk 6y agoMy parents' iPhones: 0 sketchy apps or browser plugins My parents' Macs: every sketchy app and browser plugin available on macOS
- gambiting 6y agoI would prefer to live in a world where customers don't have to be treated like children though. Just handle it the same way Android does it - only allow apps from the app store by default, or you can enable unsafe mode and install whatever you want - the choice should always be yours.
- valuearb 6y agoWho cares what you prefer? This is the exact value differentiator between Android and iPhone. If Apple doesn’t secure the device and vet the Apps, you’ve destroyed what made it different, and in its customers eyes, great.
- gambiting 6y agoI literally don't get that argument. Just like on Android, 99% of customers would never ever untick that box and would enjoy the benefit provided by apple-vetted apps, while we as customers would regain control of the devices that we paid for, allowing them to run code that hasn't been vetted by Apple....if you wish to do so. I'd also appreciate if you laid off the personal attacks, thank you.
- valuearb 6y agoApple wins this in a walk-over. And as an iOS developer, I get a lot of benefits from the App Store that makes their 30% more than reasonable.
- paxys 6y agoCool. I am also an iOS developer and get almost nothing for the 30% I pay Apple. It would be trivial to build my own in-app payments system using Stripe for like 3%. Giving customers choice and encouraging competition is a good thing.
- valuearb 6y agoAn in-app purchase system isn’t an App Store, and isn’t remotely similar. You get worldwide access to hundreds of markets in dozens of localized stores all in a system that makes billions of customers feel secure in purchasing from you. You also get Appleto distribute your apps for free as well! Spotify alone uses terabytes a day distributing to free users. Opening up to other app stores would be a disaster for developers. Less secure, more scam are and malware, more confusing, lower consumer confidence, Balkanized app search, higher dev costs to support more stores, and for what? 20% fees at best? Apples margins are publicly documented, no one could run a profitable app store for less than 20%.
- yulaow 6y ago> Apples margins are publicly documented, no one could run a profitable app store for less than 20%. How can you say that if apple didn't allow the competition to exist? We cannot see if someone can innovate enough to cut that margin maybe even far more than what apple made you think is the "minimum to be profitable" because apple does not allow that Isn't this exactly the startup playing field? When there is a market standard of which some pseudo monopolist says "well no one can do better than this" and then a innovative competitor joins in and distrupts?
- valuearb 6y ago
- voidpointercast 6y agoSomething insinuates that you're not being entirely honest in your arguments.
- AnimalMuppet 6y agoCould you be more specific? Or say why you think that? An accusation like that should either not be spoken, or should have something concrete to substantiate it.
- sneeze-slayer 6y agoThe truth is, getting split up isn't even a punishment! When companies get split up for being a monopoly, they usually end up being even more valuable than when they were a monopoly. See Bell Telephone for a good example of this. When IBM unbundled their software from their hardware in response to DoJ antitrust inquiries, it created the modern software industry.
- ac29 6y agoBell isnt a great example because telephone companies are a "natural" monopoly - it doesnt really make sense to have a dozens of phone lines connected to your house in order for there to be competition in the telephone service market. That's why when it was split up, it effectively was only split up into smaller regional monopolies that didnt really compete with each other. Smartphone applications aren't the same - but for a couple bits here, and a cryptographic signature there, any software could run on an iPhone.
- Jerry2 6y ago> Apple is about to get bitten hard for being a monopoly. A monopoly in what? In making their own products?
- mhh__ 6y agoMonopoly is the wrong word but Apple's practices are at least bordering on anti-consumer. The only monopoly apple have is over their own customers i.e. switching away from apple isn't cheap
- cik 6y agoIt's actually dirt cheap. As a consumer I've moved from and to apple repeatedly over the years. The cost has always been nonexistent. I never buy Mac only software. Replacing hardware is the expensive part. But again, if you want to change technology vendors, there's always a cost.
- zackkitzmiller 6y agoSure it is. Android phones are cheap, windows computers can be cheap, a home-build with linux would be cheaper. The only 'expense' is the few hours to relearn a few keystrokes. Yes, that might be an oversimplification, but it's really not that expeisve or difficult to move from one platform to antother.
