7 ms·
This shows that open-source in general is expensive for Mozilla but cheap for the likes of Apple, Microsoft and Google who own their own Web browsers and have o
by rvz 6y ago
This shows that open-source in general is expensive for Mozilla but cheap for the likes of Apple, Microsoft and Google who own their own Web browsers and have other open-source programming languages maintained by some of their employees full time.
The actual reality of this is that they are still kept alive by a direct competitor for decades and haven't made anything to generate significant sources of revenue. Maybe they should turn into a Rust consultancy of some sort. I don't know.
If the mission statement is about 'privacy' then it doesn't make much sense to continue to bite the hand that feeds them as its up to Google if they want to re-new their contract with Mozilla; which unsuprisingly they had to.
- thomascgalvin 6y agoFor Apple, Microsoft, and Google, their open source activities are all loss leaders for their profitable ventures. Apple sells hardware, and most of their software offerings, like MacOS, their office suite, and Safari, and given away to convince people to buy that hardware. Also, it's not like they're spending a whole lot of time making Sarafi the best browser around. Microsoft's web browser was created (and bundled) specifically to prevent the web from disrupting their monopoly on the desktop, and their new browser is just a fork of Chromium. Google's browser was a way for Google to drive web technologies in service of their advertising platform. Mozilla's open source efforts are/were a loss leader for ... nothing. Their work was motivated by altruism, not profit, and that turned out to be, well, not profitable. That's why they're pivoting; altruism alone wasn't enough to pay the bills.
- lostapathy 6y agoIs open source a loss leader for Apple, really? Or is it something they mostly get for free, but have to contribute a little back to shape it how they want? The point I read from GP, at least, was that open source is cheap for these big corps because they get a ton of benefit for it, but non-profit (either orgs or individuals) are bearing the brunt of the cost.
- GeekyBear 6y ago> contribute a little back Clang was certainly an in-house Apple project from the start, and it would be hard to claim that it hasn't been a project that has seen huge uptake outside of Apple.
- cataphract 6y agoThis is not entirely accurate. LLVM was started by Chris Lattner before he was hired by Apple, which were probably spooked by gcc going GPLv3 by then.
- GeekyBear 6y agoLLVM and Clang are both projects started by Chris Lattner, but they are not the same project. Do you mean that Clang leverages LLVM on the back end?
- sirn 6y agoYes for LLVM, but Clang was made entirely while Chris Lattner was employed by Apple[1]. Before Clang you have to use LLVM GCC frontend (llvm-gcc) to compile C code under LLVM, which was the default in Xcode until 5.x (although Clang was added in Xcode 4.x, I remembered it being quite unstable at the time). [1]: https://lists.llvm.org/pipermail/cfe-dev/2007-July/000000.html https://lists.llvm.org/pipermail/cfe-dev/2007-July/000000.ht... (announcement)
- Jasper_ 6y agoApple is the primary contributor and maintainer of WebKit at this point since Google forked Blink off of it. There are consulting firms like Igalia that work on all three engines, and they're funded mostly from big clients like Bloomberg and banks so developers there can use flexbox and CSS grid everywhere. Google sometimes works on WebKit as well if they want to try to improve compatibility of websites, but the project is mostly Apple employees now.
- lern_too_spel 6y agoKHTML has an LGPL license. WebCore forked from that, so its source code must be released with a compatible license.
- hinkley 6y agoThis 'broken' goes all the way back to Marc Andreesen. He leaves a publicly funded team building a web browser, starts a commercial entity, and for whatever reason they don't feel they can charge for their browser funded by private equity. You could in fact buy it in a box at the local electronics store, but with the pricing I suspect most of that money went to distribution, not NCC. So they try to find other ways to make money, like their web server and overpriced consulting (for their notoriously awful web server). The entire dotcom era then emulated this pattern. There were certainly other logistical reasons for it (like the state of credit card billing at the time), but I can't help but feel like this was the rock that started the avalanche of adware and commercial cyberstalking. And so here we are 25 years later, and the last remnant of Netscape is trying to build the free browser and not much to fund it. I'm kinda surprised it lasted this long. To be fair to them though, and particularly on the topic of this story, if they were going to build a free browser, it always should have been on the community to contribute to the dev tools. It's the part of the browser that we have a vested interest in. And in fact, it used to be that way. Firefox had no dev tools at the beginning. They copied a very popular add-on, which I now recall made absolutely no sense to me at the time. I felt like their attempt was less effective in several ways, and why are they shouldering out this tool that made them in the first place (as GP asserts, nobody develops first-class support on a browser they can't debug in, or at least not when there is an alternative.)
- andruby 6y agoThe tool was firebug. It was a big difference when browsers didn’t offer built in tools.
- irrational 6y agoFirebug is what got me to use Firefox in the beginning. I continued to use Firefox out of habit after firebug went away, though the replacement was inferior (it still is). Now... I might have to switch to Chrome, but I really don’t want to due to privacy issues. I suppose I could use it just for development.
- 6y ago
- joepie91_ 6y ago> Mozilla's open source efforts are/were a loss leader for ... nothing. Their work was motivated by altruism, not profit, and that turned out to be, well, not profitable. That's why they're pivoting; altruism alone wasn't enough to pay the bills. Except it didn't turn out to be "not profitable". Leaving aside the issue of dependence on companies like Google and the frankly ridiculous exec compensation, all publicly available data shows that Mozilla is very financially healthy and has been for a long time. The claim of financial issues is implied by the corporatespeak press release, but simply not supported by any evidence that I've seen.
