3 ms·
There isn't a symbolic representation of plot semantics. No one cares that A thinks B, they care why A thinks B - and they care even more about what it might me
by TheOtherHobbes 6y ago
There isn't a symbolic representation of plot semantics. No one cares that A thinks B, they care why A thinks B - and they care even more about what it might mean for what happens next.
Plots aren't a series of events, they're a series of motivational challenges for the characters. The heart of a plot is how they respond to the challenges, and a good plot has a consistent theme which develops a coherent series of related challenges through superficially different events.
The mechanical specifics of the challenges are almost secondary.
- crazygringo 6y agoI've done a fair bit of screenwriting, including taking classes in it, and that's really not the case at all. You're confusing plot with other things. Plot literally does boil down telling a story in beats where each beat is essentially a character wants something, tries to get it, and either succeeds or fails. String together 80 of these and you've got a film. Now obviously there is much more to writing, like character (which is what you're describing), tests of character, etc. Which is why I talked about plot and character and dialog. But plot really is just "a series of events" that needs to be sequenced very carefully. Which is an important lesson for writers to learn, because beginning writers often focus entirely on character and motivation, and neglect plot mechanics, which makes for a boring, meandering, not-compelling-at-all screenplay.
- TheOtherHobbes 6y ago80 beats of that will give you McMovie or McNovel, and they're popular enough. You can even buy beat by beat formulaic breakdowns of when specific plot twists and other events are supposed to happen. But no one will care unless there's a coherent motivation linking the plot points together. To give an extreme example a character who tries to buy a spoon, followed by a car, followed by a laptop, followed by a kite, and so on for another 70-odd beats, isn't going to make for much of a story. It won't matter if they succeed or not - unless there's a motivation for all of those events that explains the action and puts it into a relatable context, which illustrates character through challenges and conflict. But not too much, because readers/viewers need a mystery. The mistake beginning writers make is trying to illustrate character and motivation through internal monologuing and introspection, flashbacks and infodumps, and emotional impressions rather than through plot actions. This goes too far the other way and you end up in lit fic where nothing much happens for pages on end, but it does it very beautifully. Or - more often - self-indulgently and rather boringly. Meanwhile novice genre writers follow the template with a call to action, refusal, and all the other stock steps, but it's still hollow and uninteresting because the character doesn't have any character, passion, or inner tension, and that makes them boring in a different way.