- ryanbrunner 6y agoUnless your friends are on iMessage, all your documents, contacts and calendar events are on iCloud, your photo library is on Apple Photos, all of which lock you into the Apple ecosystem and aren't available on Android. Sure, you can transition everything off, but I wouldn't call that a pain-free switching cost.
- filleduchaos 6y agoBut why should it be pain-free, though? Or rather, why is it suddenly the government's responsibility to make it pain-free?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- ancorevard 6y agoAs an Apple product user, I find their products+services+software the most enjoyable and more importantly the most trustworthy. I happily pay more $ for that attribute. Alternatives already exist for people who have other priorities (Android etc.).
- regulation_d 6y ago1. It's clearly not a monopoly by any accepted definition. 2. If you don't want to pay their fees, don't use their platform. 3. If enough content providers don't use their platform, consumers we shift to a different one. I think one of the advantages that Sony has had over MSFT in the video game console space has been their exclusive content. 4. Taxes have literally nothing to do with this. The App Store has made life much easier for countless app creators. Are the fees exorbitant? Sure. Is the market capable of correcting this behavior across a reasonable timeline, also yes. I was planning to switch TV devices after Apple's tiff with Spotify. It was resolved because Apple knows that if they don't support the content providers other platforms do, they will lose market share.
- UnpossibleJim 6y agoBy these standards, then no one should be calling for anti-trust cases to going forward against Google, Amazon or Facebook. There are alternatives to all of these, some of them large. Google has Microsoft sized competition; Amazon competes with the likes of Walmart and Target in similar shopping spaces; and Facebook competes with Reddit and has competed with Google (who is now defunct in that area). To be honest, I'm not 100% where I stand with these considering that ISP's haven't been prosecuted for, what seem, clearly more egregious anti-trust violations. These types of cases should come up first, in my opinion, but we are where we are.
- moate 6y ago>>These types of cases should come up first, in my opinion, but we are where we are. Don't worry sir, the legal system is (mostly) asynchronous! You could do both.
- bhupy 6y ago...yes? It’s not clear that there is a real or straightforward anti-trust case to be made against many of these companies (especially Amazon). For some reason the HN echo chamber is convinced that there is an obvious and bulletproof anti-trust case against every big tech company, and that the delay in enforcing it strictly comes down to corruption or some inherent flaw in the justice system.
- comboy 6y ago> US Government, please force Apple to open up iPhone to any software we want to install. It's a generic computer. You have bazillion types of generic computers to choose from. People pay huge overhead to apple exactly because apple makes choices for them - regarding what settings are reasonable to have, what software they want you to use etc. Personally I don't understand monopoly arguments. If we are talking about some ISP, something like Nestle or even social network/apps, I can somewhat understand it. But here? Users are people who bought Apple hardware to use it based on rules set up by Apple. I'm not much fan of Apple, I sincerely want to understand the monopoly argument. It seems to me as if people would want to split BMW because .. I don't know we want to be able to install our own custom AC. Because maintenance of the stock one is too expensive.
- surfpel 6y ago> People pay huge overhead to apple exactly because apple makes choices for them... That’s exactly why I use Apple products. I don’t have time to mess around with third party stores and risk security issues when I need an app that doesn’t want to be on the App Store. I’m ok with paying 30% more as a consumer for the simplicity and peace of mind. This isn’t the consumers getting angry - it’s developers. That’s why this comment and other dissenting opinions always get downvoted on HN. Not saying devs don’t matter, but there is another side to this that people here don’t want to consider.
- colinmhayes 6y agoI'm pretty unhappy as a consumer.
- mortenjorck 6y agoAs must be repeated in every thread on antitrust: Antitrust law is about much more than just monopoly. Apple doesn't have one, nor do they need one to be prosecuted for anticompetitive behavior and abuse of market position. If you're not familiar with the difference between the Sherman Act and the Clayton Act, this is a good primer: https://www.britannica.com/event/Clayton-Antitrust-Act https://www.britannica.com/event/Clayton-Antitrust-Act Apple is about to get bitten hard, not for being a monopoly, but for anticompetitive business practices.
