4 ms·
A quasi-fix could be to control for the most obvious sources of vitamin D: how often do you go outside, how long do you go outside, do you take vitamin D supple
by wjnc 6y ago
A quasi-fix could be to control for the most obvious sources of vitamin D: how often do you go outside, how long do you go outside, do you take vitamin D supplements, how often and with which strength. You can do this kind of analysis alongside any type of study, don't need full coverage and get some preliminary results. All you need is a Bayesian on your team (: partially in jest) or the willingness to open up your data after you publish.
In my opinion as someone who practices non-medical statistics the trope of correlation vs. causation and interventional vs. observational are somewhat overblown. Andrew Gelman posted somewhat snarky about MDs and statistics recently [1]. I see that this post is in (very) good faith, but it does have the MD-bias to statistics in it.
[1] https://statmodeling.stat.columbia.edu/2020/08/11/that-not-a-real-doctor-thing-its-kind-of-silly-for-people-to-think-that-going-to-medical-school-for-a-few-years-will-give-you-the-skills-necessary-to-be-able-to-evaluate-research-claims-in/ https://statmodeling.stat.columbia.edu/2020/08/11/that-not-a...
- devaboone 6y agoI'm the one who wrote the blog, and really appreciate your comment. As a physician, I can confirm that most physicians have only the tiniest grasp on statistics - and most will not have even heard about Bayesian stats. I do not want to imply that observational studies of correlation are useless - or even that observational studies are "less valid" than randomized controlled trials (something that doctors usually assume, but it incorrect). I actually want to write about this issue in future posts. There is a lot I want to cover, and stats in medicine is one of my favorite topics. One blog at a time, though.
- wjnc 6y agoI'm looking forward to future posts as well! Thanks for writing this. You gave me pause to reconsider the only supplement I give my children and perhaps even more so in future episodes.