3 ms·
Apple and Google are able to gatekeep what you can install on entire generations of devices, from smartphones to tablets. Their power to gatekeep billion dollar
by heavyset_go 6y ago
Apple and Google are able to gatekeep what you can install on entire generations of devices, from smartphones to tablets. Their power to gatekeep billion dollar markets needs to be looked at through the lens of antitrust legislation.
- Sargos 6y agoMore people in the world use mobile devices than PCs by a huge margin. These two corporations essentially decide what apps humanity is allowed to use and how all software and services are built. That is a lot of power and it shouldn't be used for the benefit of a single corporation. Pardon my hyperbole but this is nearing the level of a human rights issue. The freedom to run the apps and services you want to is so core to the way our society works that most people don't think about it. Having one corporation dictate how all apps for the entire world work is not compatible with a free society and actively harms innovation. This is becoming a big problem and regulations are being very slow to react to it.
- josephcsible 6y agoDon't lump Google in with Apple here. Android lets you sideload apps.
- MikusR 6y agoApple yes. Google no. You can install 3rd party stores and freely sideload apps.
- heavyset_go 6y agoI don't think "freely" is the adverb I'd use to describe the sideloading process, considering how "freely" and effortlessly I can install apps in Google's preferred way through the Play Store. Google made it so third party app stores like F-Droid can't even implement auto-upgrading, or background installations of apps. App stores outside of the Play Store and 3rd party apps are 2nd class citizens on Android. It is similar to how Gatekeeper works in macOS. Developers that didn't pay Apple $100 a year to develop and notarize software have their apps get treated like they're radioactive by Gatekeeper.
- Vendan 6y agoGoogle gatekeeps by default but you can trivially bypass and install custom app stores or sideload apps. Apple gatekeeps, and does everything in its power to prevent you from bypassing that. Seems like a rather striking difference...
- heavyset_go 6y agoThird party app stores can't implement background installations, auto-upgrading, or batch installs because of the restrictions Google put in place on Android. Using third party app stores is hindered experience on Android. The Play Store can do background installations, auto-upgrading and batch installs of software, while competitors can't. That's anticompetitive behavior in my book.
- Vendan 6y agoI wasn't aware of all that, thanks, but I still think that Apple's stuff is a whole different ballgame.