- bgorman 6y agoApple can just point to mobile Safari. There is nothing stopping you from building whatever you want on the web these days.
- AsyncAwait 6y agoEven there, they limit PWAs and do not allow competitors to use their own engines.
- jedberg 6y agoI can list a ton of APIs that are available to native iPhone apps that aren't available to apps via Safari. Push notifications being the most notable, in part because they are purposely not supporting an open standard.
- inetknght 6y ago> I can list a ton of APIs that are available to native iPhone apps that aren't available to apps via Safari. And thank God for that! I don't want websites in Safari to have the APIs available to a native app!
- la_oveja 6y agoYou would be asked to give permission to these APIs, just like you do in a normal web browser.
- ddevault 6y agoIf you own the hardware, you can use any software you want on it. Period. End of discussion. If the government needs to step in to make it so, then so be it. The Apple bootlickers and capitalist drones in this thread need to get with the program. The time for tolerating opposition to Right to Repair and consumer ownership over the products they buy has long past.
- saagarjha 6y ago> The Apple bootlickers and capitalist drones in this thread need to get with the program. Drew, you know better than to comment like that.
- viro 6y agoThats not how secure devices work! if that what you want there are hundreds of android phone companies.
- ddevault 6y agoThe idea that a centralized authority collecting taxes is necessary for a "secure device" is a flaming crock of shit. This nonsense is a convenient excuse Apple uses to abuse its position. For an obvious alternative, compare the history of malware - - or even just programs with spyware sidecars - getting in Linux distributions to the same history of malware in the Apple app store.
- viro 6y agocentralized authority collecting taxes? I think you meant centralized authority of Trust. very similar to secure boot on PCs. you also seem to underestimate the sheer amount of trolly "malware"/ scripts out there for linux.
- ddevault 6y agoIf they were just there for trust, then the 3rd most valuable company on Earth, valued at over a trillion dollars, with billions in cold hard cash, would have no need for the tithe. Make no mistake, Apple is rent-seeking, not establishing trust. How much do you actually think it costs to provide trust? 30%? That's obscene. Many organizations provide better levels of trust for free. Wake up, there's no need for you to subserve yourself to these malpractices.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- donor20 6y agoWow - HN reliably comes out with just incredible legal analysis, and not in a good way. Apple delivers products that are supported FAR far longer than android. Yes, they charge everyone a premium for this. One reason people don't mind their kids / grandparents etc using apple is precisely because apple takes care of things. Let's be 100% clear here - once apple allows random apps to bill you in random ways the endless scams will be here in days. Seriously - even for subscriptions most providers you find out thing renewed after the fact when you get your statement, then have to remember to fight the auto-renew. Apple (at least for me) sends me out an email IN ADVANCE telling me what will renew. Next, cancelling autorenews often requires phone calls. Ie, you can only cancel 90 days in advance, but have to cancel by renewal date and while you can sign up online you can't cancel online. Apple, in the same email they send me, tells me how to cancel. I hope folks pushing scam apps get bitten HARD for their crappy behavior. And the idea of apple as monopoly (22% market share in phones, even less in computers) seems a total stretch. However, because of all these policies, they might have a monpoply on very long term supported high quality devices that behave how you expect. They even cracked down on the scam battery replacements on resale (ie, folks would put cheapo third party batteries in that made it look like battery life was good that would die in months). Again lots of complaints from HN folks, but for average users this helped them avoid the scammers.
- basch 6y agoMy spidey sense is screaming poes law. It's like every overly simplistic argument in one post, and no replies. Kudos to the author for encapsulating all the arguments that dont need to take place again and grouping them in one tree.
