> an enclosed space like a carriage, you have no escape route You make it sound like she was cornered and in mortal danger. The carriage was crowded with peopl

> an enclosed space like a carriage, you have no escape route You make it sound like she was cornered and in mortal danger. The carriage was crowded with people. Yes, he was (likely) a creepy dirtbag who deserved to be punished. STABBING SOMEONE WITH A FOOT OF SHARP STEEL IS NOT "MELLOW"! It's nuclear. You either have a frightfully diminished understanding of the potential lethality of stabbing someone, or you have a psychotically draconian image of justice.