4 ms·
I'll be as charitable as I can here, but the fact that you're even willing to call an idea "dangerous" tells me that you didn't quite understand Mill. Position
by anigbrowl 6y ago
I'll be as charitable as I can here, but the fact that you're even willing to call an idea "dangerous" tells me that you didn't quite understand Mill.
Positioning myself as an implicit authority, the fact that you're willing to write something I can subtly misrepresent allows me to switch rhetorical tracks and 'explain' a rudimentary concept in order to gain the appearance of superior cleverness.
- dvt 6y agoYour unnecessary mental masturbation aside, Mill would never call an idea (or speech, to be precise) “dangerous” — ever under the most lax of definitions. I’d invite any evidence to the contrary.
- anigbrowl 6y agoYour red herring is stale and unappetizing. The statement you took issue with was I think Mill either ignored or did not anticipate just how dangerous a viral bad idea can be on a global scale. Nobody argued that Mill held ideas to be dangerous; if anything, that is being suggested as a shortcoming of Mill's philosophy. There is no good reason to solicit evidence for a proposition which nobody was making to begin with.