- donor20 6y agoHuh? If you can't engage the discussion don't engage. "Your spidy sense is screaming"... ? "Kudos for encapsulating all the arguments that don't need to take place...". I feel like folks don't have a feel for that the history of anti-trust action has been used for. In many cases you have clear to very clear anti-competitive behavior. Move in next door, sell at a big loss, drive out competition, then restore pricing. So you take and establish market power through predetory behavior. What's challenging about the case with apple is that they have always run their own app store, and the success of that store has attracted both users and developers. They have had the same terms for a very long time. The normal anti-competitive type behavior would be to do no fee for developers if they signed exclusive agreements, then after you had 80% of market you'd switch terms and no one could fight it. Google did this with things like maps, super cheap for developers, no one else could compete, then it was 4x the price (I forget now) and we had to wait a bit for others to catchup so we had alternatives. My cable company did this (we had a wireless provider show up, prices dropped overnight to keep them out, then when they left some areas that were harder to serve cable co raised right back up.) There is an alternative in the market here too, a well funded one. Google has an app store. Samsung has an app store. Carriers preload apps that cannot be removed to "help" their customers. Some companies build in basically backdoors to android so they can load all sorts of apps after the fact (mostly advertising). Apple does not allow any of that - they are FAMOUS for wanting control. They don't allow the carriers to preload bloatware and never have allowed it. They don't allow them to do their own auto-updating apps or app stores. They support their phones for incredibly long periods compared to much of their competition (some android phones SHIP with software 2 years old and literally never get an update). When you buy and apple you are guaranteed not to get this stuff - and some people like that. Does this make it illegal? It a long way from a standard anti-trust case. They've never had anyone else competing with them to take share. They were also the first with the glass face smartphone so this was their market, their actual market share in segment has been going DOWN not up a long time despite the laughter of their competitors when they introduced the iphone. So, is there a commercial reason for them to behave this way - sure. I'm curious - why post slams on HN rather than discussing the topic? Just don't reply.
- nickysielicki 6y agoApple doesn’t have a majority of the marketshare in cell phones or laptops. The only market they’ve won is tablets with the iPad. The idea that Apple has a monopoly in the realm of computing is ridiculous. I can’t tell if the level of hyperbole in your comment is sarcastic or not, so apologies if whoosh.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- gruez 6y ago>US Government, please force Apple to open up iPhone to any software we want to install. It's a generic computer. It's how we communicate, do banking, do basic shopping, dating, business ... everything. Apple can't be the gatekeepers of 21st century life. It's incredibly damaging to our ability to innovate and succeed as small business owners and entrepreneurs. You're going to be disappointed, if the android ecosystem is anything to go by. Of the OEMs that bother to unlock their bootloaders, only a fraction release kernel sources. Nearly all SoCs require custom kernels (which contain the requisite drivers) to run. Not having them means you're dead in the water as far as a usable system (working wifi, graphics, sound, modem, sensors, camera) is concerned. The only reason why OEMs even bother releasing kernel sources is because they're legally obligated to by GPL. Good luck getting that to happen with apple. You're almost always better off getting something like the pinephone or librem, rather than buying an iphone and hoping that the community can salvage something out of it. edit: Due to bootloader exploits, people were able to get alternate OSes running on iphones. As expected, the hardware support is flakey at best. https://web.archive.org/web/20110714042818/http://www.idroidproject.org/wiki/Status https://web.archive.org/web/20110714042818/http://www.idroid...
- lewiscollard 6y ago> Long have we suffered under your rule. Who is this "we"? It definitely doesn't include me, as I do not own an iPhone and never will. If _you_ own one on the other hand...I presume you knew about Apple's practices and Apple's lock on their devices before you bought one. Why did you buy one? Your reminder that iOS has 24.82% market share on mobile. That is not anything like a "monopoly" in any meaningful sense of the word. https://gs.statcounter.com/os-market-share/mobile/worldwide https://gs.statcounter.com/os-market-share/mobile/worldwide
- jmpman 6y agoDoes Microsoft take a cut when someone purchases on Xbox? Sony on the PlayStation? How is this different?
- georgespencer 6y agoMore importantly: can Sony sell PlayStation games on Xbox?
- filleduchaos 6y agoI'm not quite sure what you mean by this, because it doesn't seem particularly relevant or important to this situation? It's the equivalent of asking if Google can sell Android apps on iOS.
