2 ms·
> It looks clearly as if Epic remotely activated this direct payment option, thereby bypassing Apple's App Review. Is that against Apple's store terms? Becaus
by dgellow 6y ago
> It looks clearly as if Epic remotely activated this direct payment option, thereby bypassing Apple's App Review.
Is that against Apple's store terms? Because that's a common feature of ReactNative based app, you can update them by deploying new JS files without having to pass by a new app store release.
- cornedor 6y agoDepends, this is allowed to some degree, buit if you change functionality you have to go trough the review process. Changing the payment method definitely should go trough the review process.
- CreepGin 6y agoYes, it's directly against the terms, but in practice it's not always enforceable. I deployed multiple apps to the App Store using RN and PhoneGap in the past. Some were rejected for basically using these web based technologies. So my experience is that if you're using web-based tech and left clues in the UX that gives away the fact that you might be loading some external code, the reviewer may catch it and reject.
- mcny 6y ago> Is that against Apple's store terms? Because that's a common feature of ReactNative based app, you can update them by deploying new JS files without having to pass by the a new app store release. I think the point of contention is not that people can add new content without a full app store review. Any app that can access the Internet can do that[see rant below]. The point of contention is whether a direct payment option violates Apple guidelines. Personally, I think adding a payment option should not violate guidelines. What should violate guidelines is if they do NOT offer Apple pay at a rate at or below their lowest price elsewhere. Yes, Apple gets a cut of the proceeds if the user chooses to use Apple pay. No, it should not against the law as long as Apple allows the user to pay using alternate means within the app. No, the app publisher (Epic) may not 1. NOT offer Apple Pay (sorry for double negative) 2. Discourage users from using Apple Pay (rewarding people for using other payment options by means such as offering lower prices elsewhere, exclusive content, etc) 3. Make it difficult to use Apple Pay (by increasing friction as opposed to other means within the app, I'm a bit torn on this one). I think all of these points are fair. The only thing I think Apple should allow is let people add payment method other than Apple Pay. [rant] Unrelated rant: No third-party app (not published by Apple) should have access to the Internet by default. An app should prompt the user for the ability to access the Internet.
- jamil7 6y agoI've never made any real money from my apps so I can't comment too much but something similar was discussed on ATP podcast fairly recently, I think this approach would go a really long way to solving 90% of iOS developers current frustrations with the appstore.
- gamblor956 6y agoRequiring companies to use Apple Pay elsewhere as a condition of being in the app store is literally a textbook case of antitrust.
- JamesSwift 6y agoYes its against terms, but in practice almost every app developer I've known has used some sort of dynamic code distribution, regardless of runtime.