3 ms·
>As Juvenal asked almost two millenia ago: Quis custodiet ipsos custodes? Part of the last 2000 years has been the attempt to development systems of government
by PaulDavisThe1st 6y ago
>As Juvenal asked almost two millenia ago: Quis custodiet ipsos custodes?
Part of the last 2000 years has been the attempt to development systems of government which inherently reduce the importance of this question. For example, by enforcing churn on "custodes", by creating a culture in which radical transparency is the norm, by encouraging highly participatory democracy.
Now, I will concede that these efforts have not born much fruit. Certainly not enough fruit to make Juvenal's question moot. But we are now in a situation where we may be faced with "draconian authoritarianism" because of the social and psychological impact of social media and its manipulation, so I'm not convinced that this "free speech vs. draconian authoritarianism" dialectic is really useful in an analysis of this issue.
Asserting that there are only two ends of the spectrum: free speech or draconian authoritarianism is very typical American thing to do; other cultures have a much easier time dealing with the idea that while the slope may be slippery, we can choose to take some steps down it and then stop.
(I'm not saying that I know you're American, merely that this sort of perspective is much more typical in the political and civic culture of America than most other countries in the world).
And frankly, I don't think your arguments are sound, because they hinge on a hand-waving claim:
>Disinformation -- to the detriment of the public -- is a price we're willing to pay (barring some narrow cases)
You (and I, and the rest of us) don't know what that price really means.
- PaulDavisThe1st 6y agoand to whoever decided to downvote this, how about you step up and explain what you think is wrong with it, rather than just hiding behind the downarrow?
- acephal 6y ago>Part of the last 2000 years has been the attempt to development systems of government which inherently reduce the importance of this question. For example, by enforcing churn on "custodes", by creating a culture in which radical transparency is the norm, by encouraging highly participatory democracy. Majority of the last two thousand years in Western Europe was inept Roman dictatorship followed by Germanic warlords duking it out. More like the last 500 years, no? Saying 2000 years lends an air of credibility that shouldn't be there, though you may just be going for word play in response to the grandparent