- georgespencer 6y agoThe point is that every app store has arbitrary limitations placed on it by its operator. Valve takes a 30% cut which I can't circumvent, and guess what -- if I want to use a payment method which Valve doesn't support, I need to do it through a web interface and the user gets kicked out of the game. Nothing is preventing Epic from doing in-app purchases in the game, they just don't like the margin they can achieve. And nothing is stopping them from doing the same micro transactions via their website or another interface. All market places have limitations placed on them by the operators. If developers don't like them they should withhold their software from the platform.
- filleduchaos 6y agoAh, I see. I agree with your point actually, I just didn't quite catch it from your initial comment. I personally don't like the limitations (I disagree vehemently with a 30% cut), but that doesn't necessarily mean it's the government's job to step in. I think a lot of people are conflating "I disagree with this" and "it should literally be illegal".
- Seanambers 6y agoBut what if that is what I as an Apple customer actually pays for - a walled garden where everything is controlled? As a consumer it doesn't hurt me at all. All apps on the app store adhere to a certain set of rules and if they don't they are removed. It also means that payment is controlled by Apple, which is fine by me. I trust Apple more than I trust Epic or any other potential company that wishes to bypass App store rules wrt payments.. And i buy many Apps priced way above 99 cents.
- Angeo34 6y agoYour name is echeleon and you plead to the sanity and morals of the US gov for the sake of its people? It's like asking Mao why he isn't giving the Taiwanese land for free inside the PRC
- tbrock 6y agoThere isn’t anything about this that’s makes it a monopoly or any different from selling items in any other marketplace. You want to sell here? There’s a cut that goes to the house. I don’t know why people get in a tizzy about it, you knew the rules going in and they haven’t changed.
- alkonaut 6y agoCompanies should compete IN markets, they shouldn't set up their own. Customers aren't in a position to "just switch platforms" because they don't like what Apple or Amazon are doing. This shouldn't be seen in the light of "is what they are doing so bad that they need to be stopped"? It should be seen as "would consumers be better off if someone intervened?".
- greggman3 6y agoAgreed. Also the Supreme Court ruled that code is speech. Apple being the gatekeeper to code in an iOS device is equivalent to censorship. yes I know some people define censorship as only by the government but would you ok if you could only browse internet sites approved by Apple? Only watch videos approved by Apple? Only read books approved by Apple? Only listen to music approved by Apple? Software is no different. It's another form of media just like books, video, music, and as such you should be just as upset that you can't run whatever you want whether it's game portals, streamed games, porn apps, dev apps, whatever.
- lilyball 6y agoFree Speech is strictly an issue with the government, it does not ever apply to non-governmental platforms.
- RonanTheGrey 6y agoAnd anyone who argues from that position should understand exactly what they are asking the entirety of the human race until the far future to accept. You REALLY don't get how shortsighted that is? If the Constitution were written today it would very likely use less strict language. Free Speech cannot be protected by law if the people themselves don't value it.
- sbahr001 6y agoIf apple makes the case that the App Store is a feature, which it is, and not a right; They can make a strong case against the monopoly(really duopoly with Google Play). People forget that the iPhone launched with no app store, and its only 3rd party app was google maps. Apple only add the app store because developers want to develop apps, and apple said okay, and provided an interface that allows them to maintain the quality of their product. Apple could kill the app store tomorrow if they wanted to, and replace them with partnerships with various companies; technically app store apps are partnerships with Apple. The iTunes music store works that way: it is a partnership with record companies, who are not required to participate; Ex. Beatles catalog was unavailable for years. Epic games does not have to participate in the iOS market, they have a "CHOICE"; similar to how a lot of game developers don't make a Mac OS version. Granted it would not be in Apple's best interest to remove the app store, but technically it is a product not a feature. The only anti-trust argument you can really make is bundled apps. Apple will disapprove apps that appear to do functionally the same thing. This is anti-competitive, and if Apple switches there stance on that then they are fine. Also, user's have a choice to remove most default apple apps, so they once again customers have a choice to use them or not. I will say that 30% is a bit excessive, for most apps nowadays. Back in 2008 til about 2012-2014(ish) it made sense. Storage, bandwidth, and credit card processing were extremely expense. A million downloads would bankrupt small companies, especially free apps. Not only that when there were less apps in the app store, it did make marketing cheaper. That advantage is no longer the case with the oversaturation of apps. At the end of the day, Apple can do what they want to do as can developers(not provide their apps); which means that it is not anti-competitive/anti-trust. Also, iOS is such a small percentage of the market, and user's/developers have a choice to go to android.
