3 ms·
We agree that the Nazi plan was intended only to benefit (a subset of) themselves. We also agree that Nazis intended to treat slavs as prior empires had treate
by 082349872349872 6y ago
We agree that the Nazi plan was intended only to benefit (a subset of) themselves.
We also agree that Nazis intended to treat slavs as prior empires had treated their Worthy Oriental Gentlemen (wogs, in the vernacular).
I'd like to make the distinction on the first point that they marketed[1] their intentions differently. I should have said "sold" instead of "viewed", sorry. And my "benevolently" had not been meant to be taken in a positive light. (If someone tells you they are benevolent, keep a hand on your wallet.)
To me it is clear that Goebbels said that the Nazis must protect 2'000 years of Western Civilisation from the Communists (who, you correctly note, were severely conflated with jews in that speech), and that not only was everyone who was not For Them implicitly Against Them, but that it didn't matter anyway, because they were totes going to protect even countries whose governments/intellectuals didn't wish such protection[2].
Would it help if I translate the parts I left in german into english? (I hadn't because I think the original translation pretty much got it right, but will try if you'd like fresh phrasing.)
As to sheep, dogs, and pigs, they're from Animal Farm[3], repurposed to fit one of PG's recent essays[4]:
Concrete groups:
pigs - animals who seizing power for animals from humans.
(aggressive unconventionals / Nazi leadership)
Somehow the benefits from this change of power don't extend much beyond pigs. At the end of the book, the pigs and the neighbouring human farmers get along just fine.
dogs - herd sheep on behalf of pigs.
(aggressive conventionals / blackshirts, SS)
Compare recent US police use of the "sheepdog metaphor", which I believe dates back at least to the conflict in Korea. Dogs get the pigs' table scraps, so they think themselves better than the sheep, who don't.
sheep - those who happily repeat all the domestic propaganda produced by the pigs
(passive conventionals / NSDAP rank and file, general populace)
The existence of many potential leaders with authoritarian tendencies is not necessarily a social problem. The existence of many followers with authoritarian tendencies, is.
Does the distinction between how the plan was intended by the leaders and how it was sold to the followers make more sense now?
[1] I doubt the Sportpalastrede was intended to be external propaganda: it was domestic propaganda to motivate "Total War". So maybe ordinary NSDAP members (the sheep) really bought into a "They are sick, and We are the cure" line even though the Nazi leadership (the pigs) and the SS (the dogs) knew it was, finally, all about whose knee was to be on whose neck.
Compare https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vGAqYNFQdZ4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vGAqYNFQdZ4
Or the Sith Rule of Two.
[2] "Gee, nice country you've got here. Wouldn't want anything to happen to it." is the stereotypical anglophone expression of a https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Protection_racket https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Protection_racket
[3] a book taught in the anglophone world as having been about Stalin, but it also maps to other targets. Considering that was written by an anglophone author for an anglophone audience, we should not be too surprised when we can find many parallels in the anglophone experience. (Goldstein's book in 1984 goes so far as to claim that Animal Farm is how things always work. For as much as I've read of Durant's Story of Civilization, Goldstein seems to be correct.)
[4] http://paulgraham.com/conformism.html http://paulgraham.com/conformism.html
mapped to Animal Farm in: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23975900 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23975900
- watwut 6y ago> Goebbels said that the Nazis must protect 2'000 years of Western Civilisation from the Communists See, from all I read about Nazism, whatever short quote in one propaganda speech was, Nazism was not concerned with Western Civilisation at all. As far as Nazism was concerned, there was German civilization. Not western, German. French are something different. British are something different. Americans are something different. The western civilization concern is contemporary white supremacist concern. > they were totes going to protect even countries whose governments/intellectuals didn't wish such protection They were to conquer rest of west. That was appeal of Nazism. > The existence of many potential leaders with authoritarian tendencies is not necessarily a social problem. The existence of many followers with authoritarian tendencies, is. Meh. That argument takes responsibility away from those in power, away from those who seek power and places it on ambiguous faceless mass. It also ignores social systems those people operated in. It also ignores actual motivations for why people supported or did not supported movements. Paul Graham is not exactly historian nor sociologist. Forcing his theories on history wont make you understand what happened - it will make you reject actual history and replace it by own imagination. You will come in with preconceived idea about who is who psychologically based on which group is sympathetic in hindsight, from the point of view of our values. Paul Graham also makes up child psychology, but that does not matter much.
- 082349872349872 6y agoI'll happily stipulate we can leave PG to the side :-) (just hope you don't mind if I make small attempts at making HN a little more of a garden and a little less of a stream: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23337759 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23337759 ) If you could point me to other speeches laying out the Nazi domestic story differently, I'd appreciate it. I picked the Sportpalastrede because (a) it was what we'd read in school, (b) it comes at a critical point, after Rokossovsky had cut off the Nazis from middle eastern oil, and just before the Nazis go explicitly totalitarian, and (c) even though they'd basically lost momentum, the Nazis would go on to be even more cruel to even more people for a few years more. I don't believe that Max Mustermann would have given the consent of the governed[1] in 1933 for "we're going to conquer everyone and kill millions of undesirables", but "we're going to support our traditions, defend the church, and create a brilliant future for our children", despite being a different end approached by the same means, was probably a much easier sale. "...going to protect even countries whose governments/intellectuals didn't wish such protection." was intended to be read exactly as "conquer rest of west". Sorry, often I fail to realise most people are not as cynical as I. So, moving on to where I believe we differ: > "takes responsibility away from those in power, away from those who seek power and places it on ambiguous faceless mass" is exactly the point I'm arguing. I would say the implosion of the USSR is encouraging, because it shows us that people not in power can change the behaviour of those in power, when they are willing to say together, "you know, this system, it doesn't actually promote the ideals we were all taught to believe in." (Yes, it likely helped immensely that Gorbi himself also seems to have believed in his childhood picture of what socialism was supposed to have been. Also, in the case of both of us[2], we belong to this mass despite being neither ambiguous nor faceless.) I think asking people in power (especially people who sought power for its own sake) to be responsible is to ignore those thousands of years of history Goebbels claimed to be preserving. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23846415 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23846415 Can you suggest a better method for avoiding self-interested leaders than the hypnopaedic suggestions of Brave New World or the arbitrariness of sortition? (Go back a few hundred years, and one can find plenty of people willing to argue that monarchy is superior to democracy, as the identification of the monarch with the state means that the monarch is more likely to act with long term interests in mind. Related: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23184621 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23184621 ) Anyway, where we seem to differ is where best to address the problem of potential totalitarianism: with the many, or with the few? I believe it very difficult with the former, and impossible[3] with the latter. How do you see it? [1] compare Linebarger's Psychological Warfare, in the context of hot war, not peaceful political process: "the defeated people may lose their sense of organization, fail to decide on leaders and methods, and give up because they can no longer fight as a group. This happened to the American Southerners in April, 1865. The President and Cabinet of the Confederate States of America got on the train at Richmond; the men who got off farther down the line were "refugees." Something happened to them and to the people about them, so that Mr. Davis no longer thought of himself as President Davis, and other people no longer accepted his commands. This almost happened in Germany in 1945 except for Admiral Doenitz." https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23859546 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23859546 [2] Going by the odds, it is reasonable to bet that you are also not in power, please correct me if I'm mistaken. [3] Even Plato thinks that to address it among the latter, they can't be allowed family or property, or even private meals. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24069572 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24069572