4 ms·
Hi everyone, the Rust core team has been talking about making a statement on this, but I left this comment in a personal capacity yesterday: ------------------
by steveklabnik 6y ago
Hi everyone, the Rust core team has been talking about making a statement on this, but I left this comment in a personal capacity yesterday:
------------------------
Mozilla employs a small number of people to work on Rust fulltime, and many of the Servo people contributed to Rust too, even if it wasn't their job. They also pay for the hosting bill for crates.io. They also own a trademark on Rust, Cargo, and the logos of both.
Two people from the Rust team have posted about their situation, one was laid off and one was not. Unsure about the others. Many of the Servo folks (and possibly all, it's not 100% clear yet but it doesn't look good) have been laid off.
The vast majority of contributors and team members are non-Mozilla, though the Mozilla folk are very important. Rust will survive. This situation is very painful, and it has the possibility of being more so, but (thanks to a lot of work from people (not speaking of myself here) who used to be at Mozilla!) Rust is bigger than Mozilla, and has been on a long road towards diversification. Some other companies have stepped up to pay a bunch of the bills that Mozilla used to pay, namely Amazon and Microsoft. Here's hoping that we get even more involvement in the future.
- lachlan-sneff 6y agoThank you for commenting here Steve. The fallout from the layoffs is possibly quite harrowing but, from my biased point of view, this may be a watershed moment for Rust. It'll have to expand beyond its incubating organization. (And don't cut yourself short, your actions are a significant part of why Rust has such a promising future.)
- mcqueenjordan 6y agoTotally agree, Rust will survive. AWS is investing heavily in Rust. If anyone who is reading this was affected by these layoffs and you want to continue to work in Rust, get in touch with me. We have many Rust opportunities open across the company on a variety of different teams.
- capableweb 6y agoAny Rustaceans who have been working at Mozilla, have probably done so for the mission that Mozilla work on (publicly), not too earn a ton of money. Amazon/AWS, who's main goal is closed down infrastructure, is the opposite of that mission. Worth keeping in mind when trying to recruit people from the opposite spectrum of yourself.
- mcqueenjordan 6y agoThanks for the feedback. I disagree with your premise and your characterizations, but that's what opinions are for! I believe the success of Rust, as a technical goal, can transcend the business goals of whatever organization uses it. Solidifying the future of Rust is a noble goal, and it would be a huge win for our industry.
- say_it_as_it_is 6y agoIt could be a major win if layoffs result in a multiplier effect where concentrated Rust talent now spreads across industries. However, this can amount to a net loss if those with bleeding edge Rust skills and experience cannot continue putting them to use. Further, unused expertise atrophies. After the Great Depression, the New York City public schools became some of the best in the country as those with amazing credentials and work experience were displaced and needed jobs. The same can happen with Mozilla's layoffs, where Rust can spread faster and have a great impact on software development, but only if people can put their bleeding edge skills to best use.
- sjwmozilla 6y agoIt's interesting that you decide not make an actual argument in disagreement, perhaps knowing well that you don't have one.
- say_it_as_it_is 6y agoThe Mozilla layoffs indicate that the mission you speak of has ended. It's over. It was at best a business experiment with a socially progressive slant, capturing the hearts and minds of employees in exchange for their commitment to company objectives. Unfortunately, those responsible for the plan are not held as accountable for it failing to achieve their business objectives.
- AsyncAwait 6y ago> It was at best a business experiment with a socially progressive slant I appreciate you specifically pointing out "socially progressive", rather than just "progressive", because corporations often use social progressiveness, (relatively cheap), as a mask for economic conservatism.
- AsyncAwait 6y agoWould AWS ever consider hiring someone full-time to work on the compiler itself?
- mcqueenjordan 6y agoGet in touch with me. (@amazon.com email is in my profile.) I know the right people to get you in touch with to figure out if this could work. It doesn't seem far-fetched to me.
- AsyncAwait 6y agoI didn't mean me specifically, just the concept in general, but that's good to hear.
- sjwmozilla 6y agoI hope they will get toilet breaks?
- klft 6y agoDo you think it would be feasible to fund a team of core developers directly by the community? A lot of people love Rust and might bei willing to contribute a small amount of money regularely to keep Rust independent from corporate politics.
- steveklabnik 6y agoI am not sure; to be honest, I am a bit skeptical of individuals being able to get enough money together. It's just math. We will always do our best to make sure that no one single company controls Rust, but we do also want Rust to be useful to industry, and so we do want to listen to our users, no matter where they come from.
- klft 6y agoIt might be an interesting experiment for the ex-Mozilla rust team to launch a kickstarter (or similar) project to get them funded for one year. So it would not be individuals but a team with some high-level goals they plan to work on for the next year. I have no idea how many people would fund a project like this but it would be a fast and low cost experiment to find that out. I would not position this as "the people vs. the industry", it would be just an additional option to move Rust forward.
- gnomeria 6y agoThat is indeed interesting. I've thought about mentioning http://aturon.github.io/sponsor/ http://aturon.github.io/sponsor/ but then I realized you said about not individuals but a team. So I guess crowdfunded project idea is not bad at all. I mean there probably some rewards tier to have some tokens or souvenier
- steveklabnik 6y agoPast the edit window, so I'll just add this: https://twitter.com/rustlang/status/1294024734804508679 https://twitter.com/rustlang/status/1294024734804508679
- The_rationalist 6y agoWhen can we see an * up to date list of the affected core team members? There's at least three and not two like said before (I'm referring to the addition of alexcrichton)
- steveklabnik 6y agoI feel slightly weird about being so specific about it, but there were only two people at Mozilla who were on the core team: Niko and Manish. Alex hasn't been on the core team since February. He's still on the Cargo teams and the wasm WG though.