- m3kw9 6y agoIf you are using Apples platform, why act like you want to live rent free?
- Shivetya 6y agoCan is not a monopoly, you can still get all the apps you want on any other smart phone and you are not compelled to buy an iOS device. Unless you are claiming by having the best device, the device you want, that makes it an unfair advantage because you don't want to make a different choice. Now the solution if I was in charge of Apple is simple, you want a software unlocked phone then have at it, it cost double and all privacy options are absent.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- dmos62 6y agoThat's a slippery slope. Next we'll start regulating anticompetitive practices in IT in general. /s
- dillondoyle 6y agoWhat is the argument against, and dangers, of simply maintaining their app store where they continue their strict quality control & take the fees, while also allowing 3rd party app stores? App devs can choose to participate in Apple's store and pay fee or not or both. 3p allows users to load any apps at their own risk. Put a permissions popup explaining the danger. Maybe it would open up more jailbreaking. Don't allow drive by downloads, users would have to download the 3rd party stores from the app store. Probably only the most determined / technical users would load a 3p store thus protecting the majority
- rockarage 6y agoReally? If we are being candid, many software developers helped crowned the Tyrant king. The majority of developers focused on building for iOS and treated Android as a second class citizen. Developers set the prices and in a race to the bottom, many developers set the price to $0.99. I remember the apps that had reasonable prices were often criticized by consumers because other developers set their prices so low. 30% take was there from the start of the app store before Apple become the most profitable smartphone maker. Developers should never have agreed to the take in the early days, but short term thinking prevailed. If the vast majority of developers from the start refused to build for the iPhone until Apple had favorable terms or gave customers the option to allow third-party installs things would be different. Perhaps developers should work together to solve the problem they help create? Are developers want Apple to change would are they willing to coordinate a response? A coordinated response could mean the top 50 developers building mobile web apps & writing a letter to Apple that they are removing their apps from the Apps store and alerting their customers as well. The idea is not so far fetched, see: https://deadline.com/2019/07/cbs-blackout-directv-u-verse-att-contract-dispute-1202649633/ https://deadline.com/2019/07/cbs-blackout-directv-u-verse-at... Will a web app have all the features of the iOS app? of course not, but if Apple wins the legal case, this seems like the only real option to get Apple to change. Because most of Apple costumers are not bothered by Apple developers policy.
- innagadadavida 6y agoBy this argument, fortnite also has a monopoly position with all things being sold in their market place - they don’t let me sell highly discounted gold skin and have it unlock features in their game. This is just a battle between the billionaires, nothing to be gained by the rest of us.
- parasubvert 6y agoThis is utter nonsense.
- AnimalMuppet 6y agoYour comment would be more persuasive if you said why you think it's nonsense. As is, your comment is pretty worthless.
- loldk 6y agoI wish we wouldn't just say "Apple" and could name the teams and individuals responsible for such strategies. Surely there are customers and employees who deserve better. And we deserve better too as a society than to place blame on made up entities that we can't address as the root cause, so we keep repeating the same mistakes... when someone somewhere is actually doing these idiotic, destructive things.
- baddox 6y agoOn the other hand, I like several Apple products and I'm confident their products would get much much worse if the company was effectively split up, and I suspect the vast majority of Apple customers would feel the same way. I'm not sure if people who feel very strongly as you do would consider that possibility, or if there are other principles at play that don't involve customer satisfaction.
- lrvick 6y agoYou could just not use Apple products. Crazy talk I know, but many of us get by just fine without them.