- shock 6y ago> altruism alone wasn't enough to pay the bills. That certainly depends on how big the bills are.
- ThrowawayR2 6y ago> "The actual reality of this is that they are still kept alive by a direct competitor for decades and haven't made anything to generate significant sources of revenue. Maybe they should turn into a Rust consultancy of some sort. I don't know." The odds of them being able to build a business that that replaces the several hundred million they get from Google (which is essentially pure profit, not even revenue) are essentially nil. The instant Google decides they're no longer useful, Mozilla is going to go poof. I'm inclined to agree with others who have said they should be building their own endowment. It's almost malpractice on the part of their leadership not to.
- kanox 6y ago> The instant Google decides they're no longer useful, Mozilla is going to go poof. People keep repeating this but couldn't Bing replace Google as the default? The "default search engine" position is actually worth money.
- LanceH 6y agoIf they drop from 2 bidders to 1 it becomes a lot less valuable.
- julesnp 6y agoIt's worth money as long as the company that runs the search engine is willing to pay for it. In a scenario where Google no longer sees the value in that arrangement, what value would Microsoft be seeing in it?
- chubot 6y agoAlso, Mozilla has had revenue from other search providers, like Yahoo: https://gizmodo.com/yahoo-s-insanely-bad-deal-to-pay-mozilla-375-million-a-1821043679 https://gizmodo.com/yahoo-s-insanely-bad-deal-to-pay-mozilla... So I don't think their position is as fragile as people suggest. The problem is declining market share, not that they are tied to Google per se. (Of course Google is by far the strongest search engine, but it's plausible that Mozilla could survive with Bing.)
- 6y ago
- SilasX 6y agoI think it shows that Mozilla blew all their (quite significant) funding on quixotic adventures that had little to do with their core mission of an open internet where users controlled their experience.
- iaml 6y agoI don't understand why they don't just create a patreon/github sponsors/bitcoin donations for core ff/rust/mdn teams salaries and call it a day. I'm sure they'll get more than enough contributions to make it viable.
- _jal 6y ago> I'm sure they'll get more than enough How sure are you? Would you be sure enough to bet your child's health care on it?
- AsyncAwait 6y agoAs an aside, the fact that in the U.S. your healthcare is tied to your employer is absolutely nuts.
- zettadam 6y agoIn other countries your health insurance payments are deducted automatically from your paycheck before you get it. Is it not the same or very similar?
- AsyncAwait 6y ago> In other countries your health insurance payments are deducted automatically from your paycheck before you get it. Is it not the same or very similar? Not at all, In places with national single insurer system, (medicare for all), like the UK where am based, the way it works is that you do contribute to National Insurance effectively as part of your taxes, (usually less than you'd pay in the U.S.), BUT if you switch employers or even are unemployed, you still have that healthcare available to you. Also, all the doctors, hospitals etc. are technically always "in network".
- wolco 6y agoHealth insurance? Sounds like a scam. It comes from income taxes and other revenue in Canada.
- 6y ago
- Recursing 6y agoApple, Microsoft, and Google: * Forbid alternative browser engines on their platform. * Bundle their browser in a leading operating system. * Use their massive Web properties to drive downloads of their own browser.
- gamblor956 6y agoMicrosoft and Google allow alternative browser engines. Apple does not.
- dreamcompiler 6y agoOn IOS. On a Mac you can run any browser engine you want.
- leeoniya 6y agoi wonder when the other shoe will drop. maybe as part of the ARM and iOS/macOS consolidation. things are much more likely to go the iOS route given it's already ARM.
- the_other 6y agoApple will lose their entire Mac audience if this happens. Slowly, but surely.
- alwillis 6y agoi wonder when the other shoe will drop. maybe as part of the ARM and iOS/macOS consolidation. There’s no other shoe. There's no known technical reason why all the major browsers shouldn't be available natively when ARM Macs start shipping in a few months.
- perryizgr8 6y agoThere's no technical reason for iOS to not support alternative browsers from the start. It's not about technical reasons.
- joshlemer 6y agoI've been saying for years that Mozilla should have a services department to do consulting and corporate support for Rust. No idea why they'd leave millions of dollars on the floor like that.
- khuey 6y agoMozilla's revenue is $400M a year. A few million dollars in consulting revenue isn't going to move the needle.
- toast0 6y agoConsulting would offer an avenue for growth. If you do well, you can hire more people and make more revenue. Both of Mozilla's likely search revenue partners in the US are also competitors and both use anti-competitive means to push their own browsers. Building their own search revenue stream isn't going to happen on $400M annually. And I don't think Yandex or Baidu are planning to seriously address the US market. Also, I could be wrong, but I thought ad spending was way down this year.
- joshlemer 6y agoWe're talking 10s of millions here. Plenty of consultancies make 20million+ per year in revenue. It could even be the start of a new branch with value adds like Confluent, Databricks, which are more in the range of $150-200million.
- coldtea 6y ago>Mozilla's revenue is $400M a year. And it can easily drop to $0M a year. Meanwhile, a good consulting can grow to tens of millions, and even be acquired by a company like MS, etc.
- zelly 6y agoI've said on here for years that Mozilla will only be remembered for Rust and they should double down on that (to the exclusion of FF if necessary) and people got mad. It's their only product people are enthusiastic about, the only product of theirs that has a positive slope on Google Trends. They could have been what JetBrains is to Kotlin. They could have sold support, training, consultantcy, IDEs, tooling, hosted conferences, etc.
- jbaber 6y agoHmm... Amazon should buy Firefox and keep it going for the good of humanity at a loss. Like its owner did for The Post.